StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

The Fellowship of the Ring. The book vs movie - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet
This study is concerned not so much with minor changes that were done for the sake of time constraints – for example, the fact that the hobbits had a long journey by river before they reached Bree – but rather with more thematic and seemingly unnecessary changes that seem to veer away from the spirit of the book.
The depiction of the fight at Weathertop between Aragorn and the hobbits and the Nazgul is one of the sequences where the portrayal of the characters of the hobbits – especially Merry and Pippin – seems to represent them in a different light than did Tolkien. In the book, Aragorn himself starts the fire at the mountaintop. In the movie, however, Merry, Pippin and Sam foolishly start the fire because they are hungry and want to fry some tomatoes and bacon:
Pippin: Can I have some meat?
Merry: Okay. Want some tomatoes, Sam? Great tomatoes!
Frodo: (Waking up from sleep) What are you doing?
Merry: Tomatoes, sausages, nice crispy bacon.
Sam: We saved some for you, Mr. Frodo.
Frodo: Put it out, you fools! Put it out! (Begins stamping out the fire)
Pippin: Oh that’s nice! Ash on my tomatoes!
This is not the first attempt to portray Merry, Pippin and Sam as the comic relief in the movie. In earlier scenes such as the one where Pippin wants a ‘second breakfast’ but Aragorn will have none of it, the mood is at least light-hearted. In the Weathertop scene, the audience is made to believe that Merry and Pippin are gluttonous, reckless hobbits who neither know nor care about the importance of the mission they are on. Their stupidity is directly responsible for Frodo’s being stabbed by the Mordor blade carried by one of the Nazgul. This scene also highlights the nature of Frodo’s experience with the ring. ...
e Nazgul is one of the sequences where the portrayal of the characters of the hobbits - especially Merry and Pippin - seems to represent them in a different light than did Tolkien. In the book, Aragorn himself starts the fire at the mountaintop. In the movie, however, Merry, Pippin and Sam foolishly start the fire because they are hungry and want to fry some tomatoes and bacon:
Pippin: Can I have some meat
Merry: Okay. Want some tomatoes, Sam Great tomatoes!
Frodo: (Waking up from sleep) What are you doing
Merry: Tomatoes, sausages, nice crispy bacon.
Sam: We saved some for you, Mr. Frodo.
Frodo: Put it out, you fools! Put it out! (Begins stamping out the fire)
Pippin: Oh that's nice! Ash on my tomatoes!
This is not the first attempt to portray Merry, Pippin and Sam as the comic relief in the movie. In earlier scenes such as the one where Pippin wants a 'second breakfast' but Aragorn will have none of it, the mood is at least light-hearted. In the Weathertop scene, the audience is made to believe that Merry and Pippin are gluttonous, reckless hobbits who neither know nor care about the importance of the mission they are on. Their stupidity is directly responsible for Frodo's being stabbed by the Mordor blade carried by one of the Nazgul.
This scene also highlights the nature of Frodo's experience with the ring. As in the Prancing Pony when he puts on the ring accidentally, Frodo is shown by Jackson to experience visions of Sauron's eye, which is nowhere in the book. The changes that Frodo goes through are psychological rather than literal in Tolkien's book. In the book, Frodo just turns invisible, as Bilbo used to, when he puts the ring on. While this may be attributed to the director's need to visually depict the trauma that Frodo goes through because of the ...Show more
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Fellowship of the Ring. The book vs movie Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/miscellaneous/287395-the-fellowship-of-the-ring-the-book-vs-movie
(The Fellowship of the Ring. The Book Vs Movie Essay)
https://studentshare.net/miscellaneous/287395-the-fellowship-of-the-ring-the-book-vs-movie.
“The Fellowship of the Ring. The Book Vs Movie Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/miscellaneous/287395-the-fellowship-of-the-ring-the-book-vs-movie.
  • Cited: 0 times

Summary

This paper examines some of the differences between Tolkien’s epic and Jackson’s adaptation to analyse whether or not the movie seems to be faithful to Tolkien’s original. The scenes chosen for this study, which focuses on changes between the book and the movie, are the following: the fight at Weathertop, Arwen’s rescue of Frodo when he is stabbed, Aragorn and Arwen’s meeting at Rivendell, and Pippin’s knocking the skeleton into the well in the Mines of Moria…
The Fellowship of the Ring. The book vs movie
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"The Fellowship of the Ring. The book vs movie"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

The Legend of Sleepy Hollow: Movie VS. Book
The purpose of many novels is to entertain, but often literary works have a different style and goal as is the case in Washington Irving’s story. Irving is a satirical writer which is no doubt an appealing style to Tim Burton.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Realism and the Lord of the Ring 3 Movie
Realism is notably one of the main forces dominating international relations and therefore influencing such activities as foreign policy.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Lord of The Rings: Fellowship of the Ring
He explains his desire to create new myths as coming from a strong wish not to keep retelling the myths that had already been told. In creating new myths, Tolken invented new languages and built the cultures and myths around the new languages that he had created.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
A New Meaning for Green House
Houweling Nurseries as a forward-looking example to other agricultural business The history of Houweling nurseries that includes its humble beginning, its success, and long-term sustainability capacity that it has demonstrated establishes it as a model for other agricultural business to emulate.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Book and Movie versions of Lord of the Rings The Fellowship of the Ring
The first of The Lord of the Rings trilogy, Fellowship transports readers to Tolkien’s fantasy world of Middle Earth, a land inhabited by odd races of beings and strange and horrific creatures.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
The lord of the rings: the fellowship of the ring: a review of Peter Jacksons rendition of the book into film
Not often does a viewer leave the theater with a light feeling that the film seen is truly faithful to the literary work it has brought to the widescreen. However, it is understandable that despite the best efforts a filmmaker exerts in making the adapted movie he or she is working on to be as faithful to the work it is based on as possible, true faithfulness is nearly impossible.
11 pages (2750 words) Essay
Frodos Testing: The Development of a Hero In The Fellowship of the Ring
R. R. Tolkien's The Fellowship of the Ring goes through exactly these aforementioned tests, moving towards the culmination of his quest in the next two books of the trilogy. He has five key moments of testing in this first book: the initial acceptance of the quest, the need for courage and action to protect his fellow Hobbits, the stronger resolution of his accepting the quest (through a greater understanding of all the ring's possible ramifications and the necessity of its destruction), the defense of his companions when attacked by Orcs, and finally, by the resolution to dissolve the fellowship of the ring both to remove temptation from the group and remove the danger to him of the group
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
The Lord of the Rings - The Fellowship of the Ring
He knew the responsibility given to him by Gandalf might cost him his life, but he took on that dangerous task anyway. He also showed enormous resistance to the evil emanating from the ring. When his other companions found themselves vulnerable to
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Discuss the role of nature, its character and its significance in the fellowship of the ring. from the book lord of the rings
Secondly, it assumes a character on its own, not just some background element in support of the narrative, directly influencing the course of the
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Argumentative Analysis - The Legend of Sleepy Hollow: Movie VS. Book
Some readers may object to these changes but often these are done for reasons of time constraints and other issues unique to film than are not as restrictive in writing a book. However, in cases such as
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Let us find you another Essay on topic The Fellowship of the Ring. The book vs movie for FREE!
Contact us:
+16312120006
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us