StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Is Cultural Pluralism a Viable and Valid Way to Deal with Diversity in the United States - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper tells that in the last one hundred years there has not been a unified national identity in the USA and a unified national identity is neither possible nor desirable today. Arguably, there was no national identity even at the time of the Revolution and the birth of the United States…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Is Cultural Pluralism a Viable and Valid Way to Deal with Diversity in the United States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Is Cultural Pluralism a Viable and Valid Way to Deal with Diversity in the United States"

Is cultural pluralism a viable and valid way to deal with diversity in the United States? Cultural pluralism is a viable and valid way, even a necessary way of dealing with diversity in the United States. In the last one hundred years there has not been a unified national identity in the United States and a unified national identity is neither possible nor desirable today. Arguably, there was no national identity even at the time of the Revolution and the birth of the United States. One could argue that there was a national identity that unified the American colonies in their opposition to Great Britain in the last decades of the eighteenth-century. However, that was a unity against Great Britain rather than a unity within the newly formed United States. The colonists were unified in their opposition to 'taxation without representation' and other impositions that they felt membership in the British Empire was imposing on them. However, beyond that shared belief there was already a great deal of diversity in the United States. First, there were the indigenous peoples and the African-American population. Both of these groups were excluded from participating in the governance of the new nation (as were women). This alone is evidence of diversity. On another level even the European immigrants newly arrived in North America brought with them diverse cultures. Many were religious dissenters such as William Penn and the Quakers that founded Pennsylvania and the Puritans that had founded the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. Manhattan had been founded by the Dutch and there was still a large number of people of Dutch heritage who spoke Dutch in the area at the time of the Revolution. The Constitution itself also speaks to the diversity within the United States over 200 hundred years ago. In light of the diversity of the newly formed United States the Constitution specifically ruled out the establishment of a state, official religion and guaranteed freedom of religion. The first phrase in the First Amendment states, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” Religious diversity was an aspect of American national identity from the birth of the United States. The Constitution also recognizes that the former colonies, now states, are each unique. Each state maintained control over specific aspects of life and government within the state and and Article 4. of the Constitution, “The States” outlines the autonomy and independence that states maintain, “Full Faith and Credit shall be given in each State to the public Acts, Records, and judicial Proceedings of every other State.” In other words, each state is responsible for respecting the unique laws of every other state, this is, by definition, diversity. This issue of 'states' rights' came to the fore in the debate over slavery. The agrarian economy of the South was based on slavery while in the industrializing northern states slavery was a less important social institution. The Civil War can be seen as an expression of this division within American society and the determination of the southern states to maintain their 'unique institution' of slavery. This cleavage between agrarian, slave-owning southern states and industrializing, capitalist northern states, is evidence of diversity. In this instance it was a cleavage or difference that brought the nation to Civil War before it was resolved. This is clear evidence of significant diversity in the United States 150 years ago. In the wake of the Civil War immigration to the United States from diverse areas of Europe increased and so did national diversity. The term melting pot is often used to describe the immigrant experience in the United States, but the reality has always been much different. A brief survey of criminal history of the United States is a convenient way to highlight this diversity. During the Prohibition era the gangs that controlled illicit alcohol sales were divided by ethnicity. In Chicago there was the Irish gang of Dion O'Banion and the Italian gangs led by Al Capone. In New York there were Jewish gangs led by Meyer Lansky, Arnold Rothstein (famous for fixing the 1919 World Series and the Chicago 'Black' Sox scandal) and Bugsy Siegel. The Mafia, an Italian criminal organization, is known within the Italian community as "Cosa Nostra" ("Our thing")- this name alone speaks to diversity. This ethnic division in criminality was evident before Prohibition and is portrayed in the movie, “The Gangs of New York” and persists today in the newly formed ethnic gangs such as the "Russkaya Mafiya"; Chicano gangs like the “Varrio Nuevo Estrada” (VNE) and the “Sureños”; and, African-American gangs like the “Crips” and the “Bloods'. (And also in television shows like “The Sopranos”. Moreover, this diversity is evident in far more than criminal behavior. Immigrants tend to settle in ethnic communities, find work through ethnically similar contacts and develop commercial interests – from grocery stores to banks and travel agencies – catering to their ethnic community. This is entirely understandable and reasonable. It also maintains ethnic identity and, by implication, encourages diversity and cultural diversity rather than the proverbial melting pot. This multicultural milieu has been further diversified with waves of new immigrants in the wake of the Vietnam War, Latinos arriving from throughout South and Central America, eastern Europeans and former residents of the Soviet Union and most recently, Muslim and African immigrants and refugees. The concept of America being a melting pot has always been more of a myth than a reality. As the sources of immigrants to the United States continues to diversify so too does the population of the United States. References The United States Constitution. 10 December 2010. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is Cultural Pluralism a Viable and Valid Way to Deal with Diversity in Research Paper”, n.d.)
Is Cultural Pluralism a Viable and Valid Way to Deal with Diversity in Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1747114-cultural-pluralism
(Is Cultural Pluralism a Viable and Valid Way to Deal With Diversity in Research Paper)
Is Cultural Pluralism a Viable and Valid Way to Deal With Diversity in Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1747114-cultural-pluralism.
“Is Cultural Pluralism a Viable and Valid Way to Deal With Diversity in Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1747114-cultural-pluralism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is Cultural Pluralism a Viable and Valid Way to Deal with Diversity in the United States

