StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Greek history reading analyze in comparing character of Helen in two reading - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Greek history reading analyze in comparing character of Helen in two reading

In this account, Helen is portrayed as a victim of circumstances who had no choice but to go with Paris and succumb to his every whim and demand in order to save her life. In the poem we see Helen "dressed herself in fine silvery linens and came out of her bedroom crying softly" when she heard of Menelaus' attack on Sparta clearly illustrating she had no alternative but to wait and see what the aftermath of the war will bring for her future.
Later, talking to Paris's father, she says, "death should have been a sweeter evil to me" explaining that she should have taken her own life than yield to Paris's seizure. She incriminates herself by calling herself a "shameless bitch" for yielding to his demands. Furthermore, she is seen as very embarrassed to have had her family find her in a situation which she apparently had no choice.
There are several colors to Helen's character that are portrayed in Homer's Iliad. She calls herself a "hateful wife" when she thinks of Menelaus winning her away from Paris. On Paris's return and eventual defeat in the Trojan War, Helen reproofs him by telling him he should have been killed by Menelaus, a "real hero"
In the Iliad, Helen is represented as a prey plucked from her serene life with her husband and taken away by Paris to be subjected to subservience despite her many objections. She is shown to have compassion, guilt, love and even acceptance in the way she lives her life in Paris's kingdom awaiting her end.

However, in Helen a play by Euripides, the playwright puts the theory that Helen was a victim of circumstances down and has something else to say. Helen is sought by Menelaus, a grieving husband, who wants to bring her to justice by killing her following the rumors that she went to Paris willingly and was not abducted after all.

Hecuba, Paris's mother describes Helen as a woman who "captivates you with longing", "destroys cities" and "sets homes aflame". While Helen defends herself saying that she was bought and sold for her beauty and has been blameless even attempting to run away, Hecuba negates this by saying she should have hung herself if she was so desperate to get out. Helen states she was kept as a wife by her new husband "in defiance of the Trojans" and Hecuba negates that as well. She is characterized as a vicious and calculating woman who Hecuba states "saw my son in the splendor of gold" and "looked forward to a deluge of extravagance" while Helen says she grieves the death of the Trojans. This is a total contradiction to what the Homer states in the Iliad.

Essentially, Helen has been depicted as the cause of the war between the Trojans and the Greeks whatever the truth may or may not have been. Homer too has treated Helen as a cause of war but also as a helpless victim of her celebrated beauty.

There could be any number of reasons why Euripides depicted Helen in a negative light. Some scholars say that it is impossible for so many heads of states / cities to leave their work to go all the way to Troy to rescue a chit of a woman to whom they did not have much interest in except for her renowned beauty. At the time this story is placed, a lot of women and children were abducted and sold in slavery in Troy and it is thought by some scholars that this was the reason so many city heads brought about the Trojan War. This theory is followed by the hypothesis that Helen never existed! It was all a ply to put the Trojans down for their illegal slave trade.

However, if ...Show more

Summary

Helen of Sparta, later Helen of Troy was one of the most popular figures in Greek mythology. She was the daughter if Zeus and Leda and the wife of King Menelaus of Sparta. Helen's fame came not only from her beauty but also her alleged abduction by Paris also known as Alexander due to which the Trojan War came about.
Author : hklocko
Greek history reading analyze in comparing character of Helen in two reading essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Greek history reading analyze in comparing character of Helen in two reading"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Close Reading/Reading Response
In a factious manner, Clark spells out how one of the best reports from America is sent to check on research findings on moon where scientific research and exploration has been going on. However, on reaching the moon, he notices a difference in the reaction and reception he receives from the community living there, majority of who are the scientific explorers.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Reading Assessment
8). It is also the root of a person’s education life. Reading and writing begins at this stage thus teachers struggle to develop the two most important senses in the human growth process. These are the sense of touch and sight. Children are first subjected to the basic alphabetical letters in which he or she learns to pronouns as well as write.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Reading
The best application of such principles ensures that teachers understand how their learners study; they also create a community of learners, and adopt a balanced approach to literacy instruction. This would only yield positive results in teaching and reading if the core principles of Syntactic and Semantic come in place.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Reading Speed
Successfully reading requires that the readers develop and enhance their reading skills to adopt more efficient and practical ways of reading. While reading itself is an important and interesting area to cover, this paper narrows its scope to look at reading speed.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Comparing two records of a significant event in history
While the book does not detail where he obtained his information, it can be assumed that most of it was general knowledge and from his personal observations of the area. The account was written not long after Hannibal crossed the Alps it is more of a detailed re-telling of the events than a historic accounting.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
History Essay; Required Reading Provided
This makes the working life of the servant harder than the slaves as they are put to hard labor, have poor housing and are given very little to eat. The diet of the servants also leaves much
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Reading
According to the French philosopher Barthes, the role of the reader when going through text is to be writerly instead of being “readerly.” As they go through the essay the reader should add information and write with the author (Mavor, 272). The aspect of being a
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Close reading and analyze
It moves there with tantalising speed and makes one a bard. This is true of the relationship between Von Aschenbach and Tadzio. With the first strike of love, Aschenbach’s heart is never the same forever, though he intelligently tries to sweep his true feelings for Tadzio
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Reading
The blame for lack of intensive reading of these printed materials is to be levied on the rapid pace of life. Today, people only engage in reading these printed materials in order to show courtesy. They do not read them to obtain knowledge. Today’s generation
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Analyze the reading
The target text emphasizes on the aspect of co-existence between man and man. Within the society, it is the jurisdiction of natural law that every individual should get
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation