StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
I will discuss and explore the question has The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 transformed the relationship between the Executive and the Legislature I will take a further look at the major principles including the Principle of the Separation of Powers, powers of the state and the work of government…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
Constitutional Reform Act of 2005
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Constitutional Reform Act of 2005"

In this assignment I draw on Parpworth, Bradley & Ewing and Allen &Thompson thoughts and ideas to discuss and explore The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005.I will discuss and explore the question has The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 transformed the relationship between the Executive and the Legislature I will take a further look at the major principles including the Principle of the Separation of Powers, powers of the state and the work of government. In doing so I propose that the Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 has indeed transformed the relationship between the Executive and the Legislature.

The answer is not straight forward although perhaps the most significant change is the role of authority between the Executive and the Legislature. I will discuss the changes in more detail during this assignment.The current British law makes it a requirement that every citizen should be under the same law and that the law seeks to act fairly by not punishing individuals who are innocent of crime. It is essential that the law has certainty and that all actions are regulated accordingly. The British legal system seeks to achieve these requirements and usually achieves this.

However there are circumstances when these requirements have been a concern. The government previously had power over legislation and could reverse legislation, but with 'The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 it no longer has that authority. (Bradley & Ewing, 2008)Since it is essential that no individual should be more powerful than the law The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 was created to form a distinct and unbiased judiciary. To completely understand the relationship between the Executive and the Legislature one has to examine the duties of the judiciary.

(Parpworth N, 2008). As Parpworth points out the major role of Parliament is to make legislation and to make sure that the duties of the executive are followed through correctly. The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 changed the way Parliament worked. It changed the roles between the Executive, the Legislative and the Judiciary. The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 brings changes such as; the creation of a supreme court, separate from Parliament, in the final court of appeal the judges will no longer be members of the House of Lords.

The Lord Chief Justice will now be the head of the judiciary rather than the Lord Chancellor. Although this Act has come under much scrutiny it follows the principle of the separation of powers and recognises the role of the judiciary as a third branch of the constitution. The shift in powers was divided more equally between the three branches; the executive, the legislature and the judiciary. In the past the British Lord Chancellor was part of the legislative and there was no separation of powers.

There are three different meanings to describe Separation of power.1. That no one person should form one of the three branches.2. That each branch should be distinct and not have the power to get involved with another's duties, and3. That these branches shouldn't be allowed to take authority of the other branches. (Bradley & Ewing, 2008)It was Montesquieu that introduced the principle of separation of powers in the 17th century. He believed that there should be three separate branches involved with the decision and law making process.

Montesquieu argued that to avoid tyranny the Executive, Legislature and Judiciary should be separated.(Barnett, 2001) Since The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 the separation of power has been more distinct. The relationship between the Executive and the Legislature was transformed by this new constitution in a way that would separate its powers and reflect today's societal changes better.Since 2002, the Council has played a significant factor in providing a judiciary to debate and find solutions of policy, involving an important role in respect of forming the Concordat.

Its working parties have contributed to the relations with the Executive.The principle of legislative supremacy is a firmly rooted fact of British government and British political thought. The main principles of the separation of powers were never forgotten and were a firm part of British political thinking. It was important that these principles were interjected into constitutional theory. This would bring about a much more balanced constitution. Originally judges were not as significant as they are today.

Therefore the Constitutional Reform Act was essential to give judges a distinct place and also to bring about a new way of political thought. The Constitutional Reform Act matched the new political thought and closely balanced the fundamental principles of the separation of powers. It would solve any altercations between authority creating three distinct branches that were balanced more equally. The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 was brought about so that British citizens could have confidence in the government knowing that they could not change the legislative at any given moment.

The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 would improve credibility and effectiveness of public institutions. It would improve the strength of our democracy and public engagement with decision making. It would improve trust and accountability in public bodies. (Allen, M & Thompson, 2008)The transformations since The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 have helped strengthen the partnership between the executive and the judiciary. Some changes have happened to reflect the society that we live in and to show what a diverse world we are currently living in.

Power is shifting more fairly between the executive and the legislature helping to reduce areas of conflict. Not only does the Act bring solution to conflict it also improves the administration of justice, the up keeping of the rule of law and the safe guarding of the public interest. The main transformation that The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 brings about is the change in Parliamentary Sovereignty.In conclusion, The Constitutional Reform Act 2005 has transformed the relationship between the Executive and the Legislature' in many ways.

