StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Assessment of Plato's two arguments about knowledge in the Meno and the Phaedo - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Instructor Course no. Date Deliberating on knowledge according to Plato’s Phaedo and Meno, respectively, the term “knowledge” lacks the one definition that encompasses in totality what knowledge is and what it entails. Philosophers have, for a long time, been at task to find the one definition that would cover knowledge completely, but that definition is still elusive…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Assessment of Platos two arguments about knowledge in the Meno and the Phaedo
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Assessment of Plato's two arguments about knowledge in the Meno and the Phaedo"

Download file to see previous pages

In both Meno and Phaedo, knowledge and learning are viewed as a recollection of what someone already knows. However, in Meno, Plato writes that knowledge is concerned with the recollection of necessary truths. In Phaedo, on the other hand, knowledge, according to Plato, is concerned with the acquisition of concepts, which are not necessarily truths (102b-c). In essence, Phaedo tries to imply that a person can gain knowledge simply by learning new concepts based on their individual opinions. The subject of debate in this essay is whether either form of knowledge can be independent of the other.

Can a person claim to have knowledge about a subject by simply recalling some prior truths, or can a person learn new concepts based on a recollection of prior opinions? The idea of recollection or anamnesis, according to Plato, holds that if at all a person remembers something, they must have had prior knowledge of the subject (73c). Plato, in Phaedo writes that the fact that a person can hear or see something and recognize it, and even think of something alike, is all based on anamnesis (74c).

In Phaedo, Plato gives an example of knowledge through recognition by stating that a person may see a lyre that reminds them of their lover (73c-e). In this context, the person’s recognition of a lyre is independent of them being reminded about their lover. However, there is a difference between seeing just any lyre and being reminded of one’s lover, and seeing a lyre belonging to one’s lover and being reminded of them. The alter explanation deals with a truth about the lover’s lyre, while the former introduces a new concept, with an opinion about any lyre.

In Phaedo, Plato also explains what recollection is all about suing the example of the equal itself (74c-d). Here, the argument is that one person may see two stones or sticks as equal, while another sees them as unequal. The equality of these objects may vary according to one’s opinion, but the equal itself is always equal, with no variations of equality. Fundamentally, this is to say that the two people both have prior truthful knowledge of what the equal itself is; what may differ, however, are their opinions concerning the equality of the objects.

The two cases above require some degree of recollection, although for the former, it is a recollection of a truth about the equal itself, while the latter deals with the recollection of a personal opinion about a subject. The knowledge about the truth of the equal itself that can never be unequal is the precondition for the opinion as to whether the objects in question are equal or unequal. From this analysis, it is safe to infer that knowledge acquisition is a progression from prior truth to opinions formed in reference to the said truth.

The seeing of one thing and being reminded of another, whether like or unlike, is what Plato refers to as anamnesis. However, a person can see something and instead of being reminded of another, they can create their own idea of something else that could be dissimilar from what they saw. This creation of an idea by a person is a new concept that does not necessarily come from a pre-existing truth. This argument, therefore, puts into doubt the idea that the pre-condition to being reminded is to have cognition of something.

This is a case of having knowledge through recollection of things that are

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Assessment of Plato's two arguments about knowledge in the Meno and Term Paper”, n.d.)
Assessment of Plato's two arguments about knowledge in the Meno and Term Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1477002-assessment-of-plato-s-two-arguments-about
(Assessment of Plato'S Two Arguments about Knowledge in the Meno and Term Paper)
Assessment of Plato'S Two Arguments about Knowledge in the Meno and Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1477002-assessment-of-plato-s-two-arguments-about.
“Assessment of Plato'S Two Arguments about Knowledge in the Meno and Term Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1477002-assessment-of-plato-s-two-arguments-about.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Assessment of Plato's two arguments about knowledge in the Meno and the Phaedo

