StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of God - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
An essay "Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of God" claims that Descartes studies about God were to show that God is not a deceiver, and he aims to bring a clear perception in our minds. Descartes gives two arguments for the existence of God…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of God
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of God"

Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of God Descartes is one of the most renowned philosophers, he was of French origin and his studies centered in Mathematics. Having finished his law degree Descartes would eventually move into seclusion in the Netherlands, where he would frequently change his address to conceal himself. Descartes produced many publications and he would delay his publication to avoid criticisms. His most notable studies centered on the truth about God and his existence where his work aimed at bringing God into the picture, his publications were based on his dreams Prado, (Prado, 2009). Descartes studies about God were to show that God is not a deceiver, and he aims to bring a clear perception in our minds. In his ontological arguments, Descartes gives two arguments about the existence of God. He sets to prove about the existence of God in these two arguments. In his first argument, Descartes states that God is a perfect being and that to exist than not to exist is the perfect thing and God must therefore exist. These were properly based on his early dreams and he set out to document them. The Descartes second argument is the most complex of the two. In his publications, he distinctively sets out two forms of reality. In believing that his thoughts were innate, Descartes thought that his perceptions and the way he sees God should not be objected. He points out that God is an infinite being and that reality come in the forms of infinite, modal and finite. Descartes sees God as existing in infinite reality. He further asserts that all substances by virtue of their existence posses’ finite formal reality and that all ideas that occur in any phase of thought posses modal form of reality. Ideas, as he puts that have a form of reality which, when they are put in relation to the objects that they represent must have an objective form of reality. He further points out that these objective realities are of three forms, which mirror the formal realities dependent on the amount of reality contained in the object that those ideas represent. Basing his ideas on objective reality, Descartes argues using his inner reasoning that God is an objective finite being. He further bases his ideas on inner logical thoughts to state that something can come from nothing. On this basis, Descartes arrived at two major principles: Effect must be preceded by a cause of a reality A cause in an idea must possess as much reality as there is an objective reality in a particular idea Descartes concluded that since we possess the idea of God, there must be a finite being that causes objective ideas, which in effect means that God exists. Criticisms One of the attacks on the philosophy of Descartes about God concerns the use of God in order to justify distinctions in his idea of perceptions. The objection comes from “Cartesian Circle” in which Descartes uses distinct perceptions to show God’s existence and that the existence of God arise due to his distinct perceptions (Prado, 2009). His ideas provide a kind of revolving ideas which tend to explain one another, forming what has been referred to as “Cartesian Circle”. Many critics have questioned Descartes use of the idea of God’s existence in order to prove his ideas of perceptions. Descartes in his thoughts, however, appear not to be foolish but truth. His ideas actually state in particular that it is not due to the existence of God that we will believe in clear and distinct perceptions. Clear and distinct perceptions are always true; in effect, we only need God so that we can erase any doubts that may arise. Based on Descartes principle, we use the idea of distinct and clear perceptions to prove the existence of God after which we do not have to go back to these ideas to be sure they are absolute truth. One other major criticism on Descartes postulations on existence of God is his ontological arguments. Many critics believe that Descartes ontological arguments are untrue to some extent possessing some ideas that raise room for doubts. Ontological arguments play a critical role in Cartesian rationalism and helps in creating certainty in arguments. Ontology date back to medieval philosophers like Plato and Socrates. In order for ontological arguments to be true, they must have a clear ending. However, the only entity that is his own explanation is God, so for any ontological explanation to be true, it must present God to be his own explanation. The idea of self-causing create an idea of self-explanatory by pointing to a fact that in order to explain a fact you need another and for the resulting fact, you need another, all in succession until you reach an end where you have a fact that explains itself. These self-causing arguments possess many problems. Descartes in his works, based on ontological arguments presents an easy way to criticize. Descartes claims for the existence of a kind of special reality, which he terms “object reality”, are ontologically untrue. According to Descartes, he assumes that, in fact, reality sort of come in a series of grades, which are loaded metaphysically, a notion that is arguable. Descartes major postulations are not true since none of us possess clear innate and distinct idea of God as being infinitely perfect. Descartes Meditation Meditations form the basis of modern philosophy among western scholars. Descartes postulations still raise heated arguments to date, his famous work occurs where he turns Aristotelian principles upside down. In breaking Aristotelian assertions, Descartes cites that knowledge comes from the senses, where he comes with a completely new concept about the mind. In his first meditation, Descartes clearly displays philosophical skepticism, (Descartes & Moriarty, 2008). In his first meditation, he starts by asking himself how he can be sure of anything, then he goes and gives a myriad of outlandish and inventive assertions why he had to develop mistrust on his senses. His ideas have sparked continuous debate in philosophical outlook. This controversy has led to greater studies, by philosophers; into the way, body and mind interact. In conclusion, Descartes was more of a rationalist than empiricists who included Aristotle and Locke. Descartes stated that the perceptions, which are distinct and clear, are the only means that the intellect can gain knowledge. He also points out the fact that senses are meant to guide us navigate the universe practically rather than give us some knowledge.However, as stated earlier above, Descartes assertions of God are insufficient in their explanations as shown by the ontological proofs. The most important aspects of Descartes publications are the Wax argument, his theory of ideas and the Cartesian circle, they form the basis of good philosophical discussions. References Descartes, R., & Moriarty, M. (2008). Meditations on first philosophy: with selections from the Objections and replies. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Prado, C. G. (2009). Starting with Descartes. London: Continuum. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of Essay - 94”, n.d.)
Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of Essay - 94. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1653244-essay
(Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of Essay - 94)
Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of Essay - 94. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1653244-essay.
“Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of Essay - 94”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1653244-essay.
  • Cited: 2 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of God

