StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Main topic is: Is Abortion wrong , and the branch topic is Marquis and His Critics - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
Is Abortion Wrong If it isn’t a baby, then you aren't pregnant, so what are you aborting?  Author Unknown Issue of abortion is usually seen from two different ethical perspectives, that of a fetus and that of relationship between a fetus and a pregnant woman…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
The Main topic is: Is Abortion wrong , and the branch topic is Marquis and His Critics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Main topic is: Is Abortion wrong , and the branch topic is Marquis and His Critics"

Is Abortion Wrong If it isn’t a baby, then you aren't pregnant, so what are you aborting?  Unknown Issue of abortion is usually seen from twodifferent ethical perspectives, that of a fetus and that of relationship between a fetus and a pregnant woman. The position that abortion is morally impermissible is based on two premises: 1) human fetus has the same right to life as an adult human being; and 2) if we agree with premise number one, it means that abortion is morally impermissible as it means depriving a fetus of life or, as Don Marquis refers to, “future-like-ours”.

One of the major arguments against abortion is based on the principle that killing (no matter whom) is morally wrong in the first place. Human fetus is morally and ethically equaled to an adult human being. Therefore, killing an innocent unborn baby is morally wrong. In his essay Why Abortion is Immoral Marquis proves that the most of the deliberate abortions are morally wrong and, hence, impermissible. However, Marquis’ major argument against abortion was met with much criticism. Loss of one’s life (plans, dreams, projects, activities, etc.) is one of the greatest losses of humanity.

Abortion is the direct pass to such a loss, while life itself is like a gift we receive only once. Therefore, abortion is morally wrong. Furthermore, since killing leads to no future, it is morally wrong. The major arguments here are based on “the personhood theories of the wrongness of killing” (Whats Wrong? Applied Ethicists and Their Critics 63). All the anti-abortion arguments mentioned above lead to the inference that killing potential person is as wrong as killing actual person. Such logical reasoning on the issue is similar to the argument presented for the wrongness of infliction of pain on animals.

Marquis’ arguments presented in his essay were to prove that abortion is prima facie wrong that does not cover each and every case of abortion. In section IV of his essay the author discuses property of value of a fetus. Lack of value which comes from a valuer implies that a fetus cannot value his future. However, a person attempting to commit suicide also lacks value of his/her life, which is a good counter argument to the anti-abortion statement mentioned above. Marquis discusses issue of contraception from the perspective of future-like-ours argument.

He clearly concludes that contraception is not actually killing of anybody and hence is not morally wrong (or as wrong) as abortion itself when a baby is already conceived. Personally, I think that lack of some adult property or value of future of a fetus (because it is too young and, to some extent, unconscious of his values), does not really give anybody a right to kill the would-be adult human being. If to ask anyone of us, “would you be happy if your mom agreed to abortion when you were tiny fetus inside her?

”, very few (unhappy ones) would reply positively. Gerald H. Paske presents criticism of Marquis anti-abortion argument in his essay Abortion and the Neo-Natal Right to Life. So, he argues that Marquis’s argument based on the concept having future-like-ours is “neither a sufficient nor a necessary condition for having a right to life” (Whats Wrong? Applied Ethicists and Their Critics 63). In his argumentation Paske compares Marquis’s reasoning about immorality of abortion with euthanasia.

Moreover, Paske claims that Marquis’s arguments about neonates who are not fully developed persons are unsound (p. 74). Furthermore, the author makes a parallel between contraption and abortion. If abortion is morally wrong, so must be contraception. Paske concludes since neonates do not have brains yet (death of brain constitutes biological death of a person), they lack consciousness. It is matter of potentiality. Finally, he concludes that “since a potential person is not a person, its loss is not equivalent to the loss of a person”.

I agree to such a conclusion, but I disagree that such thinking justifies abortion and gives the right to kill unborn babies. Only at the end of the author talks about woman, persons who are, in most cases, responsible for making a final decision whether to do abortion or not. I think that a woman’s interests and rights have to be respected. Only existing risk to woman’s life can be the only justifiable argument to make abortion. After having read these two essays representing opposite views on the issue, I have made a conclusion that I belong to the group of philosophers who are against abortion.

