Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Write a critique about "Cinderella" A story of Sibling Rivalry and Oedipal Confilcts By Bruno Bettelheim - Assignment Example

Only on StudentShare
High school
Author : kelvin49
Assignment
English
Pages 2 (502 words)

Summary

A Freudian psychologist, Bettelheim believes that story books with fairy tales have deeper and hidden meanings apart from the happy endings experienced in all of them. Bruno Bettelheim explains this notion in his essay “Cinderella”- A story of sibling rivalry and oedipal…

Extract of sample
Write a critique about "Cinderella" A story of Sibling Rivalry and Oedipal Confilcts By Bruno Bettelheim

This is created from the conscious part of our brains. According to Hentz (2002) the unconscious part of our brains has the ability to dig deeper into the story and relate to another interpretation. This is the same in a child’s brain where is it possible for a child to create both conscious and unconscious interpretation of a story.
The Cinderella story helps children relate with their difficulties in life. In the essay Bruno Bettelheim goes deeper trying to explain how sibling rivalry and the oedipal stage in children contribute to their difficulties in life. The author argues that children relate greatly to the Cinderella story when they are faced with the difficulty of sibling rivalry. They tend to hope that they will get something great from the tribulations just as Cinderella did. While at the oedipal stage children do not have the ability to differentiate different emotions. They cannot differentiate between anger, guilt, jealousy, parental criticism, worthlessness and rejection (Hentz, 2002). However, with fairy tales like the Cinderella children can very appropriately relate to their emotions. The fairy tales provides children with an outlet for their thoughts. And it is for this reason that parents and teachers try to relate life to children by using and applying fairy tales in the real life. Just like the Cinderella story children cannot wait for their freedom from their parents. They yearn for the day that they will be independent from their parents.
The essay by Bettelheim has points which I liked and other worthy of criticism. The author downplayed the original purpose of a fairy tale. When reading a fairy tale, the whole idea is entertainment (Hentz, 2002). Fairy tales as the most beautiful stories a child can relate to without relating them to their difficulties in life. The author takes beauty from them as he argues that children should find more than ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Discuss the importance of sibling rivalry in "Everyday Use" or "First Confession."
But this does not apply in the novel. Maggie, who is younger the Dee feels neglected while her elder sister, Dee is well cared of. This creates a rivalry between the two. The elder sister is also attractive than her younger sister because Maggie has some scary marks from the fire incidence when she was young. The hatred strengthens Maggie since she does her own things without depending on fellow family members. Dee on the other hand is over dependent on her parent (mama). Sibling rivalry promotes responsibility among family members, more so the children. Dee is known to be lazy, despite being…
7 pages (1757 words)
sibling rivalry
Such actions bring out feelings of mercy and pity on the part of Cinderella and hatred on the part of her stepsisters. Such opposite feelings can only come out effectively through a relationship that shows sibling rivalry between the children. Sibling rivalry usually takes the form of competition in terms of affections, character, and other issues that affect the daily lives of the children. In many occasions, sibling rivalry occurs in ways that make one side of the rivalry to portray good characters while the other side of the character displays negative characters. The side that portrays the…
4 pages (1004 words)
Find a story to write about and analyze the story
What makes the conflict more complicated is the age gap of the major people involved—the adult doctor and the ill child. Apparently, the child has no power to refuse medication; the right to resist is in the hands of her parents. But what happens if there is an element of harm involved? What if the child knows that she will feel pain or get hurt by the medical procedure based on previous experience? Is it still unjustifiable to allow the child to decide for herself? And, most importantly, is the use of force justified in a situation wherein a child with a possible life-threatening illness is…
4 pages (1004 words)
Critique Writing of “Cinderella”
The feelings lead to fear of rejection by the child giving them the distress of others being favored over them. Therefore, sibling rivalry arising.…
2 pages (502 words)
How the story of Cinderella has developed over time.
other literary tales, Cinderella came from an earlier oral tradition of stories that were recurring in different cultures around the world and they still show a lot of similarity even though the total known variants are more than seven hundred.…
6 pages (1506 words)
To read a story and write about it
To him, life became unbearable when his he even decided to attend new meetings to improve on the knowledge he had, as the unemployment benefits were running were almost ending, the cost of living was rising up in Washington. It was after searching from town to town of Pennsylvania, New York, Kentucky among others, in different companies that one call came from a headhunter and said it would be a perfect job for him, only to be asked why he never wrote about his bachelor’s degree. The author said that he never did one, and was told it is one requirement that would have made him prefect.…
2 pages (502 words)
Cinderella
These versions include The Story of the Black Cow, Donkeyskin by Charles Perrault and the recent Cinderella by the Grimm Brothers.…
4 pages (1004 words)