Discuss the role of wisdom in true virtue according to Meno and the Phaedo

Both "Meno" and "Phaedo" comprise long and even complex arguments in a way of philosophical deliberation between teacher (Socrates) and disciples (meno and Phaedo respectively).... ?? (Plato (b)10) A unique concept of good and evil is put forward in phaedo.... phaedo propagates the idea of life beyond death by distinguishing between body and soul and how virtues applied wisely can lead to liberation of soul.... In phaedo, it is contended that when alive, the soul should try to control pleasures related with the sense organs and body in which it is rebuked to be animate and from which it seeks to liberate itself....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Plato's Meno

nbsp;One of the ideas presented in the meno is the Theory of Recollection.... This paper ''Plato's Meno'' tells that As one of Plato's earliest dialogues, the meno is known as one of the ancient Greek classics that revealed Plato's Theory of Forms and beliefs in a world which is separate from the material world.... hellip; One very significant part of the meno is that which demonstrates the Theory of Recollection, or the idea that “what appears to be learning something new is recollecting something already known” (Cohen, University of Washington), or what is known as the doctrine of anamnesis, which means that “all learning is [merely] recollection” (Samet, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Explain Plato's Method of Finding True Knowledge in Meno

Plato argues in the meno that knowledge is innate.... The doctrine of recollection states that the knowledge is not acquired through any senses or through the interactions of mind but it is gathered through recollection of realities in this life and previous lives.... Plato emphasizes that true knowledge of virtue is attainable through appropriate ways and methods.... Plato states that true belief coupled with rationality is knowledge and a true belief not motivated by a rational account is not knowledge....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Analysis of Phaedo by Plato

It also shows the attempt of Socrates to prove that his soul will remain alive after… “phaedo” is first of all one of the brightest documents in the cultural history of humanity.... These documents discuss the issues, which the majority of people are interested in: about life, body, soul, destiny of body and soul, “phaedo” by Plato “phaedo” should not be considered as purely philosophic creation.... “phaedo” is first of all one of the brightest documents in the cultural history of humanity....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Comparative Analysis of Russell's Theory of Knowledge and Plato's Doctrine of Anamnesis

Russell's theory defines knowledge in that for an individual to discuss knowledge, one must be able to know the definition of a belief and the definition of a fact.... This study discusses the pursuit of comparing the theory of knowledge by Russell and anamnesis doctrine by Pluto it is important to understand the concept knowledge, how to acquire it and how it affects our daily to daily living.... hellip;  In philosophy, anamnesis is the idea that human beings have knowledge from past incarnations and that learning consists of rediscovering the knowledge within us....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

The Phaedo by Plato

This paper “Plato's phaedo” will seek to examine the viability of the claim that all learning is a process of recollection in relation to the other claims made by Socrates that support the notion.... hellip; The author states that all learning is a process of recollection since we are born with a lot of knowledge, which we forget at birth, and thus we can be made to remember all this knowledge through a process of proper questioning....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Socrates Four Arguments for the Immortality of the Soul in the Phaedo

'Socrates' Four Arguments for the Immortality of the Soul in the phaedo" paper compares the myth of the true earth in the phaedo with the allegory of the cave in Plato's republic.... nbsp;… In phaedo, Plato presents one of the classic dialogues in Philosophy in which Socrates on his last day illustrated the immortality of the soul using four lines of argument.... In other words, opposites coexist at the same instant (likened to two bodies sharing ahead), and there is a perpetual cyclical change between them as they are continuously generated from each other....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Phaedo, the Trial and Death of Plato's Teacher

This book review "Phaedo, the Trial and Death of plato's Teacher" tells us about one of the best-known dialogues of plato's middle period.... hellip; phaedo notes that, though the death was astonishing to experience, he never had pity regarding it, considering that Socrates had happily and bravely faced death without being afraid of the unknown.... At this point, phaedo takes the opportunity to emphasize the absence of Plato on the occurrence due to illness....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us