StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
This book report "The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink" focuses on Bruce Fink, a professor of psychology that has retraced the subjectivity of Jacques-Marie-Émile Lacan, one of the leading French psychoanalysts in his book “The Lacanian Subject”: Between Language and Jouissance…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink"

The Lacanian by Bruce Fink Bruce Fink, a of psychology has retraced the ivity of Jacques-Marie-mile Lacan, one of the leading French psychoanalysts of the 1960's and 1970's in his book "The Lacanian Subject": Between Language and Jouissance. Contrary to the idea of most of the post-structuralists of the time who saw Lacan's theory as a 'death of the subject', Fink asserted otherwise. Subjectivity was the core concept of Lacanian psychoanalysis, according to the author. Fink examined the principal ideas that formulated Lacan's theory of subjectivity. From a thorough reading of the book, we find that the author emphasized on the chief notions which governed the central theme of Lacan's subjectivity. The author has put forward a comprehensive analysis of the unconscious, language, alienation and separation, jouissance, the other's desire, distinction between the sexes and the ethics of psychoanalysis as explored by Lacan. One of the rare Americans to have taken training in the Lacan's school in Paris, Fink presented the theory of Lacanian subjectivity extremely well in his book "The Lacanian Subject." Fink re-introduced the subject of Lacan's subjectivity for the readers. He gradually moves into the details of how Lacan forms the idea of subject and finally resulting in psychosis. Here the author has dealt with Lacan's clinical theories (Fink, 79). The author begins Lacan's theory of subjectivity with an elaborative analysis of the structure of the language and its relation to the other. This he maintains was the core chief idea of Lacan's theory of subjectivity. Lacan who was referred to as a structuralist in the 1970's and 1980's did not deal with the problematic of subjectivity. But in later years, the concept of subjectivity became the main idea of his works and seminars. The author affirms that Lacan's idea of the subject was based on the relation of one signifier with another signifier. He begins with the significance of the concept of 'otherness' which is completely alienated from the unspecified object. The author delves into what Lacan described as the slip of the tongue to describe the phenomenon of otherness and its alienation from language. Here the author talks of a patient who utters schnob instead of job. This example is given to show that language or discourse is not related to a single or particular aspect only. A slip of the tongue signifies that, more than two discourses can be used at the same time by the speaker. Here the author talks of two types of discourses, one that is intentional and the other that is unintentional. The intentional discourse refers to the words, the speaker wanted to say, whereas the unintentional discourse would be the disjointed word. Two different kinds of discourses refer to two different kinds of talk. Here the author speaks of the ego talk and the other kind of talk. Ego talk is the words we express consciously. Juxtaposed with the ego talk, Lacan puts forward the importance of the other kind of talk. Lacan's theory of psychoanalysis stems from this other kind of talk. By this Lacan meant, as Fink maintains that the unintentional words that are uttered incoherently flow from the other place or agency. This other place is completely different from the ego. Here we find Lacan echoing the idea of unconscious as presented by Freud. The other place or agency or state had been unequivocally described by Freud as the unconscious (Sigmund Freud, "The Structure of the Unconscious", 1961). Lacan described this unconscious as the other type of discourse. This other type of discourse is alien to the conscious mind or the ego, which every human being is aware of. The other type of discourse which in Lacan's words is the 'unconscious', is foreign to the ego. A child is born into a discourse. His parents speak about the as a new member of the family. The words they utter form that other linguistic discourse which Lacan spoke of in great detail. This collection of words and expressions remain in the mould the unconscious of the child. (Fink, 3-11) As Fink noted, both Lacan and Freud were united in the fact that they both spoke of representatives which were in other words were signifiers in linguistics. The author further noted that the unconscious was organized and integrated just like language to Lacan. To substantiate his statement, the French psychoanalyst maintained that the elements that make up the unconscious share the same relationship just as the elements that represent the conscious linguistic discourse. The author has explained in details later in the book, Lacan's idea of otherness as against language, demand, desire and jouissance. The author has substantiated much on the 'creative function of the word as upheld by Lacan. Fink adds that Lacan made a distinction between the symbolic and the real significance of the word. To this idea further, Lacan mentioned that, letters which add to the sophistication of language are actually disruptive in nature. The letter in a word destroys the real that existed before the language. Lacan also mentioned that existence was the result of language. Existence does not become a human life unless it is symbolized or expressed in words. There is nothing called the real as it comes before language. Lacan refers to this real by a separate term, which he called ex-sists. The symbolic is found to act upon the real, reducing it and wiping it out completely. Lacan here spoke of trauma, which was directly related to the real and the symbolic. A real exists before the symbolic which constitutes of elements that form the second real. The words we mumble, a product of the unconscious, eradicate the differences between the symbolic and the real. In the second part of his book, the author essays the idea of Lacan on subjectivity. As Lacan proclaimed in seminar XXIII, that the subject is only assumed. It became an indispensable idea for Lacan to formulate his theory of psychoanalysis in later years. The idea often echoes Freud's notion of the second stage of fantasy. This stage according to Freud is never real. It was never a part of the conscious mind. It results from analytic thinking. In Lacan's terms, the subject was not an individual or the conscious being. The author strictly maintains that the Lacanian Subject was also not the subject of the statement. Apparently the grammatical subject of a statement with the use of 'I' will refer to the sender or the subject of his message, which in other words was integrally linked to the ego. The ego dominates the subject of the sentence. The Lacanian subject, asserted the author "appeared nowhere in what is said". (Fink, 38). Fink has described the Freudian Subject to draw a connection with the Lacanian subject. As we express incoherent or mumbled words, a kind of foreign influence sets in. Freud has shown that these interferences were actually connected with the unconscious. This influence is spoken of as an agency or accorded the idea of a being. This unintentional causation is given the character of being and was the Freudian subject. Freud has never talked about the category of subjectivity. The author in his analysis of the Lacanian subject and in trying to draw a parallel between Freud and Lacan, has uniquely devised the concept of Freudian subject. The characteristic of subjectivity to the 'unconscious' of Freud as a disruption to the linguistic discourse is quite different from Lacan's subject, asserts the author. The Lacanian subject is a product of two movements. (Homer, 74). The first process is that of alienation and the second is that of separation. Lacan, however, never points out at the specific juncture, when the subject comes into being. There is no such specific point, when the subject appears. The characteristic of permanence is never attributed to the Lacanian subject as there is no particular point when the subject appears as a complete whole. The subject arrives through a fleeting process of 'alienation and separation'. The concept of alienation and separation was reiterated by Lacan as the subject and the other's desire. According to Lacan's concept of alienation, the child surrenders to the 'other'. As a result, the child becomes the subject of language. But it depends upon the child to choose to submit to language. The child then expresses his wants through the medium of language. The next step is separation which in other words is the 'other's desire. The child, as Lacan mentioned came to this world out of the other's desire, such as pleasure, revenge or power of his parents. Their wants work on the child and is the main attribute for making the child the subject of the language. In this case, we see, as the author mentions that the subject is the outcome of the other's desire. The author further affirmed echoing Lacan, that the subject can never appear in a perfect situation, where thought and being overlapped. This was contrary to the idea of Descartes, who believed that thinking and being coincided. This was the 'Cartesian subject, which Lacan dismissed as the false being. To Lacan, the subject remained detached from the being. Lacan categorically stated as the author put forward is that, there can be no subjectification without metaphors; the subject is formed by the metaphor. The effect of the metaphor is the effect of the subject. Metaphor is therefore, directly linked with subjective analysis. The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink makes for a good read for a student of psychology and psychoanalysis. The author has in exceptional terms shows how Lacan moves away from structuralism and develops the subject as the other of linguistic discourse, its relation with the symbolic order and how it emerges from the Other's desire. Works Cited 1. Homer, Sean. "Jacques Lacan". Routledge, 2005. 2. Fink, Bruce. "The Lacanian Subject: Between Language and Jouissance." Princeton University Press, 1996. 3. Fink, Bruce. "A Clinical Introduction to Lacanian Psychoanalysis: Theory and Technique." Harvard University Press, 1999. 4. Sigmund Freud, "The Structure of the Unconscious". Copyright renewed 1961 by W. J. H. Sprott; reprinted by permission of W. W. Norton & Co., Inc. Retrieved from http://members.tripod.com/anupamm/freudst.html on December 17, 2008. . About Google Book Search - Book Search Blog - Information for Publishers - Provide Feedback - GoogleHome 2008 Google 2008 Google About Google Book Search - Book Search Blog - Information for Publishers - Provide Feedback - GoogleHome 2008 Google About Google Book Search - Book Search Blog - Information for Publishers - Provide Feedback - GoogleHome 2008 Google Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526221-the-lacanian-subject-by-bruce-fink
(The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink Book Report/Review)
The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526221-the-lacanian-subject-by-bruce-fink.
“The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526221-the-lacanian-subject-by-bruce-fink.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink

Strange Beliefs by Bruce Dakowski

In the movie review "Strange Beliefs by bruce Dakowski" unfamiliar and taboo dogmas, faith in witchcraft and relation to the livestock of the Azande and Nuer tribes are presented not as a form of primitive behavior or irrational beliefs but as the formal African religion adopted by anthropologists.... In “Strange Beliefs”, a documentary film produced and directed by Andre Singer and written and presented by bruce Dakowski, ethnic communities have been discovered and observed by the reputable anthropologist, Sir Edward Evans-Pritchard, and their bizarre philosophies and views were shown to the world....
3 Pages (750 words) Movie Review

Bruce Smith Is a Totally Incompetent Manager

At the outset when one is informed about the opinions and reactions of the staff of bruce Smith about his leadership ability it seems to be an open and shut case where the verdict is in favor of bruce.... But when we are confronted with the negative feedback coming from fellow managers from different units, one begins to wonder whether they are being unreasonable in their evaluation or whether there are serious issues with bruce.... hellip; A cursory evaluation of the situation throws up happy subordinates and unhappy peers. Let us evaluate bruce's strength's and weaknesses using Mintzberg's Theory of what managers do....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Power, Desire, Difference

To borrow the vocabulary of mainstream psychoanalysis for a moment, this intervention is critical to the process of psychical differentiation, to the subject's differentiating itself from others; and this is one reason why sanity relies on the symbolic (Withford:1988).... As the mark of need, it pertains to the fact that the subject is not complete unto itself.... This brings to a critical lacanian claim that sexual difference is the crucial one in being able to speak, thus think; and, mutatis mutandis, that speaking is critical to sexual difference....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Clever Marketing for Luxury Goods in the Fashion Industry

The first portion of the essay looked into the demographical information of the respondents of the study.... It first looked into the number of years that the number of years by which the latter are working as members of the marketing industry within the luxury fashion industry.... hellip; The essay looks into the ability of the financial groups to enhance the brand image of the companies to which the respondents belong....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The Cognitive Basis of Visual Object Perception

ldquo;The psychological study of visual perception grew out of the philosophy of mind” (bruce et al 2003, p.... This essay analyzes that visual perception, particularly the recognition of objects is an immediate but complex process.... Objects are defined as solid bodies of substance which show “spatiotemporal continuity, cohere within their boundaries when they move, and move only when contacted by other objects”....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Baconian, and Baroque Systems of Vision

In this essay, the author demonstrates how Renaissance was a remarkable epoch in history as the start of a philosophical understanding of visuality in the context of modernism.... Also, the author describes Martin Jay, who baptized the “scopic regimes of modernity”.... hellip; The Cartesian model, known as Cartesian Perspectivalism centers itself in the “harmonious and scientific” approach in defining a vision....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Lacanian Mirror Stage for Theorizing Film Spectatorship

Althusser considers the ideological interpellation of the subject where individuals misrecognize themselves with the socially given identity, and then they start to see themselves in this form.... We choose to believe or at least get the effect from what we see.... But the debate gets more interesting when this seeing is about one's own reflection in the mirror....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Robert Bruce as a Great Scottish King

Robert bruce was born on 11 July 1274 to an aristocratic Scottish family who controlled huge swathes of land in Scotland, showing their extensive power over the masses (Halliday 2012, n.... At the heat of the succession dispute in Scotland, bruce's father was amongst the… Currently, the English king, Edward I chose John Balliol to be the king, bit Balliol did not receive the backing of bruce and his family.... When Edward I invaded Scotland, he ruled it as a province of England, but later, bruce When Wallace was defeated, bruce became the custodian of Scotland ruling it with Comyn but they later fell out....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us