StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Evaluation of Bouwsma's Argument - Essay Example


Extract of sample
Evaluation of Bouwsma's Argument

(4) We are not deceived about the world around us (A-). If we closely analyze the argument above as Bouwsma put it, we will notice in the major premise (1) that A is either B or B-. He then proceeds to prove in the minor premises (2) and (3) that B = A- and that B- = A-, and so he concludes that A- is true, thus implying that A in the major premise is not true. What Bouwsma is trying to say here is that simply because B and B- actually lead to A-, then it is A- that is true and not A. Nevertheless, without analyzing the content of the premises, the minor premises (2) and (3) commit a fault since they contradict the major premise (1). Based on the major premise, A = either B or B-. Therefore, if A = B, then A ? B-; or if A = B-, then A ? B, because whatever happens, A must either be B or B-. In short, one of these two possibilities must necessarily be true. There is actually no way that A, or Descartes’ claim that we are deceived about the world around us, can be proven false if it is stated in a major premise. The reason is that if A is not B, then it must be B-; or if it is not B-, then it must be B, regardless of whether B or B- is false. It is like saying that John is either a bird or a fish. It therefore means that if John is not a bird, then he must be a fish; and if he is not a fish, then he must be a bird – regardless of whether the conclusion is true, and regardless of whether both terms “bird” and “fish” are nonexistent and are not even concepts. Using this argument about John,

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Evaluation of an argument through analysis
However, the article by Janet Holmes discusses the issue in detail while offering an understanding of the various issues associated with ‘talking too much’. Across the world, women have been believed to talk too much even in situations that do not require communication.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Evaluation of an argument through analysis
According to a research carried out by Kruszelnicki (2010) it is was proved that an average woman speaks over 15,000 words in a span of 24 hours, while the challenged male counterpart speaks a maximum of 12,000; however, these factor are altered by several determinants; for instance, character and other attributes.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Evaluation Argument
2) The costume will be judged according to certain criteria, namely its historical significance, what it represents and aesthetic entertainment value. Perhaps the single most important criterion in making a judgment is the costume's historical significance and the least important would be its entertainment value.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Evaluation argument
The movie has been often compared to the likes of The Godfather owing to their close resemblance in terms of the main storyline underlying the two movies, in which they are about the immigrant experience and a charismatic figure from the underclass trying to employ
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Argument of Evaluation
He makes the best use of ensuing silence and its notable effects in a manner that comes out like a twilight zone making it a silent movie
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Evaluation of an argument through analysis
Across the world, women have been believed to talk too much even in situations that do not require communication. In view of the developed ideology, Holmes evaluates and conducts analysis on
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Analysis and Evaluation of an Argument
She needed someone to take over her position and Dr. Grey turned out to be the best fit in that position. This is because he tries to assume a fact that ageing is unavoidable (De Grey, 102). He treats ageing as a mere or ordinary
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Kentuckys Educational System; Argument by Definition, Evaluation, and Proposal
According to the report the Kentucky education system is evident in various environments where individuals are willing to learn new basics. In this case. learning does not have dependence on the teachers or any of Kentucky’s education institutes but occurs through self-learning. Most students show a preference in the learning methods.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Present your argument evaluation and counterargument
However, the formation or evolution of intelligence starts off in one’s childhood and then it further evolves thereby ‘providing’ a personality to the individual. According to the views of various
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Evaluation of an Argument
The argument can be termed as invalid despite the conclusion of the argument, based on the premises, being true. Moreover, since the premises of the argument are true, then it is conclusive that the argument is sound. Incidentally, Rubinelli defines a sortie as an argument that lacks a significant premise.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
the bird and the fish, what Bouwma did was to say that either John is a bird or a fish, and then prove that neither bird nor fish point to John, so therefore John does not exist. What then is the use of the major premise if the possibilities are not exhaustive? After all, Bouwma’s major premise is actually “John is a fish, or a bird or does not exist.” Likewise, in our original argument, Bouwma’s major premise is wrongly stated and should have been: (1) “If we are deceived about the world around us, there are three possibilities: we are able to detect the deception through our five sense


(Name) (Professor) (Subject) (Date) Evaluation of Bouwsma’s Argument The argument of Bouwsma is not valid, particularly because of the major premise (1) and the minor premises (2) and (3). For the purposes of clarity, the premises will be represented as: (1) If we are deceived about the world around us (A), either we are able to detect the deception through our five sense (B) or we are not able to detect the deception through our five senses (B-)…
Author : briannerunte
Evaluation of Bouwsmas Argument essay example
Read Text Preview
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment