Philosophy Assignment - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Philosophy Assignment

On the warship, Claggart, his master-at-arms, somehow dislikes Billy. One night, one of Claggart's loyalists tries to bribe Billy in an attempt to make him join the group of some naval men ready to rebel. Aghast, Billy threatens to dump him in the high seas (About the novel, a brief synopsis, fourth Para).Later, Claggart lies and complaints to the Captain Vere that Billy is involved in an attempted mutiny. In the enquiry, Billy, unable to control his anger and spurred by inability to speak due to stammering, unintentionally hits Claggart and kills him in the presence of Captain Vere.
The Captain faces a dilemma as to what he should do in the circumstances. He immediately calls for a drumhead court and sentences Billy to death, despite his love for the latter and the fact that Billy is not intentional in hitting and killing Claggart. The Captain is also sure that Billy Budd would never resort to involve in a crime of mutiny. Here, the Captain knows that his action of giving a death sentence to Billy is immoral and bad on his part but right and compulsory according to the universal principle of military rules, as laid out by the Kant's deontoligical theory. When viewd in the backdrop of Kant's theory, the court martialling and hanging of Billy is imminent , despite the fact that he is not at fault. ...
Download paper


German philosoher Immanuel Kant's deontoligical theory talks about the good and bad things in relation to their universal accetability. His theory includes the idea of a categorical imperative which suggests an unconditional and absolute requirement in all circumstances and is justified as an end in itself (Categorical imperative, first two paras).
Author : devanbode

Related Essays

Assignment 3
In this literary dissertation, I will focus on the term 'objective correlative, which appeared in his essay on Hamlet by William Shakespeare, studying it and its effects by giving examples taken from his poem The Waste Land and from Virginia Woolf's To the Lighthouse.
9 pages (2259 words) Book Report/Review
A Confederacy of Dunces
Nonetheless, I have learned a valuable lesson in life from reading this book and studying this character and what I have learned has given me a philosophy on which to live.
2 pages (502 words) Book Report/Review
Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad
When Conrad wrote the novel (during the latter part of the 19th century) the British were at the helm of their imperial power having colonies around the world, including India, Malaya, Hong Kong and much of Africa and also dominated over the Suez Canal, the East Coast of Africa, and the dominate to the source of the Nile. Achebe contends that Heart of Darkness sees Africa:
3 pages (753 words) Book Report/Review
Juan Rulfos Short Stories
There are other definitions of the term that include "The simulation of something which never really existed." (Baudrillard) "The authentic fake." (Eco). These definitions are provided from hyperreality philosophers and can be compared with the definition of reality to clearly observe the divergence into hyperreality. As a result, a disparity as to what reality is surfaces. This is because the
5 pages (1255 words) Book Report/Review
Crimes Against Nature: How George W. Bush and His Corporate Pals Are Plundering the Country and Hijacking Our Democracy by R.F.K. Jr.
In the arena of U.S environmentalist activism the author is a quite recognized name. Despite environmental issues are becoming subjects of great worry for the scientists, environmental scholars and common people but the Bush government has not shown any special attention to those issues. The Bush presidency has only been concerned about expanding the corporate effectiveness and capitalist aggression at the same time. Through is book, 'Crimes against Nature: How George W. Bush and His Corporate Pals Are Plundering the Country and Hijacking Our Democracy', the author has actually pointed out the...
10 pages (2510 words) Book Report/Review
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!