StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Subject of Legal Abortion - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Subject of Legal Abortion" highlights that fundamental rights reprove basic truths in the functioning of a society. Rulings preventing the segregation of the races are now accepted by the public therefore can be viewed as fundamental rights…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
The Subject of Legal Abortion
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Subject of Legal Abortion"

Abortion The of legal abortion has lead to a nationwide, often emotion-filled, debate that has endured for many years and will for many years to come. People are decidedly in either in the ‘pro-choice’ or ‘pro-life’ camp. There are no compromises to be negotiated: one concerned with the life of a child; the other, the freedom of choice and woman’s health. To properly analyze the issue, the opposing viewpoints including the moral, medical and legal aspects must be argued with equal resolve and without bias. The abortion issue is multi-faceted and both sides of the issue provide credible, thought-provoking arguments. The right to choose is the foundation upon which this country was built. Those who are pro-abortion trumpet this slogan while proclaiming a woman’s ‘God given right’ to make her own choices without government interference. This simple ideology is embraced by some but the arguments are flawed when the realities of abortion are examined. Studies have shown that most women are coerced into committing this murderous act of a living human and that there is no such thing as safe abortions as many are led to believe. Pro-abortion proponents generally espouse that the rights of a non-living tissue that feels no pain are non-existent. This discussion exposes these untruths that have been reported and are widely perceived as facts. It also explains the framers’ intent for the legal and moral direction of American society when they drafted the Constitution, the document that defines the laws of the nation. There is little freedom of choice for women who are experiencing an unwanted pregnancy. The women themselves usually wish to bring their baby to full term. Other powerful influences in her life such as husbands/boyfriends, parents and friends are generally the forces that exact pressures on her to terminate the pregnancy. “Eight out of 10 women surveyed after abortion said they would have given birth if they’d had support and encouragement from family and friends.” 1 It’s the abortion that, in many cases, is unwanted by the woman, not the baby. Most often, the father of the child, not wishing to accept responsibility, may beg or even threaten a woman until she agrees to the abortion. Legal abortion enables fathers to force their will on mothers. Some women resort to abortion in desperation because they fear continued abuse. That fear is substantiated as women who refuse to abort have been subjected to serious abuses which have escalated to murder if the women still persists in her refusal. Murder is the leading cause of death for pregnant women and for what other motive could there be? Immediately following an abortion, the one(s) coercing the decision are relieved and seldom, if ever, give the inconvenient issue another thought. Women, on the other hand, suffer long afterwards, racked by overwhelming guilt and agonizing over their irreversible decision. This pain may last a lifetime as they are never able to forgive themselves. Another myth espoused as fact is that the aborted fetus is no more than a cluster of cells, a bit of tissue unable to even feel pain. A developing embryo has a unique set of fingerprints as well as different genetic patterns than its mother. It is a human being unto itself. If one defines death as the stoppage of a heartbeat and murder as the forceful and intentional stopping of a heart then abortion is surely murder. If the existence of a heartbeat legally defined life, then almost all abortions would be illegal as the heart is formed by the 18th day in the womb. A British medical journal reported that when a pin is stuck into an eight-week-old fetus, it opens his mouth in a crying motion and pulls his hand away. By week five, eyes, legs, and hands begin to develop. “By week six, brain waves are detectable, mouth and lips are present and fingernails are beginning to form. By the eighth week the baby can begin to hear. Every organ is in place, bones begin to replace cartilage, and fingerprints begin to form.” 2 ‘Pro Choice’ activists argue that women should have access to safe abortions, that ‘a nation founded on and dedicated to civil liberties could allow its citizens to resort to dangerous self-abortion procedures.’ That too is a false premise. Ninety-seven percent of women who have had abortions describe intense pain experienced during the procedure despite the use of local anesthetics. “Compared to other pains, researchers have rated the pain from abortion as more painful than a bone fracture, about the same as cancer pain, though not as painful as an amputation.” 3 Studies also show that patients typically found abortion more painful than their doctors or counselors told them to expect and that younger women tend to have a more painful experience than older women. “Complications are common such as bleeding, hemorrhage, laceration of the cervix, menstrual disturbance, inflammation of the reproductive organs, bladder or bowel perforation, and serious infection.” 4 Overall, women who have abortions increase their risk of future miscarriages and sterility. Humiliated, scared and ashamed, a mother to be must, generally, go to a clinic, not a familiar doctor for the most traumatic experience of her young life. Women can suffer long term physical as well as psychological complications from an abortion procedure. Laws that force women to carry their pregnancy to term contradict the precepts of the U.S. Constitution as well as any definition of compassion and decency. It is unconscionable that a nation founded on and dedicated to civil liberties could allow its citizens to resort to dangerous self-abortion procedures. However, prior to the Roe v. Wade decision in 1973 which legalized abortion in the U.S., this practice was commonplace. Before abortion was legal, many thousands of young women were mutilated and died attempting to end a pregnancy though the wealthy were able to have illegal abortions safely. The wealthy were able to travel abroad or pay high fees to a local doctor willing to perform the procedure for a price but a poor woman must resort to less safe options. Prohibiting abortions does not and has never stopped them from occurring; it just acts to harm women. Those opposed to legal abortions are also in the same camp that opposes programs that aid the impoverished and abused children who are the result of unwanted pregnancies. They point to ‘Christian morals’ and ‘family values’ as justification for the loss of liberty, discrimination of the poor and the increased cases of injured women. The ideological divide will never be bridged but the debate whether abortion should be legal or not is a matter for the courts, as are all legal matters. This discussion considers the legal aspects of the abortion issue. The arguments for and against are significant in a social context yet inconsequential because they will not decide whether or not abortions remain safe and lawful. When most people speak disapprovingly of the Roe decision, they base their objection purely on moral grounds but scholars, lawyers and especially judges who condemn the decision should only do so based on constitutional grounds in addition to voicing their moral objections. The argument against the decision should address the 9th Amendment which states, “The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.” 5 Those opposed have said that the ninth, or any other amendment, does not specifically mention abortion therefore the Constitution is not applicable when attempting to determine the legality of abortion rights. This opinion, however, very obviously contradicts the short and to the point statement that is the Ninth Amendment which clearly encourages the recognition of abortion and all other rights over and above what is contained in the Constitution. . If courts are engaged in recognizing if the fundamental rights of individuals are protected, then the personal interest of a woman being forced by the government to have an unwanted child certainly applies. Recognizing that courts do indeed have the authority to intervene in decisions involving individual rights citing the Constitution as precedence, could laws preventing abortions still be justified in spite of this egregious encroachment on the civil liberties of women? After all, constitutional rights are not unconditional. Why doesn’t the government have an interest in protecting the rights of those not yet born? The Fourteenth Amendment answers this question. It begins by referring to “All persons born ... in the United States” 6 indicating that the protections under the Constitution refer only to persons who are ‘born.’ Though the constitutionality regarding the Roe decision can be easily argued, it must be acknowledged that since the issue remains intensely controversial more than 30 years after, opponents may be justified in believing the right to an abortion should not be thought of as fundamental. Fundamental rights reprove basic truths in the functioning of a society. Rulings preventing the segregation of the races are now accepted by the public therefore can be viewed as fundamental rights. Abortion rights do not enjoy this universally held view so it is fair to debate the issue even on legal grounds though that is seldom the arena for debate. It is understood, however, that the majority of Americans do agree with the Court’s decision and believe it to be a fundamental right. Both sides of the abortion issue contain legal, ethical and social considerations that provoke great emotions as this paper has shown. It is important that those of each opinion understand the opposing viewpoint if they truly wish to debate the topic rather than simply insist that their own viewpoint is correct. Only in this way can the national debate proceed with any hopes of resolution. If both sides understand the issues of the other, the emotional aspect can be lessened and replaced with reasonable conversations. Works Cited Bulanger, Eliane; Melzak, Ronald & Lauzon, Pierre. “Pain of First-Trimester Abortion: A Study of Psychosocial and Medical Predictors.” Pain. Vol. 36, (1989), pp. 343, 345. Danforth, David N. Obstetrics and Gynecology. 5th Ed. Philadelphia: J.B. Lipincott, (1986), pp. 217, 257, 382-83. National Right to Life Foundation. “Fetal Development: From Conception to Birth.” National Right to Life. (n.d.). January 26, 2009 Reardon, David C. Aborted Women, Silent No More. Springfield, IL: Acorn Books, 2002, pp. 11-21. “United States Constitution Bill of Rights.” Cornell Law School. Legal Information Institute. (2006). January 26, 2009 “United States Constitution Fourteenth Amendment.” Cornell Law School. Legal Information Institute. (2006). January 26, 2009 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Abortion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Abortion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/law/1720076-abortion
(Abortion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Abortion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1720076-abortion.
“Abortion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/law/1720076-abortion.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Subject of Legal Abortion