Descartes Meditations

Descartes examined the existence of god.... In the third meditation, Descartes seeks to examine the existence of god.... Because the existence of god is no bases on any assumptions, (it is an idea) then there is no base to evaluate its falsehood.... Then it follows that, in his clear thought, he has an idea of God with certain characteristics, then existence of god is true.... Since his idea of god extended beyond the finite, it could not have originated from himself as a finite being....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Descartes' Discourse on the Method (Part IV)

Descartes then makes a surprise turn to prove the existence of god and after the proof, God becomes the metaphysical foundation of the knowledge of all external things.... This paper analysis and evaluates Descartes discourse method in part four and focuses on how Descartes deviated from proving his own existence as the basis of all knowledge to prove the existence of god as the source of truth.... hellip; This therefore serves as the first principle of his Philosophy....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Concept of God with Particular Reference

It is no surprise that Classical theistic concepts of God fundamentally propose the existence of god.... One can begin here to see the entirety with which classical theists tend to view the extent of the existence of god.... But can one capture a more specific concept of omnipotence, of the deeper concept of the existence of god?... hile one recognizes that the task at hand is not to merely describe how Aquinas depicts the existence of god, and which arguments he refers to in order to strengthen his theory, it is also valuable in understanding further his theory....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Descartess Arguments Regarding the Existence of God

What things remain… Do you agree that he salvages the foundations of knowledge that he undercut using Method of Doubt? Descartes's argument regarding the existence of god in the Meditations comes in the framework of his larger philosophical project in which he attempts to establish a Adrian Musiuk Josh Keton CORC 1210/ MW8 Topic Descartes eventually proposes that God's necessary existence allows him to be free of doubt with respect to many things.... Descartes's argument regarding the existence of god in the Meditations comes in the framework of his larger philosophical project in which he attempts to establish a basis for the very act of knowing....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Rene Descartes Epistemological Theory

He arrives at one single idea that the only thing he cannot question its existence is his very existence.... The argument he relays for the proof of his existence is the idea that he thinks.... To begin with, Rene descartes epistemological theory comes into practice.... In his discourse theory, descartes strives to arrive at true knowledge.... Rene descartes finds that almost all of preexisting knowledge, with exception of mathematical principles, is liable to doubt (Timmons and Shoemaker 284)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Descartes and the Existence of God

This paper “Descartes and the existence of god” will attempt to determine the grounds that Descartes uses to ascertain his own existence as a way of proving God's existence.... nbsp; Descartes meditation about the existence of god cannot be used to serve as proof of the existence of an Evil Demon.... This is because Descartes establishes a clear line of thought that is specific to his a priori existence of god.... Therefore, this would mean that Descartes could claim the existence of god but refrain from making any assertions on whether or not some Evil Demon actually exists....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Decarts and existence of evil

In this same case, it should be realized that there are… Descartes argument for the existence of god cannot be stretched to apply to another argument regarding the existence of an Evil Demon.... Therefore, this would mean that Descartes could claim the existence of god but refrain from making any suggestions on whether or not some Evil Demon actually exists (Marion, 2008).... The existence of god, according to Descartes, is a “gift”  In this way, the knowledge of such must be based on distinct...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Existence of God

nbsp; One of the first things that Descartes proved in his philosophical questioning reported in Meditation III of Discourse on Method was that he had a basic idea of the existence of god.... hellip; This essay demonstrates that the nature of god's being cannot be imagined and certainly not positively identified; therefore the proof must be found in observing events that could occur only as the result of a creator.... The question regarding the true nature of god, whether He actually exists....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us