StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Revisiting the role of miscue analysis in effective teaching - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
Goodman and his contemporaries were in the 1960’S interested in development taking place while reading and thought that miscues (any…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Revisiting the role of miscue analysis in effective teaching
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Revisiting the role of miscue analysis in effective teaching"

Education: Revisiting the role of miscue analysis in effective teaching Analysis of reading Miscue is a main whole language test intended to evaluate the strategies used by children while reading or studying. Goodman and his contemporaries were in the 1960’S interested in development taking place while reading and thought that miscues (any deviation from the content by the reader) would portray a symptom of any fundamental cognitive processes. Goodman used the phrase miscue instead of error or mistake, reflecting the observation that a deviation from the reading manuscript is not essentially erroneous (Goodman, 1979).

The miscues observed in readers includes omissions, alterations, and additions to the sequence of words and replacements of the printed word with another. Goodman initially came up with a Taxonomy which featured 28 various kinds of miscues (Goodman, 1969). Developed originally for research reasons, its unwieldiness plus a need to enlarge its utilization inspired Carolyn Burke, Yetta Goodman in 1972 to establish a smaller edition made up of 9 questions to be queried about every miscue-which was a straightforward system that they reasoned would become a more manageable and helpful tool especially for teachers and clinics in the school system.

Thus the authors were not so much interested in conventional quantitative measures like reading rate or reading accuracy and figured out that their qualitative method gave more fine-grained and appropriate information as compared to other methods of reading assessment. This therefore implies that using Reading Miscue Inventory (RMI)a learner’s incorrect answer ,in comparison to the printed word, may portray a variation in dialect, a shift in intonation, sound similarity, graphic similarity, syntactic acceptability, grammatical similarity, semantic acceptability, self-correction having semantic acceptability and meaning change.

It is clear that McKenna and her colleagues do not understand much about the analysis of miscue. Analysis of miscue continues to be accepted by teachers since it assists them comprehend how their students make sense of the written word. It is widely used in programs for educating teachers as a way of making teachers revalue the process of reading. Miscue also continues to be utilized in research since it gives a depth profile of the process of reading in use. There is no single publication of critique analysis which has proved its invalidity.

McKenna and Picard and her colleagues only cite one unfunded study carried out by Goodman over 4 decades ago, which was at the very start of examination of oral reading miscues (Goodman, 1965).This very first study actually was in support of what teachers have all along been knowing: that even first graders are able to read several of the words in context that they are not able to read out of context. McKenna and colleagues claims that other scholars have been able to prove that Goodman’s conclusion concerning the study about significance of reading in context was wrong.

Its funny how anybody interested in reading would make an argument that words are identifiable easily out of context as while in context. It’s only in real print does any word have a meaning that is definable and several can’t be pronounced reliably out of context. The two authors are also wrong in believing that every miscue is assigned to one cuing system. Thus in analysis of miscue, each miscue is analyzed on a number of diverse variables. They make an invention of a pony/horse alternative miscue example in their article.

They are not able to give a context which means that an individual cannot illustrate how the miscue would be analyzed fully. However miscues differ in type: omission, substitution, complex, reversal or insertion .For instance a complex miscue may involve shifting in numerous words in the observed or expected response, however in their illustration, pony is replaced with a horse. Miscue analysis is usually qualitative though it can also be quantitive. Miscues are not just counted; their qualities are also examined.

Thus analysis of miscue could be qualitative but can also be quantitive. Miscues are not just counted their qualities are also examined. This is one reason why analysis of miscue usually gives a wealthy description of the given reading.ReferencesGoodman, K. (1965). A mLinguistic study of cues and miscues in reading Elementary English,42,639-643. New York: Hamppton Press.Goodman, K. (1969). Analysis of oral reading miscues:Applied psycholinguistics. Reading Research Quarterly , 5,9-30.Goodman, K. (1979). Reading:PsycholinguisticGuessing game.

Theoretical models and proceses of reading , 259-2171.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Revisiting the role of miscue analysis in effective teaching Article”, n.d.)
Revisiting the role of miscue analysis in effective teaching Article. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1648197-revisiting-the-role-of-miscue-analysis-in-effective-teaching
(Revisiting the Role of Miscue Analysis in Effective Teaching Article)
Revisiting the Role of Miscue Analysis in Effective Teaching Article. https://studentshare.org/education/1648197-revisiting-the-role-of-miscue-analysis-in-effective-teaching.
“Revisiting the Role of Miscue Analysis in Effective Teaching Article”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1648197-revisiting-the-role-of-miscue-analysis-in-effective-teaching.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Revisiting the role of miscue analysis in effective teaching

New Zealand Tourism - Target Market Segments

Thus effective marketing strategy is very essential to communicate with people over the globe that the country is ready for business.... With time better relationship of the country with the global market and effective communication system will increase the number of stakeholders if the marketing communication strategy can be effectively developed and marketed.... For this purpose the project makes an analysis of the stakeholders and the market segments in the region....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Difference in Cultural or Ethnic Background between the Teacher and the Students

This objective involved the role of questioning in socialization and language.... This provided the right criteria for effective schooling ethnography.... Philosophy Inquiry Study Review Name Institution Course Date Part a Goals The author bases the study on the problem experienced by most teachers, whereby there usually exists a difference in cultural or ethnic background between the teacher and some or all of the students in the classroom....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Plan for Addressing a Key Employee Behavior

Coaching Plan for Addressing a Key Employee Behaviour Introduction Most employees particularly the managers fail to realize the reasons behind their employees' underperformance and think that they can resolve the issue by firing such employees.... However, the cost of substituting human resource ends up being high thus, managers are advised to adopt other options such as coaching to locate the actual problem and solve it....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Paths out of homelessness in chicago

hellip; This paper entails the internal and external sources that have played vital role in causing people to be part of the homeless fraternity, followed by a SWOT analysis of this agenda.... Chicago's environment Internal Causes Internal Effects External Causes External Effects Severe levels of addiction to alcohol and drugs Affected mental stability and health of the homeless Fall in individuals' income levels and unemployment in Chicago Homelessness consumes national funding and increases residents' taxes Social and sexual abuse for children and lack of parental guidance Behavioral problems especially in children Adverse local housing market conditions making it unaffordable for Chicago masses Homeless people engage in criminal activities thereby harming others Family frictions eventually causing parents to turn children out of home Loss of community connectedness and social life Racial, status, social and other demographic differences between Chicago residents Cleanliness cannot be ensured causing health and hygiene related issues in Chicago (Fertig and Reingold, 2007) SWOT analysis Strengths: Availability of surplus community resources adequate to cater the homeless in Chicago; presence of performance management systems with authorities of the Chicago government to collect information about homeless, measure statistics and prioritize people in order of need for aid; and strong relations and ties with outside countries and other American states shall enable it to bring in foreign aid support for the homeless in crucial times of need....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Proposal

Piagets Theory and Good Discipline between the Team

teaching staff should encourage the students to involve in discussions.... The integration of skills needed to live should be incorporated into the curriculum, textbooks, instructional materials, and teaching-learning and evaluation processes.... n order to make special educational relevant, effective, meaningful, and worthy we shall give priority to the following research approach: Policy Research in EducationMatters relating to policy concerns should be developed Policy issues should be dealt with high effectivenessPolicy issue findings should be disseminated Case Studies Good discipline between the team, good collaboration, and multi-centered....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Analysis of a Health Care

The paper will concentrate on the analysis of where the present system contributes or lacks contribution into the use of its resources, as well as the role of the system in transitioning patients from one care level to another in the healthcare continuum. … Medicare is the health delivery system for elderly people.... 23)Thus, the main contribution and role of Medicare in the state healthcare delivery system was in making its main stress on chronic diseases, moving away from the hospitals being the center of any healthcare delivery system....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

A critique of published research By Anthony Feiler

The quality of the learning environment as well as the role played by the parents in the learning activity of students has great significance in the learning skills of children and the research investigation by Feiler focuses on the family literacy schemes, especially the strategy occupying the parents as well as children.... In this critique, an analysis of the paper ‘A home visiting project for reception children predicted to experience The result of the analysis is decisive in a complete comprehension of the article as well as its strengths and weaknesses....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Business Process Management

Business management process is currently effective due to the advancement in technological environment.... Business process management is a systematic action seized by a business with the aim of evaluating, identifying, and improving the processes in business arena.... Further,… For instance, an application build on business management processes is capable to monitor the systems that receive for any missing items (Riley 45)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us