StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Manager of the Vacation Inn - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Manager of the Vacation Inn" highlights that generally, with time cameras that detect at first instant any illegal entrant should be put in place and monitored on a 24-hour basis. These should once and for all, solve these homeless people’s menace…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Manager of the Vacation Inn
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Manager of the Vacation Inn"

The Inn installed a ten-foot wire-mesh fence around the pool. Two weeks ago, however, your staff found the body of a homeless man in the pool. An investigation determined that the individual climbed the fence in an inebriated state and lost consciousness upon entering the water. The decedent’s relatives are now suing the Inn. Your district manager asks you to “put an end to such problems,” and warns you that another incident like this could “cost you your job.” While you are certainly sympathetic to the plight of the homeless, you also want to keep your job.

You feel that installing barbed wire at the top of the fence would be inhumane and would also scare your guests. Instead, you opt to turn to a small company that manufactures electric fences for cattle. The solution they recommend is to run a “hot wire” at the top of the fence. The wire would deliver a mild, normally non-lethal, electric shock to a would-be trespasser. A week later you install the wire. Two days later, another inebriated homeless man, who has a pacemaker, climbs the fence. He dies instantly as a result of the mild electric shock. His family sues the Inn.

1. Ignoring any municipal codes and statutes that may exist, based on the information you have reviewed in Katko v. Briney, the Coase theorem concerning negligence, and your common sense, what are the policy arguments for and against tort liability in this case? The case brings into perspective the eagerness of litigants to sue for damages even when they are in the wrong. The wire mesh erected around the swimming pool differs greatly from the trap in Katko v. Briney. This is because while the trap in the former was hidden and caused damage to an unsuspecting trespasser, a wire mesh is clearly visible and when one climbs it, they do so at their own risk. The death occurred due to the man’s intoxication and not negligence on the side of the hotel. If the man had not been inebriated he would certainly have survived. As such, his death is a result of his cause and should not be blamed on anyone else.

The mild shock could not also under normal circumstances have caused death to the homeless man. His inebriation must have largely contributed to his death as a rationally thinking man would have immediately let go of the wire. His death must also be viewed as of his own causing and hence no one else should carry the responsibility.
When arguing about liability, it is important to consider the alternative to fencing the pool. Failure to safeguard the swimming pool grounds from intruders caused serious health problems for children. The hotel has been trying to keep out intruders to safeguard the health of children. The children’s health must be taken to supersede the interests of the intruders.

It can however be argued that the hotel used deadly force on the intruders by putting up the electric fence. This is because based on previous experience, the hotel ought to have realized that intoxicated intruders may attempt to climb over the electric wire and due to their state hold on to the wire posing a risk to their life.
The Coase theorem states that if and when conflicts on property rights appear, a mutually beneficial agreement can be reached where the negotiations are costless. In this case, it is impossible to reach such an agreement since the hotel would not in good faith compensate the intruders’ families.

2. What do you think the best solution would be and why?
The solution would be to employ live watchmen to man the swimming pool area who can ensure that the homeless people neither spoil the water in the pools nor cause harm to themselves. While this may be expensive it remains the only way that can temporarily be safest. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Law ass5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1604908-law-ass5
(Law Ass5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1604908-law-ass5.
“Law Ass5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1604908-law-ass5.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Manager of the Vacation Inn

Role of Manager - Individual Differences, Personality, & Intelligence

Role of manager Individual Differences, Personality, & Intelligence Since few years, there has been significant development in the processes and procedures of organisations around the globe, especially due to globalisation that has altered almost every perspective and thus, ways of performing things globally.... unning Head: Role of manager Role of manager [Institute's Role of manager Individual Differences, Personality, & IntelligenceSince few years, there has been significant development in the processes and procedures of organisations around the globe, especially due to globalisation that has altered almost every perspective and thus, ways of performing things globally....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

How the Company Manages Projects Which Span Two or Three Department

iscuss how your company manages the two boss situation when a staff member is reporting to both the project manager and the functional manager.... s project manager, discuss how you would negotiate with the resource providers for the use of their resources on your project.... ou have been appointed as the project manager to produce a marketing DVD of your company.... Discuss how your company manages the two boss situation when a staff member is reporting to both the project manager and the functional manager....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

General Patterns among Friendships of College Students

He manages to distinguish between a leader and a manager.... A manager on the other hand depends on rules and protocols for purposes of influencing people to move to a particular direction.... For instance, in his explanation of the concept of a manager vs.... manager personality, Abraham uses an illustration of an animated cartoon.... Under this illustration, Abraham manages to effectively explain how a leader uses influence to direct the behavior of his or her followers, while a manager will use rules to direct those interests....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Career Management and Development

This assignment "Career Management and Development" discusses strong communication skills that are preliminary to any job today, including the job of a new manager.... Basic communication skills training can assist the new manager in giving specific feedback, coaching, and counseling staff.... heory can help the manager or an individual learn what can be generalised from one unique experience and applied in another unique situation.... Theory can also provide categorisations for the manager to be able to select and adapt from past learning to meet current needs and conditions....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

The Negotiation Skill of the Manager or Leader That Is Calling the Meeting

"The Negotiation Skill of the manager or Leader That Is Calling the Meeting" paper discusses strategies that will produce useful outcomes in a meeting particularly when the participants may have different objectives from that of the person calling the meeting.... Primary focus is put on the negotiation skill of the manager or leader that is calling the meeting.... In a certain department of the organization, for example, is a meeting between and manager and his people it is possible that his people may oppose what the manage wants to happen or these people below may have something better to say than the manager....
12 Pages (3000 words) Coursework

How Managers Utilize Key Elements of Organizational Behavior Concepts

It examines the views of Maureen Portee, the branch manager of Sun Trust Banks, Inc.... It examines the views of Maureen Portee, the branch manager of Sun Trust Banks, Inc.... It examines the views of Maureen Portee, the branch manager of Sun Trust Banks, Inc.... It examines the views of Maureen Portee, the branch manager of Sun Trust Banks, Inc.... This paper analyzes how the manager uses primary elements of organizational behavior concepts....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Responsibilities of the Security Manager

The author of the following paper under the title 'Responsibilities of the Security manager' focuses on the roles and responsibilities of the facility manager and security manager.... The paper begins with the definition of the facility manager and security manager.... A facility manager is an individual who does strategic planning who assist in organizing daily activities of the business and ensuring the premises operates based on predetermined requirements....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Basic Investment Strategies an Investment Manager Can Follow

The paper "Basic Investment Strategies an Investment manager Can Follow" is an outstanding example of an essay on finance and accounting.... Active fund managers try to perform better than the stock market average, while a fund manager who follows the passive strategy does not even try to out-perform the market average.... The paper "Basic Investment Strategies an Investment manager Can Follow" is an outstanding example of an essay on finance and accounting....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us