StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name: Course: Date: Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma The debate regarding morality and rightness of actions based on individual’s consent may be considered as a dilemma in ethical practices. In his philosophical arguments, Kant noted that the basic moral principle to treat people is by respecting and recognizing the right to decent or consent to any possibilities…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma"

Download file to see previous pages

In this article, I provide reasons to support O’Neill’s argument regarding the validity of consent as the fundamental principle in dealing with others. First, I evaluate the moral dimensions of treating others as they would like. Secondly, I address the validity of consent in justifying the way others are treated, thirdly I address the issue of hypothetical consent and moral actions, fourth, I address the issues of Kantian alternative and the Formula of the end principle, and finally how these ideas are applicable in job and relationship issues The moral ideals of treating others as persons is not primarily a matter of treating people as they want or would want to be treated.

Though O’Neill (253) argues that involved employers treat employees as persons, first, there would be a need for cognitive maturity in making decisions regarding the best treatment approach, regardless of the employee’s views. For example, an employee may not want to be involved in a certain project due to lack of knowledge or information. The cognitive ability of the employer to know the benefits of such program to employees may overrule what the employee actually wants in implementing it.

Secondly, though a prostitute who does her job with involved perfunctoriness may not be using the client, or the client may not be using the prostitute, such a relationship would not amount to treating others as persons. Any action has to be observed to promote the end of the receiver. It follows that such action to quench sexual desires with a prostitute treats her as an object, and not as a person, though treated as she would want to. Therefore, treating or not treating others as they like may not amount to treating or not treating others as persons.

In actual consent, the ideal that treating others as persons has to view their consent as being of moral significance is not plausible. First, a rape victim may consent to the act to avoid distress and further harm. Though the victim consents to the rape ordeal action, this would not amount to a consent that is of moral significance. This implies that such consent cannot be used to support the rape act, as the action in itself does not promote the good of the receiver. Secondly, the consent of workers to be employed in capitalism as Marxist critics noted (O’Neill, 255) cannot be of moral significance if the same employees are exploited for the gains of the employer.

In this case, employees are treated as things or as objects rather than like persons. This implies, though they have consented to such employment, moral significance does not hold to such treatment. Therefore, consent cannot be regarded to be of moral significance as these employees are not treated as persons. There might be an agreement that the consent of each individual is required to make an action morally significant. However, the happiness of such receivers is not promoted in this case, implying that such an action cannot be considered to be of moral uprightness.

In hypothetical consent, O’Neill (257) argues that sometimes, actual consent is not morally decisive even when the individual is well informed. This suggestion as O’Neill argues is true and applicable in many circumstances. The maturity of faculties in this case applies as the deciding factor. A person may consent to what they are not well conversant with, such as a form of treatment. A Doctor may ignore a

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1446344-kant
(Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1446344-kant.
“Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1446344-kant.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma

Confidentiality as an Ethical Dilemma

hellip; The essay "Confidentiality as an Ethical dilemma" shows the key facts that create an ethical dilemma when confidentiality must be breached.... This is the nature of an ethical dilemma in which confidentiality is an issue.... According to Stephen Behnke, APA ethics director, (2005), “confidentiality is the core value of the profession,” but when faced with an ethical dilemma, the APA Ethics Code can offer guidance in a difficult situation....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Making Ethical Decisions and Choices

Ethical decisions and choices are made by people in every day.... Ay work and at home, people have to choose between alternatives and find the best solutions in difficult life situations.... As people increasingly under public scrutiny, they find themselves exposed to complex ethical issues.... hellip; There are many ethical issues with which society struggles and points to ethical systems as tools that can be used to solve ethical dilemmas....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

What Exactly Is a Moral Dilemma

What exactly is a 'moral dilemma', and does one face it in everyday life A 'moral dilemma' is a situation where here is conflict and where an agent regards himself as being completely morally justified in doing what he is doing, while at the same time, carrying out the second option of the situation where he is in may not be possible.... hellip; The most crucial factor of a moral dilemma is therefore that the agent is required to carry out each of the two actions, the agent can carry out each of the actions, and the agent cannot perform both the actions....
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

Pro-life and Prochoice campaigns and the ethical dilemmas within them. Annotated Bibliography

The connotation “pro-life” that goes hand in hand with “pro-choice” are general episodes, which seeks to expound whether an individual is willing to carry out a certain agenda commonly, termed as an ethical dilemma.... Human beings are animals from international philosophical quarterly....
12 Pages (3000 words) Annotated Bibliography

Utilitarianism view on a dilemma

The ethical dilemma, which we have given, is a critical one.... According to this dilemma, if a ship is sinking and there is only one life boat on the ship.... In this situation, the dilemma is not of great number of goodness rather it can be explained using the lesser number of sorrow, pain or sadness while selecting anyone option....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Journalism designers code of ethics

The call to observe ethical responsibility with regard to manipulation of information also borrow a lot from the philosophical thoughts of Immanuel Kant as one of the important contributors to ethical thinking.... The present essay "Journalism designers code of ethics" dwells on the ethics issues....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Importance of Employee Language and Organisational Discourses

nbsp; In the critical analysis, these issues are again discussed from the writer's perspective within the context of highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of the article content and approach to pointing out these philosophical dilemmas.... he philosophical framework that guides the business and management research is a very important consideration and a fundamental component because it dictates the nature of the entire process.... The researcher may even be unaware of the philosophical basis of the research, but by knowing the precise stance the researcher is taking, the research aims, objectives, assumptions, perspectives, orientation, limitations, and so on, can be much better understood and grounded....
14 Pages (3500 words) Case Study

Ethical Dilemmas: School Counsellors

In this case, an ethical dilemma faced by the school counsellor is that he/she might end up requesting for information from the student that is no consistent with the aim of the entire counselling session (Iyer, 2010, p.... ne way for avoiding this dilemma from even occurring is that the counsellor needs to provide different caretakers of a child including the parent, teachers as well as the administration that it is highly important for the counsellor to keep the information gained confidential (Bodenhorn, 2006)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us