Pluralism in Management Research

Generally when managers adapt pluralism in management research, they are inevitably engaged with diversity and multiplicity (Werner, 2002).... At the initial level, all managers find pluralism a difficult approach to adopt in management research, but when fruits of... Philosophical Assumptions of Pluralism in Management Research According to the contemporary literature, pluralism is a philosophical school of thought that is composed of four different elements - diversity, understanding, commitment and dialogue....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Consequences of Pluralism According to Pfeffer's View

The paper describes the dual effects of the value placed on theoretical and methodological diversity and participation.... As in other contexts, there are trade-offs involved; this is not to say that the trade-offs should be made in one way rather than another.... For organizational science, the kind of freedom to expand, reach out, realize itself like an ageing upstart making its way down the path to renaissance even under a stodgily normative paradigm - if only that paradigm was a finished product....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Issue of Cultural Diversity

Cultural diversity is therefore the… The broadest meaning of the term basically has to promote and acknowledge cultural pluralism.... According to Gay, cultural diversity is a key element of human identity and can be said to be a common property of humanity (12).... Nonetheless, equating the identity of human with cultural diversity implies having to acknowledge that the notion of diversity itself entails the This is because without unity, cultural diversity would then turn into cultural multiplicity....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Unity and pluralism

Cowell Lane, united Kingdom.... Lastly one has to try and engage with the diversity around.... In this respect, the greatest principle in a pluralistic society is the principle of accommodation as noted by How to Achieve Unity in a Pluralist How to Achieve Unity in a Pluralist pluralism in society is the acceptance of the diverse human beliefs and ways of life (Held, 2006).... or a society practicing pluralism, the existence of peace, understanding and unity is difficult to achieve, though not impossible....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Cultural Pluralism in the US

the united states is perhaps the most plural in terms of all kinds of people from different ethnicities, backgrounds, cultures, religions and countries.... So many people have migrated to America over the years creating diversity in culture.... Politically, the diversity in culture has enabled the representation of all minorities in the government.... From the paper "cultural pluralism in the US" it is clear that cultural diversity has been a great way of ensuring that people are well identified with their different beliefs....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Cultural pluralism (Project 1)

Asian Americans have been struggling to compete in several areas especially in education and job fields (Zhan, 2003).... However, recent studies have indicated that Asian… The following interview gives an overview of the situation of Asian Americans in the U.... . “I cannot complain.... We have lived happily However, I cannot deny the fact that life has been challenging especially with the issue of my parents securing good jobs....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Phenomenon of Religious Pluralism

By the proponents of this viewpoint, the salvation for all the people was envisaged by the God; "Designated The Phenomenon of Religious Pluralism Religious pluralism is a diversity of beliefs, each of which claims to be right, and often denies the right for being true of the other religions.... he self-assessment of the Christianity, in context of pluralism varied from insisting on its exclusivity to the recognition of the other religions - and is still not fully defined....
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

Pluralism and Democracy

Many scholars argue the importance of cultural pluralism as well.... This type of pluralism overlaps with the domain of decentralized decisionmaking (Barber, 1963)Finally, there is one more type of pluralism in social pluralism, which was defined by Lipset and Kornhauser in terms of “diversity arising from modernization” (Kornhauser, 1959).... Thie author of this paper "pluralism and Democracy" focuses on investigating the notion of pluralism, how pluralism informs the decision-making of liberal democracies, and its influence on liberal democracies....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us