StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Offences against Person and Property - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
In 1995, Giovanni Masciantonio stabbed his son-in-law to death. The reason given was that the son-in-law had been mistreating his daughter Lia over many years. Two days before retribution fell on him, he demanded money from his wife, and when she refused, he took away the TV, which she had bought…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
Offences against Person and Property
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Offences against Person and Property"

Download file to see previous pages

Now, a psychiatrist can always say that "the defendant had a predisposition to a disassociative state when under stress and that he was in such a state when he killed his son in law."1Notwithstanding the fact that he began by stabbing the person in a fit of anger, and then continued doing it after his son in law had fallen down. These were not "blows struck in anger," but sheer premeditated actions of giving in to the joy of primeval bloodlust. And that is how one could agree with the statement that the law about murder is a mess.

It was therefore necessary to reframe it in such a manner with the minimum of loopholes to make sure any future example of impulsive or premeditated homicide does not know that it can get away with murder by invoking the plea of "it was provocation, my lord, " First of all, we have to see the difference between murder- planning out and killing a person with malice aforethought, and manslaughter, killing of a person in "hot blood," keeping into view, "the limits of human frailty," Murder meant that you looked at the methods of getting rid of one particularly obnoxious person and waited for the time and the opportunity to send him to his forefathers.

Manslaughter meant that you had no intention of dispatching that particular human specimen, but he provoked you continuously, incessantly, intolerably, unremittingly, verbatim and seriatim, until it was beyond the normal tolerance level of you, who happen to be a sane, sober and somewhat sombre pillar of society. So you killed him but you were not in your right senses at that moment. One pleads not guilty my lord.This pleading of manslaughter instead of murder began to be clearly demarcated in the 17th and 18th century, when people resorted to the use of weapons to assert their rights, which they thought had been infringed upon by some upstart who did not know better.

There were also plenty of opportunities to get rid of your opponents, by challenging them to duels and then dispatch them in a very honourable and conventionally accepted way. Any sort of matter of honour or any insult, where real or insinuated could be wiped out by pistols or swords at dawn. This wholesale killing of innocent lambs to the slaughter went on until dueling was outlawed, and it was made a hanging offense.Murder was also a hanging offense. There had to be a clear distinction between premeditated and well calculated murder and manslaughter under provocation.

And that could make all the difference between life and death.Defects in the law of provocation.So, in the 17th century, the doctrine of provocation meant that the circumstances of killing someone happened to be extenuating. It touched upon a matter of honour, (possibly adultery, which no red-blooded man could condone unless he wanted to be jeered at by his peers.) There needed to be some mitigation of reckoned punishment, because the killing was done in a moment of anger. They were considered less reprehensible, and could only come under the name of manslaughter and not murder.

Yet, killing a person in cold blood on a dueling field, hours after the challenge had taken place , and the blood had had time to cool down, and better thought and sense prevail, can only be termed "murder." But the social code of honour of that time demanded that one retrieve his

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Offences against Person and Property Case Study”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500935-offences-against-person-and-property
(Offences Against Person and Property Case Study)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500935-offences-against-person-and-property.
“Offences Against Person and Property Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500935-offences-against-person-and-property.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Offences against Person and Property

Current Issue Assignment on Correctional System

Stewart points out that more than 60 per cent of all US inmates are imprisoned for nonviolent offences.... Instead of mass incarceration, sentencing should be based on consideration of alternative (often less costly) sanctions for particular offences which have proven to produce better results in terms of offender rehabilitation, lower recidivism, and compensation of aggrieved victims....
3 Pages (750 words) Personal Statement

Dangerous Driving Habits

The generally accepted rule is, it is always the fault of the person behind you, if you get hit from the back.... In the essay “DANGEROUS DRIVING HABITS” the writer analyzes primary violations which have proper rules designed and violations lead to repercussions and secondary violations, which do not have well defined rules due to their trivial nature....
3 Pages (750 words) Personal Statement

Letter to Law Client

This is why many small businesses choose to incorporate; they are able to protect their personal property.... It sounds like they were still on public property, however, and the actions of Bubba are still an issue-had he asked them and they refused, calling the police would have been a better alternative.... However, the medical bills are truly an issue-if one person injures another person it is generally required that the person that caused the injury pay for the medical bills of the other....
3 Pages (750 words) Personal Statement

Euthanasia: the Practice of Ending a Life

a bedridden person who has permanent brain damage would only become a burden to his family for the rest of his life.... Hospital wards are limited, medicine is restricted, spending such resources on a person who will only eventually die would be a waste.... a bedridden person who has permanent brain damage would only become a burden to his family for the rest of his life.... Hospital wards are limited, medicine is restricted, spending such resources on a person who will only eventually die would be a waste....
2 Pages (500 words) Personal Statement

Poverty in Africa

Each person can be a proponent of change and this can be done in a number of ways that is not limited to earthshattering acts.... There have concerts, fundraisings, special editions of magazines, music albums and other alternative means to be able to contribute financially in the fight against poverty....
2 Pages (500 words) Personal Statement

The Problem of Intimidation

I was 14 years old that summer when the decent person in me felt an extreme need to stand up for another young man who was being intimidated at Wheelock College where we were both attending an acting class for the season.... Intimidation as a human trait is one of the worst kinds that man can exhibit and inflict upon another person because of its far reaching consequences.... I was 14 years old that summer when the decent person in me felt an extreme need to stand up for another young man who was being intimidated at Wheelock College where we were both attending an acting class for the season....
2 Pages (500 words) Personal Statement
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us