StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Concept of Moral Reasons - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Concept of Moral Reasons" discusses that one of the moral issues at stake is honesty because Jane needs to admit that she has been eavesdropping on her friend’s conversations. Invasion of privacy is also an additional moral issue at stake…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
The Concept of Moral Reasons
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Concept of Moral Reasons"

In addition, the public and the school are also involved because they do not support abortion. Jane has a moral stake in admitting that she has been eavesdropping on the conversation of her best friend, and acting that is ethically wrong. She should be a loyal friend to Sue, who does not invade her privacy without her knowledge. In addition, Jane has a moral stake of revealing that Sue and her younger brother have been sexually active and that Sue is considering an abortion.

The school has a moral stake because it needs to maintain high levels of morality and a remarkable reputation. Without a doubt, the moral stakes of Jane and Sue are conflicting. If Jane decides to admit that she has been eavesdropping on Sue, their friendship will be compromised due to the invasion of privacy. In addition, if Jane decides to tell the truth about Sue’s plan of carrying out an abortion, she will also be putting the interests of her brother at risk. On the other hand, Sue’s moral stake involves telling the truth that she has been sexually active and taking responsibility for her actions by keeping the baby.

Sue also needs to identify the real father of her unborn child. It is Sue’s right to expect her phone call conversations to be entirely private (Fink, 2008). Assuming you are a deontologist like W.D. Ross, how would you weigh the different moral stakes, interests, or duties against each other? That is, are some moral stakes “weightier” than others? Are some moral considerations or interests or stakes more important than others? Can you rank them? From the case study, it is evident that Sue’s right to privacy is not as important as a violation of moral law and taking one’s life through an abortion.

In addition, Sue’s right to privacy appears to be less important than her indulgence in irresponsible sexual activity and secretly considering an abortion. In the case of Jane, invasion of privacy appears to be a less important issue than exposing the truth, which can save the life of an unborn child. From the facts provided in the case, Jane should reveal the truth that she has been eavesdropping on Sue’s conversation. On the other hand, Sue should admit that she has been indulging in sexual activity and that she is pregnant.

She should also be willing to take up the responsibility of bringing up the unborn child. Jane’s younger brother should also assume the responsibilities of a father if he is the one responsible for impregnating Sue (Vaughn, 2013). How would a Utilitarian Approach this Case? From a utilitarian approach, the right thing to do would be the one that promotes good for everyone. Therefore, Jane should not say anything about Sue’s pregnancy. Therefore, she will not be compelled to admit that she was eavesdropping, and their friendship will normally continue.

In addition, if Jane keeps quiet, she will save her brother the trouble of being involved in a scandal because of his sexual activity. If Sue goes on with the abortion, she will have cleared the evidence of her sexual irresponsibility and will remain in the school without anyone suspecting her actions. However, Sue is likely to suffer the effects of her actions in the future when the truth about the abortion eventually comes out (Vaughn, 2013). How do you know an issue is moral or not? How do you distinguish it from other types of arguments, non-moral arguments?

A moral argument involves conflicting ethical beliefs and moral stakes. Moral arguments involve actions that have the potential to harm or help the individual, as well as other people in society. Therefore, a moral argument has alternatives that the individual can choose from depending on their level of morality. On the other hand, non-moral arguments do not have any ethical principles or moral stakes (Fink, 2008). What is the structure of a moral argument; what must an argument have to be considered a valid moral argument?

Moral arguments comprise of two elements. The first element is a conclusion supported by the ethical beliefs while the second element comprises premises that denote the reasons for supporting the conclusion (Vaughn, 2013).

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Moral Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1689398-moral
(Moral Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1)
https://studentshare.org/social-science/1689398-moral.
“Moral Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1689398-moral.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Concept of Moral Reasons

The Metaphysics of Morals by Emmanual Kant

For example, the enlightenment era marks many such instances when the philosophers have justified imperialism in the light of moral explanations.... Many different philosophers argue that Kant went too forward and ignorant when describing morals, and giving moral theories when using logic to develop a cause and effect relationship....
24 Pages (6000 words) Essay

Overview of Immanuel Kants Grounding for the metaphysics of morals

After Kant laid down the principles of moral law, he stated the reason behind why we should be moral, and that reason is freedom.... When we use others as purposes to reach our goals, we are going against the concept that we, as individuals, are our own means to an end.... Then there is metaphysics, a completely different category that focuses solely on concepts as they apply to moral or physical experiences.... It is often believed that moral responsibilities are only based on concepts of rationale, rather than anything pertaining to personality or culture....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Defining Reason and Morality in Kant

The idea of respect is one that is then further defined with the concept of morality, value and what the end result will be if these ideologies are withheld in any given situation.... This creates a sense of attraction to doing the right action in any given circumstance while building a sense of moral principles that are followed by others within a given environment... the concept which Kant creates is one which he leaves as a basis of being logical in terms of creating responses within the way in which an individual treats another....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Moral Instinct Concepts

Name: Course: Instructor: Date: moral Instinct Introduction The article is about the state of morality in our body since very many people have different views concerning the subject.... The article also states that people practice their moral behavior because they are afraid of punishments which are the consequences of immoral behavior and this pushes them to indulge in socially acceptable standards of the society.... However, the author points out that there are no clear avenues of reasoning and rationalization of the moral behaviors as different societies have different views concerning behavior, as much as people know that some behaviors are wrong and does not meet the standards of morality in the society, others don't understand and can not justify them in this case....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

How Do Emotions Function in Plato, Aristotle and the Stoics' Conceptions of the Good Life

Plato values the concept of emotion but regard beings not to act out of emotions.... The stoic account constructs the concept that human beings are born with an awareness of themselves and environmental factors dictate the state of well-being.... In this context, the right emotions are established from the principle of living a moral life.... In my opinion, Plato concept makes the most sense in that he recognizes that emotions can be constructed....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Kant and Aristotle's Ideas on Morals and Happiness

the concept of Aristotle on the morally right is not the same one that most other philosophers have.... Kant further propagates the idea that a moral decision must be consistent with the moral laws and must be done for moral reasons (61).... There is the biggest concern on who knows who is moral and who is not.... Morality is, therefore, thought by others not to be connected in any way to happiness, for instance, Kant (63) argues that morality is all about doing what is accepted in society as the moral thing to do....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Kant's Moral Philosophy

The author also explains why Kant maintains that moral law cannot be derived from human nature.... Kant believed that unless intuition (or perception) is processed by the empirical concept it remains a raw sensory data without any knowledge of the object.... The intuition relates to the object directly and is particular in nature while an empirical concept relates to several objects (or perceptions) indirectly and is general in nature.... The 'form' is based on intellect (concept) which is independent of all experience and the 'matter' (intuition) is based on sensory impressions or experience we receive through our senses....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

The Concept of Defining Human Existence

This paper "the concept of Defining Human Existence" states that the concept of humanism was one that was debated in the Renaissance period because of the several implications that were a part of this.... the concept of humanism came from writings such as The Divine Comedy, which began to question human existence and the main attributes which one held when living a specific lifestyle.... the concept of human existence through Dante's Divine Comedy and the following lectures then allowed the humanitarian concepts to arise in society and among Christians....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us