Comparative Analysis of Million dollar Baby and A Small, Good Thing - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Comparative Analysis of Million dollar Baby and A Small, Good Thing

X. Toole's "Million $$$ Baby" and the connection of the Weisses and the baker in Raymond Carver's "A Small, Good Thing."
The characters of Frankie Dunn and the baker both find themselves making a moral choice. For Frankie, he must choose whether to act upon Maggie's request for euthanasia. Maggie first won his respect by through her own dedication to boxing, the sport that he loves; through the rise and collapse of her career, Frankie has come to view her like a daughter. Frankie's initial hesitation in training Maggie hinged around his dislike of seeing a woman get hurt, and it is this chivalrous instinct that gnaws at him when Maggie becomes quadriplegic and suicidal. The baker also has a moral foundation for his actions: he comments working that 2/3 of his day is spent working in the bakery. He has every right to expect payment for his work but perhaps not the right to seek restitution in the manner that he does. When the baker is informed of the child's death, he is appropriately chagrinned to have made the harassing phone calls. With what little humanity he is able to salvage, the baker offers the Weiss couple food, observing that "Eating is a small, good thing in a time like this." (Carver 88). By this he acknowledges that some things in life cannot be changed, but can only be endured. Food will comfort and sustain the body, giving it the strength to continue. ...
Download paper


Human experience revolves around joy and tragedy. When joy arrives, it is most fully realized when shared with another. In the case of tragedy, however, all too often one must deal with loss or disappointment alone when another's presence would be of most help…
Author : casperhazel

Related Essays

Comparative Analysis of Slavery
Within his book for instance, he emphasizes that an approximate 82 percent of the Union officers had articulated patriotic assurances , at the same time as only an approximate 52 percent of the Confederate soldiers did so; an approximate 84 percent of the South Carolinians he considered were powerfully patriotic, while an approximate 46 percent of the North Carolinians were.13 He had made an attempt to quantify the Confederates' racial slavery . Their observations along with their views on slavery. Their aim was not really to quantify their findings along with their racist comments; however it…
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Organizational Behavior Comparative Analysis
And its immense success can be attributed to its unusual model and people management style, which will be discussed in detail in this document (Doganis, 2002).…
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Too Much of a Good Thing by Dan Kindlon
This really shatters their growth and strength and finally they loose their mental stability at times of depression. He says that many of them blame their parents for being too protective, and just because of this they loose all the chances of meeting new and varied challenges. In this way, the book also examines children's attitude towards their parents.…
4 pages (1004 words) Book Report/Review
A Small, Good Thing by Raymond Carver: A Review of the Literature
Scotty is unconscious after the hit, and taken to the hospital. The baker ends up phoning the family's house in the middle of the night (when he does his baking) that night, wondering why no one had come yet to pick up the cake. At the same time, no answers are being given to Scotty's family on why Scotty isn't waking up. The parents notice that when the doctor comes in to the hospital to check on Scotty, he is tanned and meticulously dressed, and they wonder how he could have a life outside of the hospital when they do not. Scotty ends up dying, "a one-in-a-million circumstance" (Carver,…
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Million Dollar Consulting by Alan Weiss
Client relations are dominated by the consulting sector. As client needs for specialist advice change, so does the nature of consultancy, and it becomes increasingly difficult to distinguish between overlapping old and new requirements. A chief concern in human relations is to understand the visible and hidden selves of clients. Employees tend to judge as unacceptable behavior that deviates or appears to deviate from their own adopted norms. Very often, consultants do not take into account the role of clients' value and their loyalty. Alan Weiss underlines the importance of these concepts and…
3 pages (753 words) Book Report/Review
comparing two story( A small good thing & The girl with the pimply face)
The two doctors’ communication with their patients demonstrates how different the two doctors approach their jobs. The central tenet of Williams’ “The Girl with the Pimply Face” is that doctors are human and are subjected to human emotions. Carver approaches the topic from the other side by displaying the harmful effects of a doctor who is professional, but patronizing in “A Small, Good Thing”.…
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
the summary of Million Dollar Arm
To finance the trip, training and all the other requirements for the scheme, Bernstein convinces an investor and extremely wealthy business owner, known as Mr. Chang to help them. Bernstein convinces the investor to create and support a show called “Million Dollar Arm”, which they will use to get the right, skilled players that they are looking for once they go to India.…
2 pages (502 words) Movie Review
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!