There are not enough words to discuss every aspect of transformation that the Act has brought about, but there is a lot of scope to discuss this further and to go into more depth.1016 wordsReferencesAllen &Thompson ( 2008). Cases and Materials on Constitutional and Administrative Law 9th ed. London: OUP Oxford. 800Barnett, H. (2001) Constitutional & Administrative Law 3rd ed. London: Cavendish Publishing.Bradley & Ewing ( 2008). Constitutional and Administrative Law . 14th ed. London: Pearson Longman . 872. Neil Parpworth (2008).

Constitutional and Administrative Law 5th ed. London: Oxford. 632 .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1500566-constitutional-reform-act-of-2005
(Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1500566-constitutional-reform-act-of-2005.
“Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1500566-constitutional-reform-act-of-2005.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Constitutional Reform Act of 2005

Rule of Law within the United Kingdom Constitution

The Anti-Terrorism act was passed by the Parliament of the UK in November of 2001, a mere two months after the historic 9-11 attacks.... nbsp;… Though the act has been seen as controversial at its inception, it cannot be denied that the reforms it has introduced bode well for a more stable and more responsive legal system....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Law of the Costitution

Despite the absence of a written Constitution in the United Kingdom, this principle has established the supremacy of Parliament in the legislative… But in recent times, especially with the incorporation of European law into the framework of English law through the Human Rights act of 1998, the inviolability of Parliamentary Sovereignty is increasingly being questioned. Oxford Professor A....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

English Legal System

Since 1991, solicitors with a little extra qualification have been allowed to act as advocates before the highest courts.... They are Barristers, Solicitors, Legal Executives and Licensed Conveyancers.... The largest categories are the Barristers and Solicitors.... Legal Executives and Licensed Conveyancers are… Barristers deal with the advocacy or representation of clients before the courts and with the high level consultancy on Solicitors were more concerned with office work such as the preparation of contracts for clients....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Constitutional Reform Act of 2005

Furthermore, it is important to explain that the Supreme Court was enacted after the passage of the Constitutional Reform Act of 2005.... This court was created under part three of the constitutional reform act.... The constitutional reform act played a great role in reforming the judiciary, and specifically the three roles of the Lord Chancellor.... The intention of the constitutional reforms that were undertaken by the British government was on the expansion of the British judicial system and courts, for over the last thirty years....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005

The paper "The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005" discusses that the move towards the establishment of an independent and separate judiciary appears to be a certain future development as individual rights and European Law gain precedence within the UK judicial system.... In view of recent European legislation such as the European Convention of Human Rights8, the conflict arising between the judicial body as the arm of Government to enforce the mandates of Parliament vis a vis its role as the avenue of justice for individual rights is in the process of being addressed through the Constitutional Reform Act of 2005....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Doctrine of Sovereignty and Jackson

Moreover, once an act is passed, a judicial reference to the Law Commission's Report on the Interpretation of Statues10 in order to determine the true construction of a statute is contravened on the basis that it is of doubtful benefit and a costly exercise11.... The author of the "Doctrine of Sovereignty and Jackson" paper analyzes the case of Jackson that is significant in that the notion of Parliamentary Sovereignty is being challenged....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Analysis of Administrative and Constitutional Law Cases

The proposed active encouragement by Government of discrimination as well as martial law, etc will constitute further infringements of individual liberties, which may be opposed by the judiciary The need to preserve individual rights are also recognized and addressed in the Constitutional Reform Act of 2005, which aims to strengthen democracy and enhance the credibility of public institutions.... The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 is a response to the growing imbalance in the power of the executive, which is taking on quasi-judicial functions....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

UK Legal System: Judicial Appointments Commision

The coursework titled "UK Legal System: Judicial Appointments Commision" is aimed at reflecting the fact that the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) for England and Wales, launched April 3, 2006, is a statutory fulfillment of vital legal restructurings embodied in the Constitutional Reform Act of 2005.... Section 61, Chapter 1 of Part 4, which also established a Supreme Court in the United Kingdom and abolished the appellate jurisdiction of the House of Lords, endowed the JAC with three functions: to base appointments on merit alone; to consider candidates who are of good moral character, and; to “encourage diversity” among applicants (CRA 2005)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us