StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

Tort law: Liability for psychiatric trauma - Essay Example

Summary
Liability for psychiatric trauma is an area of Tort which has presented many difficulties for tortuous claims since a claim does not necessarily have to involve proof of direct involvement in an incident giving rise to the injury. The risk of opening the ‘floodgates’ is…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Tort law: Liability for psychiatric trauma
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Tort law: Liability for psychiatric trauma"

Download file to see previous pages

A relaxation of the guidelines would only complicate matters by opening the floodgates and as such the practical problems are probably insuperable. One of the most important lines drawn was enunciated in Alcock v Chief Constable of the South Yorkshire Police. In this case it was held that in order for a claim to be substantiated for psychiatric injury the plaintiff must demonstrate that he or she suffered from a recognizable psychiatric condition as a direct result of what he saw in respect of the incident.

Lord Ackner said that nervous shock necessarily involved a ‘sudden appreciation by sight or sound of an horrifying event.’2 In Alcock, 95 persons were crushed to death at a football match in Sheffield. Many of those involved as well as close family members suffered from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and claimed damages for nervous shock. (These victims, bystanders, family and rescuers are generally secondary victims, whereas primary victims are persons directly involved in the accident)3 Allowing the claims, Alcock also ruled that secondary victims, who were not close family members as in a parent and a child will be closely examined.

This principle was applied in North Glamorgan NHS Trust v Walters.4 It is important to note here that the judiciary has made a valiant effort to limit the class or category of potential victims. While Alcock draws the line restraining who might come within the range of secondary victims by virtue of their relationship with the primary victim, there are those who advocate broadening the category to include persons who share amorous relationships with the primary victim. Kay Wheat, Senior Lecturer at Nottingham Trent University is of the opinion that homosexuals in stable relationships should fall within the category of secondary victims.

5 Indeed, in recent years there has been a tendency

...Download file to see next pages Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Tort law: Liability for psychiatric trauma

Nervous Shock and the Commission Concern

Tort liability for psychiatric Damage, Sydney: The Law Book Co.... The House of Lords agreed unanimously to hold the claim of the plaintiff for psychiatric illness as to sail through.... The Commission Concern When viewing the liability law for psychiatric illness, there are always two fundamental issues that have to be addressed.... Recovering Damages for psychiatric Injury, London: Blackstone Press, 1995.... ‘Issues in Tort liability for Nervous Shock' Australian Law Journal, 1992 Teff, H....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Law on Recovery for Psychiatric Injury Caused by Negligence

The paper "The Law on Recovery for psychiatric Injury Caused by Negligence" states that psychiatric injury has been a big concern over the years and how people deal with it will always matter.... liability for Negligent Words, 2000.... This is because people take trauma differently the same way they heal differently.... This is because people take trauma differently the same way they heal differently.... Claimants suffering from psychiatric injury caused by negligence have hard it rough while establishing trying to establish liabilities to the defendants....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Liability of Employers for Psychiatric Illnesses

liability for psychiatric damage can be claimed where the employer breached a duty of care by not acting in response to the reasonably foreseeable signs of damage (Munkman, 1990).... Employers need to take measures to reduce stressful working conditions for employees to avoid liability for psychiatric illnesses suffered due to this.... This essay "Liability of Employers for psychiatric Illnesses" focuses on contract agreements between an employer and an employee involving the former providing reasonable care to the latter....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Tort Coursework

ausation is an important factor for determining liability for damages.... Public policy, per se, cannot relieve the tortfeasor from liability for damages.... Modern tort law.... This decision served to preclude the liability of the defendant, in Gray v Thames Trains Ltd; because, the court opined that even if the plaintiff had not committed manslaughter, his earning capacity would have decreased, on account of his post trauma stress disorder19....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Voluntary Assumption Of Tort Liability In English Law

aw Commission Consultation Paper No 137 - liability for psychiatric Illness ... heat, K (1995) Law Commission - Consultation Paper No 137 - liability for psychiatric Injury.... ullany, NJ and Handford, PR (1993), Tort liability for psychiatric Damage.... The paper "Voluntary Assumption Of Tort Liability In English Law" discusses the law on compensation for psychiatric harm in respect of the assessment criteria used by the courts in finding liability specifically in the area of employer's liability for negligence....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

The Liability of Employers for Psychiatric Illness Suffered by Employee

The paper "The Liability of Employers for psychiatric Illness Suffered by Employee" states that employers can be held responsible if they fail to remedy situations within the working place that is likely to cause stress e.... THE COMMON LAW DUTY OF CARE, THE LIABILITY OF EMPLOYERS for psychiatric ILLNESS SUFFERED BY EMPLOYEES ARISING FROM STRESSFUL CONDITIONS Date: ... Damages for psychiatric Injuries.... Employer liability for Workplace Trauma....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Effect of the House of Lords Judgment in Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd V Forsyth37

The question of liability for psychiatric illness evokes a series of strongly held opinions.... Some argue that similar principles which apply to liability for physical injury should be enforced to liability for psychiatric illness as well.... While some others argue that liability for psychiatric illness should be discarded altogether.... “Tort liability for psychiatric Damage.... Claims for psychiatric illness were made for by relatives of those killed or injured in the tragedy56 and by police officers who were present at the scene....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Analysis of Tort Law Cases

"Analysis of tort law Cases" paper focuses on a tort as an injury to a person or property compensable under the law.... Martha has a good cause of the claim because of the psychological damage it did to her from the loss of her fiancée and the effects of trauma of the whole disaster on her.... These are the facts that entitle Joanna to compensation for damages under the principles of Negligence, Duty of Care, and psychiatric Injury.... DART's inspectors has not made any attempt to perform its duties of care to the public by securing the premise, or if it does it did not do anything about it, thus results to the psychiatric condition of Joanna....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us