Abortion, a Right of Choice

The topic of legal abortion often leads to emotion-filled ideological debates which have divided the nation's citizens and politicians.... The topic of legal abortion often leads to emotion-filled ideological debates which have divided the nation's citizens and politicians.... legal abortion allows fathers to force their desire on women.... To appropriately examine the subject, the opposing viewpoints including the legal, medical and moral aspects must be argued with similar determination and without bias....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Abortion Rights American Legal System

abortion Rights – American Legal System.... abortion rights in the American legal system The United States of America portrays an emerging trend where the freedom of choice is used to presage the freedom from responsibility.... The abortion rights and the decisions rendered by the American legal system on the abortion rights of the Native Americans had a significant and widespread impact on the lives of the citizens across the United States of America....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Abortion Challenge in the United States

The paper "abortion Challenge in the United States" discusses that to solve the problem we need to look at the root causes.... Access to abortion facilities depended on race, economic status, and someone's place of residence.... ven before abortion was legalized, some experienced and well-trained physicians began offering abortion services, even with the risk of imprisonment and loss of their medical licenses.... Women who wanted to undergo abortion obtained the information through word of mouth....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Abortion in USA

Various religious texts have also broached the subject in one way or another.... Various religious texts have also broached the subject in one way or another.... Though many countries have legalized abortions, in the United States, the debate regarding the legality has still not been resolved, despite the United States Supreme Court having made a ruling on the subject.... abortion, or the willful termination of pregnancy, has very much been in the forefront in public debate in the United States....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Abortion and Nurse's Conscientious Objection

Two Roman Catholic nurses recently won the right not to work in an abortion clinic, which is not new considering the right of conscientious objection to abortion on religious or ethical grounds, was written in an act of 1967.... Legality of abortion: Nurse's Ethics and Conscientious Objection The dilemma of abortion is faced by the society for so many years and is still in prevalence but what we can do is discuss the factors surrounding the argument, so when the person such as a nurse is faced with the dilemma he or she can make a conscious, educated, thoughtful decision....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Abortion: A Necessary Legality

This essay, Abortion: A Necessary Legality, stresses that The Subject of Legal Abortion has lead to a nationwide, often emotion-filled, debate that has endured for many years and will for many years to come.... pponents of legal abortion argue that using the right to choose as the foundation for a woman's right to choose abortion is flawed when the realities of abortion are examined.... As the paper highlights, the abortion issue is multi-faceted and both sides of the issue provide credible, thought-provoking arguments....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Right-to-Life and Pro-Choice Arguments

This paper 'legal abortion' will first present the 'right-to-life' then follow with the 'pro-choice' argument.... Those who are pro-abortion trumpet this slogan while proclaiming a woman's 'God given right' to make her own choices.... Pro-abortion proponents generally espouse that the rights of a non-living tissue that feels no pain are non-existent.... Those who are pro-abortion trumpet this slogan while proclaiming a woman's 'God given right' to make her own choices without government interference....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Religious, Ethical, Conservative and Pro-Choice Viewpoints of Abortion

The Subject of Legal Abortion has lead to a nationwide, often emotion-filled, debate that has endured for many years and will for many years to come.... This paper 'Religious, Ethical, Conservative and Pro-Choice Viewpoints of Abortion' portrays the issue which continues to be the subject of fierce disputes between supporters and opponents of this painful procedure, which damages the health of the mother and deprives the life of an unborn child.... In the US, one of every three pregnancies never comes to term because the woman has an abortion....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us