StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Devolution Will Inevitably Lead to an Independent Scotland - Literature review Example

Summary
"Devolution Will Inevitably Lead to an Independent Scotland" paper examines the arguments for and against the idea that devolution will inevitably lead to an independent Scotland rather than the federal United Kingdom. Scotland had a long history as an independent country with its parliament…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Devolution Will Inevitably Lead to an Independent Scotland
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Devolution Will Inevitably Lead to an Independent Scotland"

192244 Politics - Assessment Two Devolution will inevitably lead to an independent Scotland - Discuss The following will examine the arguments forand against the idea that devolution will inevitably lead to an independent Scotland rather than a federal United Kingdom. Scotland had a long history as an independent country with its parliament prior to the Act of Union of 1707 with England. Ironically the Act of Union came towards the end of the Stuart dynasty’s rule over England, Scotland, and Ireland. The Stuarts had after all been the Scots royal family that had taken over England and Ireland, yet England would dominate the United Kingdom. For much of the subsequent three centuries the majority of the Scottish people seemed to be content with remaining within the United Kingdom. However the popular support for either devolution or full independence from the Westminster government grew from the 1960s (Fisher, Denver, & Benyon, 2003 p. 14). Increased support for devolution or independence was caused by resentment in the way the revenues from North Sea oil were spent by Westminster as well as the growing perception that the British government was concerned about looking after England and the English (Schama, 2002 p. 549). The Conservative governments between 1979 and 1997 further increased support for devolution as well as for independence due to their apparent neglect of Scotland and its social and economic problems. New Labour quickly devolved government in Scotland after it came to power in 1997 (http://www.scotland.gov.uk/home). There are certainly groups and individuals that argue or publicly state that devolution would lead inevitably to an independent Scotland within a relative short period of time (Jones B & Kavanagh, 2003 p. 10). Ironically it is the strongest supporters as well as the strongest opponents of Scottish independence that have made the most arguments about devolution inevitably leading to an independent Scotland (Young, 2003 p. 200). The most vocal opponents of devolution in Scotland (and Wales as well) were the Conservative party, although it was their unpopular policies such as the poll tax that had made devolution a certainty once they had lost control of power at Westminster (Coxall, Robins, & Leach, 2003 p.35). The Conservatives had successfully resisted calls for devolution between 1979 and 1997 because of their Westminster majority, yet they had not done a great deal to antagonise the Scottish electorate. Such as not reversing economic decline, spending North Sea oil revenues on keeping people throughout Britain unemployed, and introducing the poll tax a year earlier in Scotland than in the rest of the United Kingdom (Lynch, 2001 p. 1). The unpopularity of the Conservatives had meant that there were no Conservative MPs in Scotland after 1992, yet the Major government still made decisions that affected Scotland directly until it lost power. The Conservatives were the only mainstream political party to campaign against devolution in 1998 on the grounds that the Scottish National Party (SNP) could use it as a stepping stone to an independent Scotland (http; //www.scotlandoffice.gov.uk/index.html). Devolution according to the Conservatives will eventually lead to the end of the United Kingdom, as the SNP will at some point in the future succeed in making Scotland independent. By arguing that devolution would inevitably lead Scotland to full independence was meant to deter people from supporting its adoption in 1998, that was an electoral tactic that failed (Moran, 2005 p. 50). The SNP were also very vocal in stating that devolution would inevitably lead to Scotland becoming independent, which is precisely the objective that the party wishes to achieve. The SNP’s leadership believed that it was sensible to campaign in favour of devolution in 1998 alongside New Labour and the Liberal Democrats as it would improve the prospects of them being able to lead Scotland towards full independence from the United Kingdom. It is obviously in the best interests of the SNP to talk up the prospects of full independence being inevitably achieved once a devolved Scottish government was established in Edinburgh. The SNP was hoping that New Labour would at some point lose its long-established position as the most popular single political party in Scotland (Young, 2003 p. 200). Whilst the SNP leadership also considered that there was a strong possibility that the proportional representation electoral system used in the Scottish Parliament elections would improve the party’s chances of gaining control of power in Scotland, and eventually holding a referendum on the issue of independence (Keating, 2005 p. 10). New Labour’s widespread unpopularity and the apathy of voters towards it meant that the SNP was able to become the single largest party within the Scottish Parliament in the elections of 2007. The SNP’s strong position means that its leadership is currently keen on holding a referendum on full independence as soon as possible. However it could not be taken for granted that any such referendum would automatically lead to independence, though that would be the best possible outcome for the SNP. Politics is as much an art of taking all available opportunity, as of attempting to predict what is inevitable and what is not. With hindsight some events seem to be inevitable, whilst it is harder to predict future events with foresight (Schama, 2002 p. 549). There are arguments that devolution in Scotland will not inevitably lead to full independence from the United Kingdom, even if it could make it more of a possibility than before it happened. New Labour and the Liberal Democrats supported the adoption of a devolved government in Scotland because they believed devolution would strengthen the United Kingdom rather than inevitably lead to Scotland becoming independent. Their belief was that refusing to grant Scotland devolution that was in fact more likely to lead to Scottish independence than introducing a devolved parliament based in Edinburgh. The gist of this argument is that devolved government gives the Scottish people greater benefits than the old unitary system did, and also more than full independence would give them as well (Coxall, Robins, & Leach, 2003 p. 10). Devolution gives the voters of Scotland a greater influence over their own future whilst at the same time allowing them access to the larger level of resources of the whole of the United Kingdom than the more modest revenues of Scotland on its own (http://www.fco.gov.uk/). It could be added to this point that the revenue derived from North Sea oil and gas will continue to decline as supplies near complete exhaustion making it more difficult for an independent Scotland to finance current levels of expenditure on public services and social security benefits (http; //www.scotlandoffice.gov.uk/index.html). The English taxpayers would of course not be available to subsidise such expenditure as they do at present, whilst independence could prove to be unpopular in England (Schama, 2002 p. 549). Just because the SNP were the largest party after the 2007 Scottish elections does not automatically mean that Scotland will become independent, or that the Scottish voters will approve independence in any future referendum on that issue. Besides New Labour, the Liberal Democrats, and the Conservatives would vigorously campaign against independence. Lower voter turnout and the unpopularity of New Labour could adequately explain the SNP’s recent successes. Voting SNP as a protest vote against New Labour is not the same as wholehearted support for independence (http; //www.scotlandoffice.gov.uk/index.html). To conclude it is not proven beyond doubt that the introduction of a devolved government will inevitably lead to Scotland becoming independent. The Conservatives have argued that devolution would inevitably make Scotland an independent country once again, as the SNP would at some point take advantage of it. The SNP certainly believe that devolution will increase their chances of being able to achieve Scottish independence sooner rather later. For their part New Labour and the Liberal Democrats have argued that devolution has made Scotland less likely to become independent instead of making it inevitable. Bibliography Coxall B, Robins L & Leach R (2003) Contemporary British Politics 4th edition, Palgrave, London Fisher J, Denver D, & Benyon J, (2003) Central Debates in British Politics, Longman, London Jones B & Kavanagh D (2003) British Politics Today Keating M (2005) The Government of Scotland, Edinburgh. Lynch P (2001) Scottish Government & Politics, an introduction. Moran M, (2005) Politic and Governance in the UK, Palgrave, Basingstoke Schama S, (2002) A History of Britain 3 – the End of Empire 1776-2000, BBC, London Young H, (2003) supping with the Devils – Political writing from Thatcher to Blair, Guardian Books, London http://www.scotland.gov.uk/home http; //www.scotlandoffice.gov.uk/index.html http; //www.scottish.parliament.uk/home.htm http://www.fco.gov.uk/ Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Devolution Will Inevitably Lead to an Independent Scotland

