Evaluation of Bouwsma's Argument - Essay Example

Free

Extract of sample
Evaluation of Bouwsma's Argument

(4) We are not deceived about the world around us (A-). If we closely analyze the argument above as Bouwsma put it, we will notice in the major premise (1) that A is either B or B-. He then proceeds to prove in the minor premises (2) and (3) that B = A- and that B- = A-, and so he concludes that A- is true, thus implying that A in the major premise is not true. What Bouwsma is trying to say here is that simply because B and B- actually lead to A-, then it is A- that is true and not A. Nevertheless, without analyzing the content of the premises, the minor premises (2) and (3) commit a fault since they contradict the major premise (1). Based on the major premise, A = either B or B-. Therefore, if A = B, then A ? B-; or if A = B-, then A ? B, because whatever happens, A must either be B or B-. In short, one of these two possibilities must necessarily be true. There is actually no way that A, or Descartes’ claim that we are deceived about the world around us, can be proven false if it is stated in a major premise. The reason is that if A is not B, then it must be B-; or if it is not B-, then it must be B, regardless of whether B or B- is false. It is like saying that John is either a bird or a fish. ...
Download paper

Summary

(Name) (Professor) (Subject) (Date) Evaluation of Bouwsma’s Argument The argument of Bouwsma is not valid, particularly because of the major premise (1) and the minor premises (2) and (3). For the purposes of clarity, the premises will be represented as: (1) If we are deceived about the world around us (A), either we are able to detect the deception through our five sense (B) or we are not able to detect the deception through our five senses (B-)…
Author : briannerunte
Download 1

Related Essays

balanced scorecard evaluation
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Project Evaluation
5 pages (1255 words) Math Problem
Apple Performance Evaluation
3 pages (753 words) Essay
STOCK EVALUATION
6 pages (1506 words) Assignment
Evaluation of SunTrust Bank
5 pages (1255 words) Case Study
Facebook Financial evaluation
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Walt Disney prospectus
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Evaluation of Corporate Performance
8 pages (2008 words) Research Paper
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!