StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Public Law, the Parliament in the United Kingdom - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Public Law, the Parliament in the United Kingdom" states that interpretation for compliance may be in conflict with the intent of the legislation. This is considered a last resort measure with an array of superior courts having the ability to issue such a declaration of incompatibility…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
Public Law, the Parliament in the United Kingdom
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Public Law, the Parliament in the United Kingdom"

The declaration does not bind the parties nor can it lead to the invalidation of legislation (Clements, 2008: p21). Therefore, section 4 attains its aims via political and not legal means through section 10 which allows the government to undertake amendment of legislation sans full approval of the legislature. In this case, a remedial order can be made only following a declaration of compatibility or similar European court findings with every appeal being completed or renounced expressly. Section 4 will allow a declaration of incompatibility by the court if, by chance, it is satisfied that its provisions do not match well with the convention of the rights (Clements, 2008: p21). Section 3 makes a requirement that courts should interpret the legislation as being compatible with the convention of rights when and where possible.

While the declaration of incompatibility is a last resort measure, there are cases where the court’s interpretation may assume administrative powers that, ordinarily, it would not possess with consequences that the court is not best placed to make a consideration (Barnett, 2009: p61). This meaning departs significantly from an Act of Parliament’s fundamental feature that it is likely to have broken the boundary between amendment and interpretation. The statute’s thrust is essential, especially since going against this thrust needs legislative power that courts of law do not possess. In the case of A v. Ministry of Justice, a declaration of incompatibility following the 4th Section is the appropriate remedy.

The power of a judge to issue a declaration of incompatibility can allow a judge to avoid becoming involved in issues of sensitive public interest (Mwalimu, 2010: p13). Declarations of incompatibility are optional and, in this case, the court needs to choose whether to use it or not according to their discretion. The judge can use the declaration of incompatibility if a point has been identified, as well as fully argued, at a hearing that was appointed for the purpose. The judge can also choose not to use the declaration of incompatibility unless it becomes appropriate for the incompatibility to be formally recorded via a declaration.

Finally, the judges can also issue a declaration that serves a legislative purpose. It should also provide for a basis, for a crown minister, to consider whether compelling reasons exist to amend the legislation (Mwalimu, 2010: p14). In the case of A v. Justice Ministry, the judge may also find it unnecessary to give a declaration of incompatibility since the Secretary of State had already accepted the domestic law as being incompatible with the convention of rights. In this case, making another declaration of incompatibility would exert unnecessary pressure to amend legislation in the parliament.
The power to make a declaration of incompatibility about human rights is only likely to be available to judges of the High Court. Judges must ensure that any declaration does not make any difference to the case at hand as the High Court will still have to use the legislation (Elliott & Thomas, 2011: p72).

The declaration of incompatibility must also not make difference to any cases, which will occur in the future since the legislation will have to remain valid. Finally, the judge needs to ensure that the declaration of incompatibility does not compel parliament to alter legislation in any manner. However, the judge using restraint should not be seen as the fear that the parliament may cave into a declaration of incompatibility by the High Court and change legislation. Parliament will be unlikely to respond to interpretations by the judiciary, which it may believe to be untenable or politically unpopular such as to jeopardize the government that is in power (Elliott & Thomas, 2011: p72).

The parliament in the United Kingdom has always heeded all judicial declarations since the passing of the United Kingdom Human Rights Act in 1998. However, while it is not bound to any declaration of incompatibility, any failure to do so would be cause for a case to the European Court of Human Rights (Elliott & Thomas, 2011: p73). This is especially so because the United Kingdom is bound, legally, to follow similar decisions by this court. Judges should ensure that they use the declaration of incompatibility to check any overt involvement in sensitive public interest issues. This is because they should be careful not to push the parliament into a corner to be compliant with their rulings. In addition, most laws only need minor tweaking intending to make them compliant with the Human Rights Act. By using, a declaration of incompatibility, the judges, may serve the purpose of showing minor deficiencies that the legislature can address happily. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Public Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 1”, n.d.)
Public Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1473021-public-law
(Public Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1)
Public Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/law/1473021-public-law.
“Public Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1473021-public-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Public Law, the Parliament in the United Kingdom

The Royal Prerogative Is a Feature of the UK Constitution

The people of the united kingdom need to realize that times have changed, and circumstances are different.... For the united kingdom to fully deliberate itself from the shackles of history, the royalty's expansive powers should be fully relegated to parliament and only act as a ceremonial organ2.... n the past, the exercise of such powers has failed to reflect the wishes of the larger interest of the people of the united kingdom, rather has been used as a tool for the monarchy to meet its ends3....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

UK Membership in the European Union

The paper "UK Membership in the European Union" focuses on such factors as the EC Act 1972 and the united kingdom's decision to align with the European Union, which had a detrimental effect on the influence of the British Parliament on the governance of the country.... So, this paper will focus on the 'Mother of Parliaments', the united kingdom Parliament, and will analyze its supremacy and importantly the issues that have crept in, to challenge that supremacy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Law of the Costitution

Despite the absence of a written Constitution in the united kingdom, this principle has established the supremacy of Parliament in the legislative.... Dicey set out the ental principles of Britain's unwritten Constitution, and the role of judges within the context of those principles by stating that the indivisibility of Parliamentary power requires that all exercise of Governmental power must be authorized by parliament, since it is the source of all valid authority....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Have Recent Reforms Increased Parliaments Ability to Hold the Executive to Account

runs like a thread throughout the constitution of the united Kingdom5.... Accordingly, the preservation of separation of powers is essential as a check on autocratic power further symbolized in the UK by the role of parliament as a check on the executive.... Additionally, the judiciary obtains their power from the Crown and there is a distinct overlap of functions between the powers, which should be separated for the effective application of the separation of powers and the efficacy of parliament as a check on the executive8....
9 Pages (2250 words) Article

Politics and Parliament in Britain

Simply put, parliament is the only sovereign body in the united kingdom, which is not bound by any law.... The author of the paper outlines that the statement 'Parliament is the Supreme law of the land', simply serves to indicate that no law or an act of parliament that is established by the Parliament of the united kingdom can be regarded as unconstitutional.... The paper will indicate that the united kingdom parliament remains the supreme law of the land since it can change the existing laws that are being applied currently, while also introducing new laws that it deems necessary for the running of Britain....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

People and Parliament in the United Kingdom

In the paper 'People and parliament in the united kingdom' the author focuses on the parliament of the United Kingdom, which is the highest legislative authority and it is responsible for checking the work of the government.... The author states that the Parliament of the United Kingdom is the supreme legislative organ in the united kingdom, British overseas territories as well as the British Crown dependencies.... The parliament is headed by the Sovereign of the united kingdom that is currently occupied by Queen Elizabeth II....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

The Structure of the United Kingdom Constitution

The paper 'The Structure of the united kingdom Constitution' presents entrenchment, according to Fred Ridley which is one of the essential characteristics of a Constitution, along with other factors such as the constitutive origin of government, creation of constituent power, and superiority.... A strict application of Ridley's definition necessarily precludes Charters that are not entrenched – just like the united kingdom Constitution.... An example of an entrenched Constitution is the Bill of Rights of the united States, many provisions of which were adopted more than 200 years ago by an elite group of white male slave owners....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Constitutional and Administrative Law

They further held that the standard position was indefinite in the united kingdom.... The case was brought to the courts by Jackson and other members of a country club opposing the parliament Acts that enabled them to ratify the Hunting Act of 2004.... he Parliament amended the 1911 Act with the parliament Act of 1949, which the claimants stated was not appropriate.... The claim was rejected by the court of Appeal and the lower courts; however, the Court of Appeal believed that the parliament Acts process could not be used to make any substantial changes in the constitution....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us