StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Philosophy - Practical Ethics - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Philosophy - Practical Ethics

In this paper I will discuss the moral difference between abortion and infanticide with special reference to the views of Michael Tooley and Mary Anne Warren. Metaphysics is an area of philosophy that deals with questions having to do with the ultimate grounding and nature of things in the world. It is concerned with such diverse topics as the mind/body problem, identity, God, the existence and nature of universals, the existence and nature of the soul, and so on. Thus, the morality of abortion, if it is to be construed as contingent upon the nature of the fetus, is an issue whose resolution depends on which metaphysical view of the human person is correct. Given this, let us take a look at Michael's argument.
Although he makes many provocative and interesting claims that deserve a reply, I will focus on a small portion of his essay that I believe is the core of his case. According to Michael, "the first principle of religious liberty is that laws will not be based upon abstract metaphysical speculation, but will be fashioned through the democratic processes in which every perspective is subject to critical analysis (Michael, 2000). Any proposal must be open either to revision or rejection." He then goes on to cite, as an example of what is not speculative metaphysics, the viability standard proposed by the Court in Roe.
I will first critique Michael's use and defense of the viability standard and then move on to a general critique of Michael's view of "abstract metaphysical speculation." ...
the viability standard in particular, fairly, sensibly, and effectively functions to safeguard the constitutional liberties of pregnant women while recognizing and accommodating the State's interest in potential human life. The viability line reflects the biological facts and truths of fetal development; it marks the threshold moment prior to which a fetus cannot survive separate from the woman and cannot reasonably and objectively be regarded as a subject of rights or interests distinct from, or paramount to, those of the pregnant woman (Michael, 2000). At the same time, the viability standard takes account of the undeniable fact that as the fetus evolves into its postnatal form, and as it loses its dependence on the uterine environment, the State's interest in the fetus' potential human life, and in fostering a regard for human life in general, becomes compelling.
Michael's argument for the viability standard is nearly identical to the one presented by Blackmun: Part of the genius in Roe v. Wade (now affirmed in Casey) was putting forward the standard of viability: that stage of development at which the fetus has sufficient neurological and physical maturation to survive outside the womb. Prior to that, the fetus simply is not sufficiently developed as an independent being deserving and requiring the full protection of the law, i.e., a person (Michael, 2000). The notion of viability correlates biological maturation with personal identity in a way that can be recognized and accepted by reasonable people.
Michael's use of the viability standard is seriously flawed. First, he praises the Court's legal use of the standard and then employs the standard as a decisive moment at which he believes it is reasonable to say that the fetus becomes a person, even though that is ...Show more

Summary

Any proposal must be open either to revision or rejection." He then goes on to cite, as an example of what is not speculative metaphysics, the viability standard proposed by the Court in Roe. …
Author : isidrooreilly
Philosophy - Practical Ethics essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Philosophy - Practical Ethics"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

What does levinas mean when he claims that ethics is the first philosophy
Levinas' First Philosophy “Levinas does not want to propose laws or moral rules…it is a matter of [writing] an ethics of ethics” (Derrida, 1967). What does this mean? “An ethics of ethics means, here, the exploration of conditions of possibility of any interest in good actions or lives.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
A Distinction Between Practical Anthropology And Moral Philosophy
The works of Kant (1728-1804), a German philosopher, are mostly drawn from the observations and his own ideas on the nature of humans. The major emphasis of this philosopher is on the priori or pure part of the moral philosophy.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Philosophy Ethics
Mill explained that Rule Utilitarianism was the rule that worked towards maximizing happiness. According to this rule an act is moral and correct if it brings about happiness for the maximum number of people. In the same way it puts an action to be morally incorrect if it brings about unhappiness and is the cause of displeasure for the maximum number of people.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Philosophy
Metaphysics also investigates the core groupings of things such as the physical and the mental, and the examination of reality in contrast to appearance. It studies the world as a whole basing on a presumption of first principles. Determinism states that there are conditions for any particular occurrence and, in the absence of such conditions, that particular occurrence cannot come to be.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Philosophy Ethics
According to Nietzsche, master morality is based on strength and what is strong is good while that which is weak is wrong, therefore, those who have master morality are strong and have created their own morality and they judge themselves. For master morality, bad is seen as a failure and a defeat as well as loss of power (Solomon132).
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Philosophy (practical ethics)
However, Mackinnon has been recognized as the strongest enemy of pornography and her views have helped the students in identifying the right definition of pornography. She is not for the total ban of
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Philosophy - Introduction to Ethics
Such acts could be held to be universally true. Due to their rationality such acts yielded complete happiness. According to Kant only perfect duty held unconditional moral worth. The
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Ethics for Professionals - Professionals & Deception (Philosophy Topic)
ons, for example in universities and professional associations, not one has negated the immorality of lying and deception in the professions; telling the truth has been always the maxim (Gert 1988, cited in Berreman 2003, p. 98) making the profession and the practitioners more
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Practical Anthropology and Moral Philosophy Distinction
The difference between Kant’s moral philosophy and the empirical moral philosophy is that the later is biased towards the posterior principles or those that are garnered through the observations and experiences of human beings. Kant, using this distinction, referred to the empirical moral philosophy as moral anthropology.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Philosophy
In comparison, it exhibits differences to other ways of addressing problems through its dependence on coherent arguments like that of God (Lawhead 345). In addition, philosophy mainly refers to basic principles and ideas in life that guides individuals in
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation