StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Main Difference between Aristotles Account of Virtue and Socrates Account of Virtue - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Aristotle’s philosophy is said to be an intellectual achievement which is extraordinary. His claims and arguments have endured as important landmarks of philosophy. They are also viewed as intellectual endeavors…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
The Main Difference between Aristotles Account of Virtue and Socrates Account of Virtue
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Main Difference between Aristotles Account of Virtue and Socrates Account of Virtue"

Download file to see previous pages

This is because it identifies happiness as an activity of the soul which goes together with virtue. Aristotle argues that if what individuals do is the source of happiness then, happiness must identify with activity which goes with virtue. Socrates argued that being virtuous was very much related with increasing individual’s happiness. The controversy between the two is that according to Aristotle happiness should always go in accordance with virtue. On the same note, according to Socrates virtue does not necessarily need to be highly related with happiness.

Aristotle attempts to criticize Socrates for his emphasis on Socratic definitions. Aristotle does not completely agree with the argument by Socrates that knowledge is important in as far as virtue is concerned. He thinks that even if there is need for knowledge it is easily attainable as suggested by Irwin (158). Aristotle also draws the analogy between acquiring knowledge and acquiring virtue. He argues that both are gained through repeating similar actions. Socrates argues that a virtuous soul should also be well ordered.

He also argues that power of knowledge of right and the wrong is the advantage of virtue. This is because the knowledge of the two is important to crafts of measurement. . He also argues that knowledge of the truth is not very important as one can act accidentally or be directed by someone else. Aristotle explains that virtuous actions are objective and are performed by a virtuous agent. Aristotle is in disagreement with Socrates concerning the nature of vice and ethical value as suggested by Segvic and Burnyeat (78).

According to Aristotle for an action to be considered virtuous there must be an agreement with the non-rational desires. The agreement should be for reason to express the actions are supposed to be pursued. Contrary to this, according to Socrates there is no need for prior agreement by non-rational desires concerning the setting of the ends. Therefore Socrates considers that the condition necessary for an agent to attain moral knowledge is through disciplining his or her appetites and passions.

The also need to be in a harmonious condition. Aristotle fails to agree with Socrates about non-rational desires lead to errors. Socrates is of the view that strong non-rational desires results to reason making wrong judgment about what is really good. On his account of, virtue Aristotle disagrees with Socrates denying the possibility of incontinence. Socrates argues that only ignorance of what is good and wrong lies behind apparent incontinence. Contrary to this, Aristotle asserts that Socrates argument conflicts appearances he Aristotle’s perception of incontinence seems to be puzzling and their interpretation is therefore controversial.

Aristotle seems to argue that incontinent individual makes the right decision. This is because he or she is moved to action by non-rational appetite that conflicts with the decisions he or she has made. The individual acts on the appetite because its strong as opposed

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Main Difference between Aristotles Account of Virtue and Socrates Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1408433-the-main-difference-between-aristotles-account-of-virtue-and-socrates-account-of-virtue
(The Main Difference Between Aristotles Account of Virtue and Socrates Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1408433-the-main-difference-between-aristotles-account-of-virtue-and-socrates-account-of-virtue.
“The Main Difference Between Aristotles Account of Virtue and Socrates Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1408433-the-main-difference-between-aristotles-account-of-virtue-and-socrates-account-of-virtue.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Main Difference between Aristotles Account of Virtue and Socrates Account of Virtue

Essentials of Political Thought

Lewis and John Dewey's major difference was in the way that they both perceived the relevance of Christianity and the existence of moral absolutes.... Name Professor Module Date Essentials of Political Thought Part I: C.... .... Lewis and John Dewey C.... .... Lewis and John Dewey devote considerable attention to the ways science might be harnessed to change human life....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Platos Defense of the Republic King in the Republic

Plato believed that a harmonious society can be attained by the interaction of specific mode of the righteous and rational order of political philosophy based on the implementation of virtue.... hellip; A subtle way to get into predefined intercourse by virtue of breeding guardian-warrior, which had been immortalized by Plato in the Republic.... The continuum representing the movement from clarification of analysis by the virtue of evaluation of beliefs to attain the goal of best political order is enunciated in the structure of Plato's Republic....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Christian Ethics: Do You See Connections between Conscience and Friendship

This paper ''Christian Ethics'' tells that Moral development has not yet become a major concern for virtue ethics, even though the topic was central to the moral philosophy of Aristotle, the traditional source οf much virtue ethics.... The importance οf practices in the formation of οf virtuous habits have gained increasing attention since Alasdair Macintyre's After virtue.... (Nussbaum 1997, 85-112) Diana Fritz Cates argues that the practice οf committed friendship trains desires and moral vision in the virtue οf compassion....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Platos Theory of Forms

hellip; The author states that the main characteristic of Plato's work was the use of 'forms' which were the 'vehicle' for the 'exit' of knowledge to the real world by the representation of 'intangible' aspects.... On this matter, socrates expresses his ideas by making a comparison with the relevant conditions in the animals' world and by making questions to Glaykon targeting in the appearance of the solution (451a-).... He wrote a series of dialogues that were held between citizens of Athens who belonged to his environment which were used in order to express ideas of general acceptance....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Socrates: Political Thought

For Plato ignorance of the true good is the main reason for the moral corruption in his time.... In the Socratic dialogues, his extended conversations with students, statesmen, and friends invariably aim at understanding and achieving virtue {Gk.... It takes into account the type of audience present, and in using language the rhetoricians highlight the socio-political aspects of the place.... This essay "socrates: Political Thought" presents socrates with his beautiful arguments that bring in a realistic picture of what the young men and their thoughts should be, and his position shows how one should be guided in the true spirit of argument and knowledge....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Views on Teaching Athenians: Socrates, Thoreau, and the Sophists

This paper "Views on Teaching Athenians: socrates, Thoreau, and the sophists" explain that socrates was one of the most influential thinkers of all the time and even though that this Greek philosopher had no written evidence left of his own views, he succeeded in immortalizing himself.... hellip; “Know thyself” was the fundamental principle of Socratic philosophy that characterized socrates' view about the world and the self.... Ironically, few historical documents are kept and scholars rely only on fragmented details describing socrates since he refused to write about himself and his life as a thinker....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Human Nature or Affirmative Action

hellip; The purpose of Aristotle's Nicomachean ethics is to discover human good which should be the main focus of every action that we undertake as human beings.... Before the twentieth century, there was little distinction between adult and juvenile offenders.... This has led to the development of a juvenile court system which is not the same as the court system for adults, with its main aim being protection and rehabilitation of wayward youths....
18 Pages (4500 words) Research Paper

Ethical Dilemmas and Theories in Hospitality and Tourism Industry

251) offer a long list of the main ethical dilemmas surrounding the industry and these consist of “bribery and corruption, gender and racial discrimination, sexual harassment, exploitation of child labor, child sexual harassment, violation of human rights, harming natural resources, selling of unhealthy food, false and misleading advertising, nepotism, and even software piracy.... The paper "Ethical Dilemmas and Theories in Hospitality and Tourism Industry" focuses on the major ethical dilemmas faced by the industry; analyses the major ethical theories such as teleology, deontology, and virtue ethics; and tries to show how these theories address various ethical dilemmas within the hospitality and tourism industry....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us