StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Human Rights - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper examines some practical aspects of human rights and the dominant trends in a given country. The research focuses on the human rights records and structures of Iran, a country in the Persian-Gulf region of the Middle East with a dominant Islamic population. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Human Rights
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Human Rights"

Introduction This paper examines some practical aspects of human rights and the dominant trends in a given country. The research focuses on the human rights records and structures of Iran, a country in the Persian-Gulf region of the Middle East with a dominant Islamic population. Iran has been cited for maintaining a poor human rights record over the past three decades. This paper examines the nature and degree of human rights violations in Iran. To this end, the writer of the paper conducted independent research on the reports of the human rights records of the Islamic Republic under study. The paper documents some popular events in human rights violations that outline trends in its national development of Iran over the past decade. The final part of the paper will focus on the legal and ethical basis for the human rights violations in Iran. It will outline the main reasons why the human rights violations continue to thrive in Iran. In attaining this objective, the research will examine the role of the Islamic elite that are ruling the country and how they maintain the systems that allow human rights violations to continue. Secondly, the study will examine the reasons why the international community cannot do much about the human rights situation in Iran. This will discuss several issues including the nuclear enrichment situation and its effects on the quest to demand better trends in Irans human rights situation. Irans Human Rights Reports The 2009 Amnesty International Report of Iran shows a bleak picture of an Islamic State that has extremely serious human rights records. There are signs of very serious and destructive violations that affect individuals and minority groups in so many ways. The report showed that there is severe unrest amongst Irans minority groups: Azerbaijani, Baluchi & Kurdish communities. Individuals from these groups are restricted in a very severe manner and they are prevented from practising their religion and observing their traditions. Amnesty International also reported that the Iranian government proposed changes to the Iranian penal code that will erode the fundamental human rights of people. Thus for instance, people are liable to certain penalties like blasphemy and insults against the state. The problem with the strict blasphemy law is that anyone indicted for saying anything bad about the founder of Islam is liable to the death penalty without recourse to a proper trial (Afshari, 2011). This is because it is forbidden for the facts of the incident to be repeated by anyone, since the repeat of the blasphemous statements can also make the one who repeats them liable to the death penalty. Due to this, there are no investigations for such offences. These legal codes are applied to offences like sodomy and the like which all go with a summary death penalty. This has been abused on several occasions in Iran. The Iranians have also been indicted for their role in a nuclear enrichment programme which threatens the lives of civilians in nations bordering Iran. This include Israel. The Prime Minister of Iran, Mahmoud Ahmedinejad has stated that Israel must be wiped off the face of the earth (Hancock, 2010). This is an act of mental and physical aggression which affects Israelis and other Sunni Muslim states in the region like Saudi Arabia. Also, Iran is accused of funding the Islamic militant group, Hezbollah which fights a proxy war against Israel and American interests in the Middle East. This is an inherent and blatant violation of the rights of the people affected physically or psychologically by the aggression and threats of the Iranian regime. This include the Israelis and Saudis who live in the fear of an Iranian strike. Irans regime is reported to be involved in repressive laws and actions against women in the state. The regime has harsh laws that denies women of the right to education. The laws prevent women from taking up certain roles in the society and suppresses their desires and expectations in life. Iran has a questionable legal system which lacks transparency. The legal system has in the past conducted several forms of sentencing without proper care in the investigations. Things are concluded without an appropriate hearing. Sentences are passed with very little regards for peoples rights to natural justice and a fair trial. Also, the Amnesty International Report of 2009 indicates that there is torture and ill-treatment of people taken into custody. These people are given very dehumanizing punishments like detention in isolation and torture. These things come together to render the abuse and denial of peoples basic and fundamental rights. Human Rights Watch (HRW), another oversight humanitarian organisation and watchdog identified the actual figures of the human rights abuses meted out in Iran (2012). They identify that a total of 65 swooping arrests were conducted