Man vs Nature in Hawthornes The Birthmark and Jack Londons To Build a Fire - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Man vs Nature in Hawthornes The Birthmark and Jack Londons To Build a Fire

The point is that although man cannot hope to overcome nature, some men are foolhardy enough to try. Such men usually get adequate warning and advice, and if they choose to ignore these, they are doomed.
Hawthorne reveals that some scientists of Aylmer's time believed that they could rob the secret of creation from Nature, but he only wonders whether "Aylmer possessed this degree of faith in man's ultimate control over Nature." Anyway, Aylmer is so blinded by his learning that he believes that he can correct an error of Nature. The 'error' referred to is nothing more than a tiny birthmark on the otherwise perfect face of his beloved wife Georgiana. Aylmer has been warned in a dream that an attempt to remove the mark could place the life of his beloved in danger. Yet, led on by his confidence in his skills and the power of Science, or pulled by Fate, Aylmer decides to remove the birthmark. Georgiana supports her husband in this experiment because she prefers even death to the possession of a face that could 'shock' or disgust her husband. She has great faith in her husband's knowledge and abilities. When he assures her that he could remove the birthmark, she encourages him, without of any thought of the danger to herself.
Aylmer is assisted in the operation by Aminadab, who with "his vast strength, his shaggy hair, his smoky aspect, and the indescribable earthiness that incrusted hi ...
Download paper

Summary

The 'man' in Jack London's story "To Build a Fire" and Aylmer the "man of science" in Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Birthmark" both appear extremely foolish in considering themselves superior to nature. Aylmer, the man of science, is a genius whose pride leads him to believe that he can improve upon nature's creation…
Author : faheyhassie

Related Essays

Jack Londons To Build a Fire Book Report/Review
He resolves to die in dignity and prepares to freeze to death in the snow.
...
2 pages (502 words) Book Report/Review
"To Build a Fire" by Jack London
Jack London makes his narration poignant by rendering all the feelings and thoughts that passes through the man's mind all throughout the story, and the heroic fight displayed by the man to avert his fate is best narrated by him. The story ultimately ends with the tragic death of the man who fails to cope up with the extreme cold. Jack London is regarded as an idealistic writer as his short stories always bring to the attention of the readers the ideas and ideals that pass through the minds and inner consciousness of his characters. The attempt of this paper is to unearth the idealistic traits...
8 pages (2008 words) Book Report/Review
To Build a Fire by Jack London
He cannot fathom the severity of the extreme cold conditions in the area, nor does he foresee how savage nature can become at times. Though new to the place, the man simply ignores the advice of the old-timer of Sulphur Creek. Unable to survive in the harsh weather condition, he finally freezes to death; a helpless prey to the savageness of nature. The story reveals how the character of a person determines the course of his life and brings him his doom.
...
3 pages (753 words) Book Report/Review
The victim: an analysis of the man's character in "to build a fire" by Jack London
It's easier to conclude that the man has suicidal tendencies to start with since he decided to go on in a journey that would put him in harm's way. Also, the end of the story which shows that he decided to stop fighting and suddenly had the desire to die ("Well, he was bound to freeze anyway, and he might as well take it decently.") (London) seemed to support the claim.However, if a reader would scrutinize the story carefully, one may find that there are many information in Jack London's work that negate such a conclusion.First point: Right after the opening paragraphs that give the reader a...
3 pages (753 words) Book Report/Review
Jack Londons To Build a Fire
However, considering the elements of naturalist movement and Man vs. Nature conflict in the story, the principal characteristic of the protagonist is his fight against nature all through the life and his ultimate submission to the greater power of the nature which was most comfortable and satisfying to him.
...
2 pages (502 words) Book Report/Review
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!