Works Cited Whats Wrong? Applied Ethicists and Their Critics, 2nd ed., David Boonin & Graham Oddie, eds., Oxford U. Press 2010.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Main topic is: Is Abortion wrong , and the branch topic is Marquis Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1406054-the-main-topic-is-is-abortion-wrong-and-the-branch
(The Main Topic Is: Is Abortion Wrong , and the Branch Topic Is Marquis Book Report/Review)
https://studentshare.org/other/1406054-the-main-topic-is-is-abortion-wrong-and-the-branch.
“The Main Topic Is: Is Abortion Wrong , and the Branch Topic Is Marquis Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1406054-the-main-topic-is-is-abortion-wrong-and-the-branch.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Main topic is: Is Abortion wrong , and the branch topic is Marquis and His Critics

Why Abortion is Wrong

hellip; This paper will begin with the statement that the moral standing of abortion has long been a topic of debate among scientists, doctors, and philosophers.... The author of the paper states that abortion is a very dangerous practice that essentially speaks of the morally retrograded society.... It is not only murder of the child but is also extremely dangerous for the health of the mother that undergoes an abortion.... Owing to the difficulties associated with the modern way of living, increased cost of living and the extra-marital affairs, the percentage of people that opt for an abortion is increasing rapidly....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

The Performance of the Saudi Media and Bahraini Conflict

6.... Discussion This study commenced from the premise that the performance of the Saudi media was in accordance to the authoritarian press model during the occurrence of Bahraini conflict.... It is a general hypothesis that the Saudi media would be subject to censorship during the coverage of the Bahraini conflict, in particular during the actual riots and protests that took place at the streets of Bahrain and that the coverage of the Bahraini conflict would be influenced by lobby groups such like those led by religious leaders, in addition to national pride and patriotism, who would apply pressure in order to either support or oppose the policy of the administration in the wake of the opposition … aggression....
17 Pages (4250 words) Dissertation

Abortion: Is it right or wrong

o bolster their position, the Churches have the support of pro-life movements and politicians … Abortion: Right or wrong?... Warren and Don Marquiz To explain the position of Mary Anne Warren, the fetus for her is not a person, and so ending its life is not morally wrong.... Major religious institutions, including Christian Churches, strongly oppose abortion along the theological reason that fetuses have souls.... abortion is still much debated, even if timely abortion has been legalized in some advanced countries like the United States....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Under what conditions is abortion morally acceptable

Under what conditions is abortion morally acceptable?... A central part of his essay is the idea of ‘potentiality' of a developing fetus.... Dan marquis' essay “Why Abortion is Immoral” clearly suggests that the author looks cannot see any genuine moral grounds for permitting abortion.... This is so, marquis argues, as terminating a fetus deprives it of all potential experience of life and happiness – the same rationale applied for sentencing those committing homicide....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Risk Assessment and Management

Every project carries an element of risk with it.... The risk can be either qualitative or quantitative or both.... If the risk is higher the project will tend to be in uncertainty.... Therefore controlling the quantum of risk is essential for the conception of a project and its steady growth.... hellip; This essay attempts to analyse the processes of project risk management and gives an insight to the development of strategies to overcome the risk factor with the help of data regarding anticipated risk and the assessment of its probabilities....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

New Expectations in the US Market

In the light of these, this paper deals with one topic entitled ‘new expectations in the U.... One after the other, the iconic financial institutions of capitalism across the world, are falling abreast banishment the Fed… It is the typical abnormality of a financial crisis: abortion of one bank inflicting losses on the added bank that lent monies to it, which in about-face may abort to accord its debts, inflicting losses on its This abrupt actualization of counterparty accident has artlessly arctic the markets beyond the western countries....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

A Rise in Nationalist Feeling in the Member States of the EU

The paper "A Rise in Nationalist Feeling in the Member States of the EU" discusses that the EU member states have a vision, but that vision cannot be achieved so long as the member states fear the “other” Europeans moving freely between their borders as members of the EU.... hellip; The provisional reference "the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia" is currently always used in relations involving states which do not recognize the constitutional name, "Republic of Macedonia"....
25 Pages (6250 words) Coursework

Why Abortion is Immoral by Dom Marquis

"Why Abortion is Immoral by Dom marquis" paper examines the plight of the individual who has to undergo that unfortunate process of abortion which is her private suffering from a physical and psychological angle and examines how the society treats women and the disposition of menfolk towards them.... The response of Dom marquis to this question is in the negative.... But the ground reality is unsatisfactory on many counts, the result being women are driven to desperation to go for abortion....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us