in 2011. The victims of these swoops were Arabs. The HRW identified that in 2011, no foreign reporters were allowed into Iran. This means that the media remained in the firm control of the state. Thus, the freewill of citizens and the right to clear uncensored information was restricted. The selective nature of the Iranian media meant that only positive things would be said about the government in power without any attempts to address the large scale violations going on. HRW reported that there is a large stream of political prisoners in Iranian jails. This is because Iran restricts the freedom of association. The detention of prisoners in Iran in 2011 was fairly a common practice. This followed the trend of arresting journalists who spoke up against the ruling government. Politicisation of the Law in Iran & The Islamic Elite According to Human Rights Watch and several other NGOs, Iran has serious human rights issues. The problem with is traced to some inherent situations in the states legal and ethical structures (Afshari, 2011). The experts identify that the main root of the problem is that the Law in Iran is politicised. In other words, the law is hijacked by the ruling elite. The ruling elite is supported by the majority of the population who are ethnically Persian and religiously Shiite. Due to this, laws have been made to ensure that only those who are part of the majority population are allowed to have a normal life. The firm control of Irans legal system by the majority Shiites ensure that the law supports human right abuses against minorities without questions. Thus, the enforcement of the laws in Iran is political in nature (Afshari, 2011). The security authorities only act on information that will keep the oppressive regime in power. This at the expense of less dominant groups in the nation. Also, there is massive bloc voting which ensures that stereotypes are protected at all times in Iran. The British Parliament reported that “senior figures within the Iranian regime used their religious and ideological beliefs to justify several abuses of human rights in the country” (Great Britain Parliament: House of Commons Foreign Affairs Committee 2009). This means that the ruling elites use their religious ideas to influence the entire nation to tilt towards a certain direction. However, this direction is one that keeps the majority and weaker groups in the society oppressed. On the other hand, the Iranian government insists that Iran is being given a bad name because of Western propaganda. They attribute this propaganda to Americas hatred after the overthrow of the Western-backed government of the Shah in 1979 (Great Britain Parliament: House of Commons Foreign Affairs Committee (2009). The position of Irans bad human rights records is confirmed by the fact that independent watchdog bodies like the Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International continue to report more violations each year. One of these statistics indicate that Iran has the highest per capita executions around the world with 320 executions in 2008. US President George W Bush announced in 2005 after the elections in Iran that there is a politicisation of the law in Iran in support of a complete disregard for human rights (Hancock, 2010). The US Presidents comment came after Mahmoud Ahmedinejad had won a landslide victory with over 17 million votes in the 2005 election. He stated that the Islamic elite had full grip of Iran and could run affairs to its advantage and to the detriment of its citizens. The Position of Minorities The maltreatment of minorities in Iran can be traced to the Shahs regime which failed to institute laws that protects minorities (Ghanea-Hercock, 2002). It was as late as 1975 that the Shahs regime attempted to enact a draft resolution to prevent discrimination and enhance the protection of minorities. However, the proposals were unfair and non-Muslims were treated as non-apprehended criminals (Ghanea-Hercock, 2002). The International Business Press (2009) identified that there is a number of situations that are meted out to minorities in Iran. From the statistics, the Persian Iranians make up over 51% of the total population. Azeris ( a Turkic people) make up 24%. Kurds are 7% whilst Arabs are 3%. In terms of religious denominations, 90% of Iranians are Shiite Muslims. Sunnis make up about 8% of the population whilst the others including Christians, Zoroastrians and the Jews. The position of minorities is put in jeopardy in several ways in Iran. First of all, there is a strong control and censorship of the media. Due to that, people are arrested and punished severely if they seek to practice activities that are contrary to the Iranian States expectations. Also, reformist newspapers are not allowed to operate in Iran. This is because such papers are seen to challenge the rights that the state has preserved for several generations. Reformation is viewed as a direct challenge and confrontation of the ruling elite who represents the majority and this comes with severe punishments. Activists like pressure groups and bloggers who lobby for equal rights in Iran are often illegal under Irans laws. This is because the ruling elite have passed laws that makes it inherently wrong to speak for the minority and down trodden. This is a severe human rights violation that needs to be checked to prevent the abuse