Impact of Devolution on Britain and the Nature of Englishness

Since 1997, United Kingdom has been undergoing devolution as regards its 4 member states, England, Wales, Northern Ireland, and scotland.... This dissertation "Impact of devolution on Britain and the Nature of Englishness" conducts a study to comprehend the nature of this dual existence in post-devolution England, in order to comprehend the changing equations between 'Britishness' and 'Englishness,' under the new conditions.... Recent studies have revealed that post-devolution survey data do not show any decline in the nationalistic 'British,' identity within England pointing to the existence of dual identities....
62 Pages (15500 words) Dissertation

Relate some of the key concepts of the classical perspectives

However, Enlightenment thinkers were also active in most major European states a day, including, in particular, in scotland.... Marx summarized the key elements of this materialist view of history as follows: In the social production of their existence, men inevitably enter into definite relations, which are independent of their will, namely relations of production appropriate to a given stage in the development of their material forces of production....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

American Colonies Political Science Research Paper

American Colonies History and Political Science 14-09-11 American Colonies Introduction: The Kingdom of England and the Kingdom of scotland began the colonization of America in the year 1607 in Virginia and soon such colonies were established throughout the entire America.... On the other hand, American colonies lacked representation in the government which inevitably led to insecurity among the Americans....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Children - Parents Problem in King Lear

Although the playwright has taken a very specific and limited subject as a matter of treatment in the drama, consequently, within such limited scope of interpretation he also has attempted to show different layers of human existence and how impulsive or biased judgments, blinded by pride or prejudice can lead to catastrophe....
10 Pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review

Buses in Scotland as Aspects of Sustainable Transport Mode

This thesis "Buses in scotland as Aspects of Sustainable Transport Mode" talks about the aspects of sustainability that are related to a specific industry, the bus industry; it is in this context that sustainable policies in scotland will be evaluated and criticized.... The bus is an essential means of transport in scotland; because of its importance for the local social needs but also for the environment, the Scottish government has developed a framework of rules regulating the bus operators across the country....
34 Pages (8500 words) Thesis

Collapse of SME in Tourism and Hospitality

The paper "Collapse of SME in Tourism and Hospitality" deals with the collapse of a small and medium-sized company within the industry of tourism and hospitality.... It commences with a deep insight into the present trends of tourism and the definitions of small and medium-sized industries.... ... ...
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Is Parliamentary Sovereignty Still Applicable Today As It Was Previously

here has been some debate concerning whether parliament is independent of the other organs of state or whether it is supreme to them.... This paper "Is Parliamentary Sovereignty Still Applicable Today As It Was Previously?... focuses on the debate that has been going on since the time when the monarchy and the government, in general, were placed under the control of parliament and true democracy started to be practised in Britain....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Should Scotland Be Independent

"Should scotland Be Independent" paper establishes whether scotland should be given independence to run its affairs as a sovereign nation.... The paper establishes solid reasons that favor scotland's independence, reasons for objection, and finally, proceed to draw an informed conclusion.... scotland's history dates back to the onset of civilization.... In effect, scotland would merge with Great Britain.... The supporters were pleased that England and scotland that had initially been querulous would unite forging a way for peaceful co-existence (Hawkins, 2012)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us