StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Reflexivity in relation to anthropologicalethnographic filmmaking - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Emphasizing reflexivity in an anthropological/ethnographical filmmaking is about creating a shared space between the researcher and the researched (Cataln, 2). It chooses to show the participation that goes into filmmaking and the production of knowledge through informant's information…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Reflexivity in relation to anthropologicalethnographic filmmaking
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Reflexivity in relation to anthropologicalethnographic filmmaking"

Download file to see previous pages

The Ax Fight was originally created to show students the difficulty in placing a single point-of-view out of a certain field experience. The footages actualize the teaching process and problematize the translation from one cultural experience to another cultural idiom, within which the anthropologist often condenses, analyzes and-makes intellectual models (Ennis, Asch, 1). In the first unedited section of the film all the events are presented and the sound continues even after the film goes dark and the comments of Chagnon, Asch and Johnson are just heard.

In the second part, Napoleon Chagnon explains the socio-political significance of the fighter's behavior. The third part, delves more into the socio-cultural complications of the village people. The final section is an edited version. Timothy wanted his students to understand the shortcoming of a film that is has smooth editing and fibula structure like the Nanook of the North. Films like The Ax Fight show how an intellectual intervention influences an onlooker. The film is also a direct criticism of the inconsistencies of spectatorship and how the desired effect in understanding is achieved by a good filmmaker.

Contrary to pre-disposed notions in science and filmmaking, anthropological faithfulness to observation of another culture cannot ever be beyond bias, unless reflexivity is used to both question that objectivity and nurture mental exercise within the spectators. Anthropological filmmaking combines two processes together. One is the filming process and the other is social science. The balance is crucial since science and art clash headlong. The frame within the camera may help to communicate cultural conditions and also further Western knowledge of the "Other", but a culture cannot be completely understood just by introducing a non-fictional narrative as Flaherty does.

The limitations are numerous. First, a narrative forces the plot of the actual observation towards a composition of a fiction. Flaherty wanted to manipulate viewers understanding of the biography of Nanook and not further any racist understanding of the Eskimo culture. But with Timothy Asch reflexivity is the first stance to question the all-understanding nature of the anthropologist. He wanted to keep certain signs and their nature open to critical interpretation and never risk a comfortable lapse leading to an acceptance from his audience.

The conscious effort to keep the audience visually uncomfortable while watching the fight makes the confrontation of inter-cultural experience more critical. Accumulation of data, the process of accumulating it, narration, and little editing of the film may help the nature of critical viewership and gives minimum control to the maker. Timothy and Chagnon relinquish all control of their point-of-view and plunges their own spectatorship with that of the audience in such a way so that it becomes impossible to neglect the cultural and ideological subjectivity of the anthropologists.

The students are left to situate the filmed observations within the sphere of public and uniform scientific study. The anthropologists become a part of the study themselves since their psychological perspectives are of profound value in regard to the choice of the subject itself. Human recording of another human behavior is the proper subject of postmodern dialogism. The indefinite and inadequate interplay of

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Reflexivity in relation to anthropologicalethnographic filmmaking Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1522588-reflexivity-in-relation-to-anthropologicalethnographic-filmmaking
(Reflexivity in Relation to Anthropologicalethnographic Filmmaking Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1522588-reflexivity-in-relation-to-anthropologicalethnographic-filmmaking.
“Reflexivity in Relation to Anthropologicalethnographic Filmmaking Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1522588-reflexivity-in-relation-to-anthropologicalethnographic-filmmaking.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Reflexivity in relation to anthropologicalethnographic filmmaking

CGI Compromising Good Filmmaking

CGI COMPROMISING GOOD filmmaking Name University Course Instructor Date Introduction Computer generated image is utilized for visual impacts because of high quality, and increasingly controllable effects compared to physically oriented processes like building miniatures for shot effects, or using additional crowd scenes.... It will also show how CGI movies are compromising traditional art of filmmaking.... Since the introduction of CGI technology, everything in the filmmaking has significantly changed, for instance, sound effects, emotional effects and visual effects....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Subjectivity in Documentary Filmmaking

hellip; What does subjectivity means in terms of documentary filmmaking and what it has to do with digital technology?... This paper attempts to explore subjectivity in terms of documentary filmmaking and the way subjectivity changed with the emergence of new digital technologies.... Since documentary filmmaking employees the way a director wants to capture the event or story, this medium is more inclined towards subjectivity instead of objectivity....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Interactionism and Reflexivity

This paper "Interactionism and reflexivity" discusses interactionism that defines how an individual or groups of individuals act or what they want while reflexivity defines how individuals act and reflexivity gives more emphasis on the power of an individual to change him compared to interactionism.... hellip; reflexivity argues that individuals decide who they want to be, though it is influenced by outside factors the individuals make still the final choice....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Different Aspects of Film Making

The resolution should be greater than 1090 pixels wide x 1080 pixels high (What Camera To Use For filmmaking).... “What Camera To Use For filmmaking'.... But only few know about the complexities involved in film making.... Even though films are made in different countries in different languages and in different themes, there are some common elements present in film making everywhere in the world....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Making of Documentary Films

And for the majority portion, all of this filmmaking filmmaking is a splendid way to enhance awareness and guide attention to a specificissue or topic.... So one of the most important things to be considered while filmmaking is the ethical dimensions to the subject, to the story, to the articulation of different scenes, to the moral justification of the utilization of media for creating awareness or creating a means of violence in the minds of audience (Maccarone p....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Investigating Learning Transfer: Reflexivity Action

The author focuses on reflexivity which refers to circular relationships between cause and effect.... nbsp;   In social education, reflexivity, therefore, comes to mean an act of personal reference where examination or action "bends back on", refers to, and affects the entity instigating the action or examination.... A low level of reflexivity would result in an individual shaped largely by their environment (or society).... A high level of social reflexivity would be defined by an individual shaping their own norms, tastes, politics, desires, and so on....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

The Role of Reflexivity in Research Work

… Summary:This paper talks about reflexivity in research work and how it could model or influence decision making in this domain.... Various theories on reflexivity have been dealt with vis-a-vis particular situations that involved film making and Summary:This paper talks about reflexivity in research work and how it could model or influence decision making in this domain.... The paper shows how use of reflexivity in research has gone into a stream of idea generation and thus their incorporation in the research....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

User Interface Design in Filmmaking

… The paper "Use of C# in filmmaking " is an excellent example of a term paper on information technology.... The paper "Use of C# in filmmaking " is an excellent example of a term paper on information technology.... The idea of this application is a derivative of the actual 3D animation filmmaking process....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us