StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Should conscientious objection be a defence to breach of equality law - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
With reference to legal writings, it is stated that the basis for equality law is pegged on the fact that the State needs to do more to protect its citizens, which is a contrast to human rights law that is perceived to be pegged on the fact that the State is participating in the…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Should conscientious objection be a defence to breach of equality law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Should conscientious objection be a defence to breach of equality law"

Should Conscientious Objection Be A Defence To Breach of Equality Law? With reference to legal writings, it is d that the basis for equality law is pegged on the fact that the State needs to do more to protect its citizens, which is a contrast to human rights law that is perceived to be pegged on the fact that the State is participating in the oppression of its citizens.1 The same legal writings further noted that the genesis of the equality law is entwined with the implementation of Anti-Racism laws that were first enacted in the 1960s in the United States under the wider scope of the US Civil Rights Act of 1964.

The Anti-Racism laws, which are a reflection of the equality law were designed to provide a remedy to the failure by the State to not do enough to protect disadvantaged member of the society.2 The United Kingdom’s Equality Act of 2010, which is part of the wider anti-discrimination laws of Great Britain, is based on the premise of the State impacting upon the UK society through legislation to educate and instruct individuals as well as institutions on how to act during public interactions.3 The Equality Law simply requires citizens to be blind on differences to do with sexuality, race, gender, and age.

Secondly, it requires citizens to be deaf on differences arising from belief or religion. However, under the concept of conscientious objection, there are seemingly exceptions to the adherence of the equality law.4Conscientious objection has been described as “a refusal on religious or moral grounds to engage in military conflict or even serve in the armed forces.”5 A conscientious objection is normally based on religious beliefs that are obtained from trainings and must be highly upheld.

A conscientious objector must prove that the newly acquired ethical and moral convictions are what direct his or her life choices. Under the English law, there are only three instances where there are legal rights to objections based on conscientious objections. These instances comprise of abortion cases, application of technological process in achieving conception/ pregnancy, and in services of the armed forces.6 Other cases examples on the application of conscientious objections are when a pharmacists declines to administer emergency contraceptives owing to his religious beliefs or when an employee breaks health and safety rules or dress codes or displays religious symbols at the work place, which is an infringement upon the rights of others.

Based on the above review, conscientious objection should not be used as defence for breaching the equality law since it will provide a loophole for discriminating against others. For example, if a priest refuse to conduct ceremonial marriage of same-sex partners based on religious grounds then he will have violated equality law that require persons to be blind on differences of sexuality and deaf of religious differences. The statement that the equality law was designed to ensure equal protection in areas where the State was not doing enough, reaffirms this argument.

Therefore, the use of conscientious objection as a defence for breaching equality law ‘waters-down’ the full force of the equality law and it creates loopholes for people to discriminate against others based on religious beliefs and trainings.7 ReferencesGreat Britain, Equality Act 2010, Part 15. London, UK, Stationary Office, 2010 Schinkel, A. Conscience and Conscientious Objections. Amsterdam: Pallas, 2007Takemura, H. International Human Right to Conscientious Objection to Military Service and Individual Duties to Disobey Manifestly Illegal Orders.

Berlin: Springer, 2009.Wadham, J. Ruebain, D. and Uppal, S. Blackstone’s Guide to the Equality Act 2010. Oxford, UK; Oxford University Press, 2012.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should conscientious objection be a defence to breach of equality law Essay”, n.d.)
Should conscientious objection be a defence to breach of equality law Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1643052-should-conscientious-objection-be-a-defence-to-breach-of-equality-law
(Should Conscientious Objection Be a Defence to Breach of Equality Law Essay)
Should Conscientious Objection Be a Defence to Breach of Equality Law Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1643052-should-conscientious-objection-be-a-defence-to-breach-of-equality-law.
“Should Conscientious Objection Be a Defence to Breach of Equality Law Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1643052-should-conscientious-objection-be-a-defence-to-breach-of-equality-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should conscientious objection be a defence to breach of equality law

Conscientious Objection in Medicine

conscientious objection School conscientious objection There are two kinds of theses that pertain to this case.... “conscientious objection in health care always affects someone else's health or access to care because the refusal interrupts the delivery of health services” (Berlinger, 2012).... I recommend conscience absolutism in this case considering the law of the state.... Legally, the organization may not be in a position to file a case against Harry Rogers because the state's law does not consider the refusal of a licensed healthcare professional to do something because of religious, moral, or ethical concerns reason enough to take some disciplinary action or apply some kind of criminal liability against him/her....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Socrates Defense of Athenian Law

This paper ''Socrates Defense of Athenian law'' tells that Socrates was an Athenian who firmly believed that the system of the law under which the jury was acting was fair.... Socrates declared that “I must observe the law and make my defence”.... In both the 'Apology' and 'Crito', Plato represents Socrates as a staunch defender of law, particularly in the sense that respect for the legal order of one's polity is a basic obligation of citizenship....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Self Defense and International Law

This case study "Self Defense and International law" is about terrorism is the one big thing; the world is concerned more than any other factor.... The Republic Of Bona and other nations should come together against terrorism.... The International Community should ask and pressurize the government that is providing shelter to these terrorist groups and base camps so that they can carry on their terrorist activities....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Secretary of State for Defence

The Secretary of State for defence is the Cabinet Minister with the responsibility of making and executing defence policy, as well as furnishing the means by which it is performed.... He is Chairman of the defence Council and of the Army Board, the Air Force and the Admiralty Board … Despite the responsibility for ultimately all components of defence, the Secretary of State for defence is backed by the Under-Secretary of State for defence, the Minister of State for defence Procurement, and the Minister of State for the Armed Forces....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Defences to Homicide Project

For the provocation defence to be invoked, the nature of the provocation had to fall into one of four categories: (1) grossly insulting assault; (2) attack upon a relative or a friend; (3) unlawful imprisonment or restraint of an Englishman; or (4) a man coming upon his wife engaged in adultery.... The Victorian law Reform Commission was established under the Victorian law Reform Commission Act 2000 as the central agency for developing law reform in Victoria....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

A Conviction for Driving while Intoxicated

The paper Consequently, the paper also discusses how appellate court will rule on the objection.... A person testifying for the prosecution is a high school graduate.... The testifier measured the skid mark of the defendant and assumed the defendant was driving at least 65 miles per hour....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Conscientious Objection

Legal Protection for conscientious objection by Health Professionals.... ccording to the state's law, Rogers has all rights to act according to his religious, moral and ethical convictions as this does not call for civil, criminal and disciplinary action (Grady, 2006).... CONSIENTIOUS objection BY HEATHCARE PROFESSIONALS Lecturer Challenges posed by the case In this case, Harry Rogers has undergone a religious conversion and based on this he cannot fill prescriptions that have been written by physicians who have performed abortions....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Maximlianus as conscientious objector

In the paper “Maximlianus as conscientious objector” the author analyzes Maximlianus objections to the doings of the Church owing to the suffering that he saw around him.... As it is, it was pretty disgraceful to have violence become a part of Christianity even though it had to be through the conscientious efforts of Maximlianus....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us