of minorities. Leaders of labour unions and student activist groups are arrested and put to jail for a long time. These unionists are required to be part of the mainstream pro-government movements. Any attempts to go contrary to the government face various levels of human rights abuses like detention and torture. There is a limitation on the freedom of association by minorities (Great Britain & Commonwealth Office 2008). They cannot conduct meetings or go about their normal lives. There are beatings in custody and forced confessions (Great Britain & Commonwealth Office, 2008). The death penalty is carried out against innocent people who are not properly tried. Another element of the maltreatment of minorities in Iran is the disproportional punishment of people alleged to be homosexuals. Although the Iranian Prime Minister stated that there are no homosexuals in Iran, people are convicted for being homosexuals. Homosexuality remains a crime punishable by death (Ghanea-Hercock, 2002). This indicates that there is a chance that people are killed on trumped up charges. The Limitation of the International Community. Irans human rights abuses have escaped the efforts of the international community to resolve it because of several reasons. First of all, Iran is an almost self-sufficient economy (Ottolenghi, 2010). Due to this, the European Union and International community cannot attain much through the sanctioning of the the Islamic Republic. In other instances, Iranian diplomacy enables the regime to go around the sanctions before they are imposed. In 2002, the UN proposed a resolution for the sanctioning of Iran on the grounds of human rights abuses. Iran escaped the sanctions by a 20:19 vote with 14 abstentions (Human Rights Watch, 2003). At other points in time, Irans nuclear ambitions take centre-stage. This is because the nuclear enrichment programme provides a more serious situation. Thus, the nations of the international community occupy themselves with a stronger effort to stop the nuclear enrichment rather than the plight of the ordinary Iranian citizens who suffer from human rights abuses. Conclusion Iran has a problematic human rights record. The state has a censored media and effectively maintains a one-party state led by an elite group of people who control all the arms of government. The negative attitude of the ruling elite ensures that minorities are suppressed and their fundamental human rights are disregarded. The law enforcement system tilts towards anti-minority activities and the curbing of activities of people who are against the government. The legal system also includes penal codes that deny the fundamental human rights of people. This leads to the passing of harsh laws and penalties. Attempts by the international community to curb these human right violations is strongly restricted. This is because Iran gets around sanctions through diplomacy or reliance on the self sufficient economy for survival. Also, the international community tend to focus more attention on nuclear disarmament of Iran rather than the plight of its helpless citizens. Bibliography Abaid Nisrine (2008) Sharia, Missile States & International Human Rights Treaty Obligations BIICL Publishing. Behad Sohrab & Nomani Farhad (2011) Islam & The Everyday World: Public Policy Dilemas London: Routledge. Mayer Ann Elizabeth (2007) Islam & Human Rights: Tradition & Politics Westmeier Press Ottolenghi Emanuele (2010) Iran: The Iranian Crisis: Can the West Iv with Irans Nuclear Threat? London: Profile Books. Shcwartz Milton (2006) Iran: Political Issues, Nuclear Capabilities & Missile Range. NOVA Science Publishers. US Congress (2005) Congressional Records (Bond Volumes: Volume 150, Part 19) Government Printing Office. References Afshari Reza (2011) Human Rights in Iran: The Abuse of Cultural Relativism University of Pennsylvania Press. Amnesty International (2010) Iran Human Rights Records, 2009. Available online at Accessed: 19th February, 2012 Ghanea-Hercock Nazila (2002) Human Rights: The UN & The Bahais in Iran. The Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff. Great Britain Foreign & Commonwealth Office (2008) Human Rights: Annual Report, 2007 The Stationary Office. Great Britain Parliament: House of Commons Foreign Affairs Common (2009) Human Rights Annual Report: 2008: Sevent Report of Session 2008 – 2009. The Stationary Office. Hancock Jan (2010) Human Rights & US Foreign Policy London: Routledge Human Rights Watch (2003) Human Rights Watch World Report Human Rights Watch. Human Rights Watch (2012) Analysis of the Iranian Human Rights Situation 2011. Available online at: Accessed: 19th February, 2012. International Business Press (2009) Iran Foreign Policy & Government Gguide. New York: IBP Mousavian Sayyed Houssein (2008) Iran-Europe Relations: Challenges & Opportunities London: Taylor & Francis. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Human Rights Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 1”, n.d.)
Human Rights Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1589541-human-rights
(Human Rights Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1)
Human Rights Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/law/1589541-human-rights.
“Human Rights Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1589541-human-rights.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Human Rights

