StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Bib 8 - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Bib 8

We have to seek the historical truth in the middle and to take into consideration the historical moment as well as who documented it.
War is a tragedy. And the losers in a war having been destroyed and devastated are left at the will and mercy of the winners. We are led to believe that winners are those who direct the course of history and they are to decide what will be written in the textbooks. In this essay I will investigate and show that indeed winners respectively those in power write the history, providing substantial examples.
The history is as true as the victors say it is. Beresford (2003) claims that there is much evidence to justify that indeed, winner write the history. He narrates about a recent discovery that he made about submarine warfare during the World War II. Bereford (2003) never doubted it that German submarines were torpedoed. However when the archives were opened few decades later, the myth clashed, as apparently it was only one such recorded submarine attack. Is this fair This rhetorical question pervades generations of historians and scholars. My opinion is that it is not fair for history to be written by the winners, but the facts show something else.
Bereford (2003) cited Jean-Luc Picard who famously said that the victors invariably write the history to their own advantage. In his article Wollman (2003) asks why we are flooded with terrible cases of war crimes committed by the Iraqis, however none such occasions are shown for the U.S violations. He quotes that according to the A.U.N. resolution it is forbidden to use uranium shells because it is declared as a weapon for mass destruction. Nevertheless, U.S. military has regularly used it, which will cause deadly diseases in the civilians and which doctors started to document recently. The mistakes of the victors have to be hidden. New, displaying revelations are not allowed, because they are painfully reminding of the past mistakes. It is a common trait for the winners to want to forget their faults. That is why the history is written only with the version that today's winners provide. The version of the losers will be heard and revised at least half a century later.

When studying history, people have to be careful with the sources they use. They have to consider that we never hear the losers and if we did, we have to weigh their story as well. The most dangerous pitfall that we can fall into is to believe that every source of misleading just because we are slaves to the clich - history written by the winners. This might lead us to suspect the authenticity of every document, since surely if it is written, the winners did it. We can never to able to solve this historical dilemma, and the likelihood to trust the winners is greater than vice versa. I believe that the majority of historical evidence is based on true facts, which are not constantly manipulated by those who take power.

(2) How does this fact shape the portrayal of societies unlucky enough to lose a pivotal confrontation
Not only do the winners write the history, but for the sake of history at least what is left for the losers is the chance to revise it. I know that the Vatican, for example, is absolutely strict about the historical facts and does not allow for the archives to be opened if a century has not passed since the event. The ...Show more


Most people would agree with the idea that history is written by the victors, meaning that the more successful (militarily, economically, authoritatively, etc.) countries both receive the most attention and decide on how to present themselves to the world.
Author : mina62
Bib 8 essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Bib 8"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Discussion 8
The article by Heyman (2012) mentioned six ways the company may be adjudged to be proactive by the way it conducts its meetings. Apparently my company implements all of these, although some more regularly than others. First, meetings are always scheduled with a clear agenda and focus.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Bib 6
In the early 1st Century, Saul – also called Paul – was a Hellenistic Jew who ardently had set out to persecute Christian converts. However, the message reached him at Damascus in the
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Bib 8
Their letters and books provide insight into their lives. Two very important players in the New Testament history are the apostles Peter and John who contributed much towards evangelizing the lands and creating churches after the works of Paul. They are
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Journal 8
w that of an airplane and then other depictions of subjects that do not seem to correlate but could be representative of the time frame in which he painted it. However, since it is a painting that is seen in a complete 360 degree angle, there are is a complete continual line of
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Journal #8
These functions were found to be better with elite players than the less elite players (Bhanoo 1). The claims that top soccer scorers have superior brain functions
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Assignment 8
manufacturers make a big proportion of the total number of sales while others like consultants, land surveyors, architects and writers only make a small proportion. Key: 1-manufacturers 2-public utilities 3-engineers 4-hospitals 5-radio/TV 6-city/town planners 7-small
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Reflection 8
According to the article developed by Berry from the book attached, passing the message on dealing with environmental effects and avoiding their wide
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Chicago 8
The movie provides the audience with the chance to enter into the judicial and political system of USA during such times (Perry). The case is based on an anti-war rally that was organized by Chicago in collaboration with DNC
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Assignment 8
However, the main purpose of action planning is understanding the situation investigated during the research and discovering new problems. The other reason for an action plan is discovering an
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
RAW #8
This principle means that forceful labor is illegal and amounts to slavery, child abuse or physical abduction among other employment offenses that violate human privileges. For companies to adhere to this principle, it means that they must a clear policy that rejects
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us