StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Adopting a Child by Homosexual Male Couple - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper "Adopting a Child by Homosexual Male Couple" will begin with the statement that when studying Philosophy and ethics, it is easy to think that the ethics of people who are long dead bear very little relevance to contemporary issues. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
Adopting a Child by Homosexual Male Couple
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Adopting a Child by Homosexual Male Couple"

This is an ethical issue because some people feel it is morally wrong or unnatural to be homosexual or to be romantically coupled with a person of the same gender, and that children need to be protected from such people. Others feel that adults have a right to express a sexual preference, that it is a private choice and not a moral issue at all, but that children need a mother and a father which, by definition, a male homosexual couple cannot provide. Still, others feel that children need parents to love and guide them, and that sexual preference is not pertinent.

Rousseau claimed that individual freedom comes from sacrificing personal liberty to the “general will” so that the common interest (not necessarily the majority vote) can be legislated and everyone is protected by the community’s will (Philosophy, et Cetera).  In the case of conflict, arising from diversity, Rousseau claims that the common interest is what benefits all members, so minority interests are protected from being exploited.  Individual rights become collective rights.  The general will can never take away individual rights because individual rights are not of practical use to the community or common good (Philosophy, et Cetera).  

Given this argument, relative to the issue under consideration, it is an individual right to become part of a couple and to raise a family. The general will can only be given an opportunity to overturn this right if two conditions are met. The first is that there is found sufficient and overwhelming evidence that there is danger or developmental threat to children from male homosexual parents. In this event, it can be said to be in the common good to protect the children of the community, who are all innocent and good (Doyle and Smith), from threat. The second condition, which must also be met, along with the first, is that the general will leads to legislation protecting all children of all parents from all threats of any kind. This condition is necessary to meet the requirement of equality under the law. As these conditions do not currently exist, then Rousseau would support the right of the male homosexual couple to adopt the child.

Benedict Spinoza builds on Neo-Platonic thought and Descarte’s definition of “substance” and advocates non-dualism, insisting everything is of one substance.  The substance is God, the Absolute.  Man is the natural unfolding of God’s nature.  Man is identical, in a pantheistic sense, with God (rafed.net). Therefore the love of man for man is still, in essence, the love of God for God. Homosexuality cannot be immoral because God is not immoral. In the same way, if a male homosexual couple adopts a child and loves the child, and the child loves them as parents, this too is the unity of God’s love. Spinoza would defend their right to adopt, reminding the State of their duty to encourage the men to know God through the rational efforts of raising the child, an expression of God, whom they seek to know.

Thomas Aquinas classified, supported, and justified the teachings and rules of the Catholic Church (Hillar, 22). He took, as absolutes, Church religious dogma and supported absolute obedience to its edicts. He would, therefore, have been opposed to a male homosexual couple adopting a child, as it is forbidden by the Catholic Church.

My own opinion, in this matter, is that if a male homosexual couple wants to adopt and parent a child, and they are reasonably certain they have a loving, stable relationship, and are prepared to love the child, then they should have the same rights as any heterosexual couple with a similar desire and intention. I agree with Rousseau that the majority and minority must be treated equally and fairly and that the majority has no right to impose power over the minority, where the common interest is not being threatened.  I also like Benedict’s way of seeing everyone as being of one God substance, and that the love of man for man is the love of God for God.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Homosexual male couple wants to adopt a child. What will Rousseau, Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1590349-homosexual-male-couple-wants-to-adopt-a-child-what-will-rousseau-benedict-and-aquinas-argue-what-is-your-view-explain
(Homosexual Male Couple Wants to Adopt a Child. What Will Rousseau, Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1590349-homosexual-male-couple-wants-to-adopt-a-child-what-will-rousseau-benedict-and-aquinas-argue-what-is-your-view-explain.
“Homosexual Male Couple Wants to Adopt a Child. What Will Rousseau, Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1590349-homosexual-male-couple-wants-to-adopt-a-child-what-will-rousseau-benedict-and-aquinas-argue-what-is-your-view-explain.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Adopting a Child by Homosexual Male Couple

Gay Adoption

Because of these anti-discrimination laws, many states no longer allow adoption agencies to discriminate against a gay couple seeking to adopt a child based on the couple's sexual orientation, but that argument has taken a 360 degree turn.... In fact, these adoption agencies must assist these couples in their search for a child.... With the injunction in place for who knows how long, the adoption agencies in those three dioceses can continue to deny same-sex couples their rights to adopt a child....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Nontraditional Families

In cases where the divorce opposite sex spouse is incapable of looking after the child, there is little choice but for the child to live with his or her bisexual/homosexual male parent.... For example, consider a bisexual/homosexual parent, who is the biological father of a child.... This parent may divorce his opposite sex spouse and take up living with another male partner.... lso, given that there are a number of people who live together as unmarried couples [heterosexual or homosexual] it is difficult to determine who should and who should not have the right to adopt (Waite, 1995, 483-507)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Same Sex Parents: The Psychological Effect on Children

The author of the paper explores the relationship between homosexual parents and their offspring.... ith much still to be decided, the homosexual marriage reached new heights in 2004, starting with President Bush's State of the Union Address.... dvocates of homosexual "marriage" would prefer the debate to focus on the former....
34 Pages (8500 words) Research Paper

Debate on Allowing Homosexuals to Adopt Children

The clerk denied the application and the couple sued him.... The trial court sided with the clerk and even after appealing, the appellate court did not find the favor of the couple.... This essay highlights that the debate, in the public view, has less gay rights sympathizers with the majority, under churches and other conservative institutions, being against the idea of gays adopting children....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Psychological Effects of Children Being Raised by Homosexuals

There are a number of research studies; surveys and credible journals have been published which discuss the possible effects that can occur when a homosexual parent is raising a child.... A key element is the literature review of credible journals and is crucial as a method for highlighting the true impact of having homosexual parents on the psychological, intellectual, and social well-being of a child.... ccording to Debra Busher, an expert in the field of child psychology, "Sexual orientation of a parent is critical to the upbringing of a child....
41 Pages (10250 words) Term Paper

Should Same-Sex Relationships Have the Right to Adopt

A heterosexual couple who cannot have children will often consider adoption; it is a morally sound commitment to take on the life of a child and ensure it is healthy, happy and socially well-adjusted.... A same-sex couple facing the same infertility concerns, however, will often face discrimination and stereotypical views when they try to adopt a child of their own.... While there are many national organizations and individual citizens who believe in the ability of a same-sex couple to raise a child as well as, if not better than, a traditional heterosexual couple, critics cite a variety of reasons why this is not so....
18 Pages (4500 words) Article

The Legalization of Adoption by Homosexuals

All these things can easily be achieved by homosexual couples.... If psychologists, social workers, and the judge think that a couple can rear a child the judge should grant adoption regardless of the sexual orientation of the adopter.... Taking into account the development that has taken place in social relations it can be safely argued that homosexual couples can raise a child just like heterosexual couples.... Conscientious and nurturing adults, whether they are men or women, heterosexual or homosexual, can be excellent parents....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report

Gay Couple Adoption

This paper explores the issue of gay couple adoption, by examining the potential advantages and disadvantages associated with the practice.... The subject of gay couple adoption remains highly controversial, with some states and conservative individuals still holding their ground against it, while liberals and human rights activists strongly advocate for the practice.... This paper argues for gay couple adoption and resolution of perceived disadvantages associated with the practice....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us