Human Rights and Poverty

This paper will tend to connect poverty and Human Rights, because the understanding may become deeper by immersion.... Societal problems may be connected to Human Rights since everybody is entitled to have the respect and the need to meet the basic necessities to survive.... It means that Human Rights are connected to poverty.... Before discussing the connection between the two concepts, it would help if Human Rights are defined first....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Human Rights and Poverty

Human Rights and Poverty [Name] [Date] Poverty in the modern world is one of the most striking issues.... For example, in the document the Millennium Declaration of the importance of Human Rights, equality, and non-discrimination for development, the key issues of dealing with poverty have been missed (Healy, 2008).... There is no doubt that developed countries of the modernity are fighting to protect the rights of poor people....
3 Pages (750 words) Term Paper

Amnesty International: A Quest for Human Rights

Their most determining intention for coming together is for the notion of bringing peace across the globe, and for the creation, protection, and usage of proper Human Rights for people everywhere.... Where, after all, do universal Human Rights begin In small places, close to home - so close and so small that they cannot be seen on any maps of the world.... "Amnesty International's work is based on principles set forth in the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Globalization and Human Rights

This essay takes a use case of Rwanda and examines globalization in relation to the concept of Human Rights in this country as the recent decade has seen the development of what is described as an international "Human Rights regime" as well as development of globalization processes.... hellip; This paper seeks for an answer to a question: to what extent has "Human Rights regime" been effectively applied, represent a genuine globalization of the attempt to implement fundamental Human Rights, and to what extent has its application reflected the balance of the 'interests' of various parties in Rwanda?...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

International Human Rights

International co-operations have been accused of gross Human Rights abuse when they are established abroad more so in third world countries where poverty levels are high.... Another challenge to upholding Human Rights where transnational corporations and other business enterprises are concerned is the dire poverty mostly inexperienced in third world countries where poverty drives people to accept any kind of work.... Furthermore, those living in countries where there is extreme poverty also do without basic Human Rights...
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Human Rights Quarterly

For almost a quarter century, Human Rights Quarterly has published a number of articles written by experts from the globe.... The HRQ provides people with updated information on essential… Human Rights Quarterly presents the updated policies and research information about Human Rights.... Large populations in the world are faced with challenges such as terrorism, starvation, mutilation, Such crimes need to be recognized as political or civil emergency since they are against Human Rights....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Trauma and Human rights

Even the most marginalized of groups in the human society do affiliate to a… It is these integral rights affiliated to the human condition that are perhaps called Human Rights in a technical context. In that sense the experience of trauma of the Gender and Sexual Studies of the Concerned Teacher 12 April Trauma and Human Rights It is a fact that humans happen tobe perhaps the only animals that have a deep seated sense of certain innate rights which happen to be an integral aspects of the very experience of being a human....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

What Are Human Rights

"What Are Human Rights" paper argues that for more than 65 years, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights is still more of a dream than reality.... The ways in which the Universal Declaration of Human Rights is still more of a dream.... hellip; Article 18 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states that everyone has the right to enjoy freedom of conscience, thought and practice a religion....  Human Rights are sets of moral norms or principles that define and express certain standards or human behavior....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us