StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The War in Iraq: Should We Stay or Leave - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The War in Iraq is a divisive issue. Let's look at two articles discussing what America should do next in Iraq. "Why We Must Stay in Iraq" is written by military historian Victor Hanson. "Time to Leave" is written by economist Paul Krugman. Let's look at how each writer uses history and third-party opinions to support his case…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
The War in Iraq: Should We Stay or Leave
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The War in Iraq: Should We Stay or Leave"

The War in Iraq: Should We Stay or Leave The War in Iraq is a divisive issue. Let's look at two articles discussing what America should do next in Iraq. "Why We Must Stay in Iraq" is written by military historian Victor Hanson. "Time to Leave" is written by economist Paul Krugman. Let's look at how each writer uses history and third-party opinions to support his case. Then let's answer the question: "Should we go or should we stay"Both articles draw on American history to make their case, but Krugman less so.

Krugman briefly alludes to the Vietnam War in writing we are in "increasing danger of facing a collapse in quality and morale similar to the collapse of the officer corps in the early 1970's" (Krugman A23). Hanson relies almost exclusively on history, no doubt because of his background as a historian. He also writes about the Vietnam War but advises, "[] make no mistake, Iraq is not like Vietnam, and it must not end like Vietnam" (Hanson B01). He recalls that we have an all-volunteer army, unlike the conscription army of Vietnam.

He warns that leaving Iraq now would moralize America's enemies in the area, which happened after the Vietnam War. Krugman doesn't mention WWII, but Hanson does so extensively. He compares the increase of Islamic terrorists in Iraq to the increase of Nazis in Germany during the war. He says America can reverse this trend through force as it did in Germany. He discusses the success of reconstruction in Italy, Germany, and Japan, which may be achieved in Iraq through perseverance.Both men mention public opinion to support their case, but Krugman more so.

Krugman writes, "a solid majority of Americans now believe that we were misled into war" (Krugman A23) and that we can now have serious discussions about Iraq since "the public has realized the truth about the past" (Krugman A23). Hanson, however, discredits public opinion. He writes that "the New York Times recently deplored the public's ignorance of American heroes in Iraq" (Hanson B01). He blames the media for the public's lack of interest and calls on the Bush administration to give the public detailed accounts of "why we are winning" (Hanson B01).

More compelling, however, are both writers' references to the opinions of military heroes to justify their own cases. Hanson concludes his article with a moving eulogy delivered by Lt. Col. Kurilla, an officer with some military successes who, himself, was recently seriously wounded. The eulogy gives voice to the view held by many in the military that this war is necessary to defend freedom and to keep the terrorism out of "our own backyard" (Hanson B01). Krugman, on the other hand, bases the lion's share of his article on the views of Representative John Murtha, a decorated Vietnam War veteran who recently delivered a speech to Congress denouncing the War in Iraq.

Krugman mentions how Murtha, who "cares deeply about America's fighting men and women," argues that our continued presence in Iraq will destroy our military, undermine America's moral authority, and possibly lead to civil war in Iraq (Krugman A23). Since the printing of the article, the last point has proven to be true.So should we stay or leave Both writers make strong arguments, but they also make serious errors. Krugman should have used historical references to his advantage. There are plenty for him to choose from, which I'll discuss shortly.

Hanson, however, distorted history. He uses WWII as justification for high casualty rates, but conveniently forgets that the situation was far more promising after Midway and Normandy (six months and three years after our entry into the war) than can be said after three years in Iraq. This error weakens his argument. He goes on to cite the successful reconstructions of Germany, Italy, and Japan, but forgot the disastrous reconstruction of the American South (which many call "America's Second Civil War").

He also forgot about the deadly Philippine Insurrection after the Spanish-American War, during which Mark Twain severely criticized America's continued military activities in the newly independent island nation. Of the two writers, Hanson definitely makes the weaker case. He is delusional when he suggests that the "infighting among the Kurds, the Shiites, and the Sunnis [] is precisely because Saddam Hussein pitted the sects against each other" (Hanson A23). These are deep-rooted, centuries-old, ethnic conflicts that continue to play out in other countries, like Turkey and Iran, which were never under Saddam Hussein's control.

His distortion and selective omission of history work to his discredit. Murtha (and by extension Krugman) makes a stronger case. Murtha has a better grasp of what's happening in Iraq as is evident when he stated that our presence in Iraq could lead to civil war. Murtha's suggestion that this war undermines America's moral authority is right in line with Mark Twain's wisdom regarding the Philippines. It's time to cut our losses and bring our troops home. Only then can we begin the arduous journey back to the moral roots our founding fathers' experiment in democracy.

Cited WorksHanson, Victor Davis. "Why We Must Stay in Iraq." The Washington Post 4 September 2005: B01. "John Murtha." Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. 23 Mar. 2006. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 16 Mar. 2006 .Krugman, Paul. "Time to Leave." The New York Times 21 November 2005: A23."Mark Twain, the Greatest American Humorist, Returning Home." New York World 6 October 1900. 23 Mar 2006 .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The War in Iraq: Should We Stay or Leave Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1511235-the-war-in-iraq-should-we-stay-or-leave
(The War in Iraq: Should We Stay or Leave Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1511235-the-war-in-iraq-should-we-stay-or-leave.
“The War in Iraq: Should We Stay or Leave Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1511235-the-war-in-iraq-should-we-stay-or-leave.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The War in Iraq: Should We Stay or Leave

What will happen to Iraq if the US leaves

"No one can say with confidence what will happen in iraq if the United States leaves precipitously and without making a continuing effort to compensate for its mistakes and failures.... In a careful analysis of the current situation in iraq, it is essential to comprehend that there are several benefits if the US army stay longer in the region.... "in iraq, the United States has demonstrated that it will stand and fight in the face of adversity when it believes that its core interests are at stake....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Should US Military Stay in Iraq

The author of this essay "War in Iraq" touches upon the war in iraq.... military personnel in iraq were back home by April 2008.... hellip; The alleged link between the terrorist group Al Qaeda and Iraq was referenced before the war and became the primary excuse of the Bush administration following the lack of weapons evidence.... Even congressional Democrats who are bitterly opposed to the war acknowledged that quickly withdrawing from Iraq would irreparably damage America's long-held image of strength....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Risks Involved if the U.S. Withdrew From Iraq

into a debilitating guerrilla war in Afghanistan and do to the U.... nbsp; The alleged link between the terrorist group Al Qaeda and Iraq was referenced before the war and became the primary excuse of the Bush administration following the lack of weapons evidence.... the war was wrong on many fronts but withdrawing would be committing yet another wrong.... Withdrew From iraq" concerns the US occupation of iraq....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Effects of Decreasing Oil Prices on OPEC Creator States, such as Venezuela, Iraq, etc

The purpose of this essay "The Effects of Decreasing Oil Prices on the OPEC Creator States, such as Venezuela, iraq, etc" is to discuss what problems can be the outcomes of the decreasing oil prices.... Original OPEC members include Iran, iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, and Venezuela.... The United States was a member during its formal occupation of iraq via the Coalition Provisional Authority (Yergin; Perkins, 2005).... iraq remains a member of OPEC, though Iraqi production has not been a part of any OPEC quota agreements since March 1998....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Was the Invasion of Iraq Justified

Saddam and his son Uday was accused of killing the huge number of Kurds in iraq.... hellip; The researcher states that we have already witnessed two world wars and the possibility of a third one is on the horizon at present.... The iraq war of 2003 was exceptional in both beginning well for the Anglo-American force that waged it and ending victoriously.... The reasons or the justifications of the recent iraq war between America and iraq are highly debated across the world at present....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Should the US Leave Iraq or Not

The essay "Should the US Leave Iraq or Not" concentrates on both sides of the war in iraq to determines the American's role in the conflict.... he war in iraq will exceed the number of casualties that occur daily if the American government will not withdraw its troops from Iraq.... One opinion argues that it is untimely and unfair for the troops to be in iraq.... Taking the whole sum, it adds up to about $500 billion dollars which are being used to finance a worthless war in times of economic breakdown....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Is the Obama Administrations Strategy in Iraq Realistic

Previously President Obama opposed “surge” strategy conceived and implemented by former President Bush which brought victory out of a defeated war in iraq, and had introduced an open, decent and effective government in Iraq that would regard the rights of its people and its neighbours.... This paper "Is the Obama Administration's Strategy in iraq Realistic?... focuses on the fact that Barack Obama, the US President laid down an Exit Strategy in iraq which went about withdrawing American troops from Iraq, leaving Iraqis to take control of their country's future....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Struggling to Survive in Post-American Iraq

The essay "Struggling to Survive in Post-American Iraq" claims that the American government must strive to repair the significant refugee problem while ensuring that those who put their lives at risk for the United States in the war are properly protected in their time of need.... The American government must strive to repair the significant refugee problem while ensuring that those who put their lives at risk for the United States in the war are properly protected in their time of need....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us