StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Internet, Society and Information: A Comparison and Contrast of the Views of Keen and Lanier - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
WRTG 101 08. JULY 2012 The Internet, Society, and Information: A Comparison and Contrast of the Views of Keen and Lanier The internet has been called many things in its somewhat illustrious, somewhat questionable history: a fad, a toy, a series of tubes. Now, however, it has become apparent that the internet is forever changing the way societies that possess it interact with information and the idea of truth and knowledge…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.6% of users find it useful
The Internet, Society and Information: A Comparison and Contrast of the Views of Keen and Lanier
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Internet, Society and Information: A Comparison and Contrast of the Views of Keen and Lanier"

Download file to see previous pages

Andrew Keen, the author of the book “The Cult of the Amateur”, and Jaron Lanier, a computer scientist and prolific writer in the realm of information technology, are two of the most prominent thinkers in this new realm of information. Both are highly weary of the developments of Web 2.0, but for different reasons. While Keen and Lanier agree that the prominence of amateurs in the prolongation of information on the internet is incredibly problematic, and both have a distaste for so-called “crowdsourcing” (the production of material from a large group of people), they disagree on the fundamental problem this causes, with Keen arguing that this issue creates a kind of narcissism and Lanier arguing that the individual becomes lost in the mob in the internet.

On the whole, Lanier’s arguments are more philosophical and more compelling based on his awareness of epistemology, of the effects the flow of information on the internet can have, and his more in-depth knowledge of computer sciences. That is why he can be recommended over Keen in this issue. One of the biggest accomplishments of Web 2.0, and, according to both Keen and Lanier, the biggest failings, is the amalgamation of masses of information on user-driven websites, such as Wikipedia. Both Keen and Lanier agree that the production of material by amateurs is a problem, but they differ greatly on exactly why.

One major agreement between Keen and Lanier is that user-generated ideas of Web 2.0 reduce the quality of the work involved. Keen sees the fundamental problem of user generated content in that it reduces the overall quality of material available because of a lack of so called professional involvement. He says that “user generated content” … “[does away] with high quality information, high-quality entertainment and replaces it with user-generated content, which is unreliable, inane, and often rather corrupt” (Brown, 2012).

Lanier shares the idea that user-generation of content, especially en masse, does not lead to high-quality things – he argues that open source movements have never produced seminal, revolutionary products like the iPhone or Google (Lanier, 2010). He also has some concerns about the nature of content on these websites, but those differ significantly from the concerns of Keen. While Keen and Lanier both agree that crowdsourcing can be problematic, they disagree on the nature of the problems the practice causes.

Keen’s primary focus is on the quality of material. He seems to believe that professional status imbues some kind of power or authority on someone to be able to write more eloquently or accurately on a topic. Lanier, however, does not believe that the non-professional nature of Wikipedia is its fundamental problem, but rather argues that the anonymity and knowledge-lens involved is problematic. In his oft-cited essay “Digital Maoism,” Lanier argues that any single “bottleneck” that channels a great deal of information is fundamentally problematic for a society and that societies function best with a wide series of sources (Lanier, 2006).

Likewise, he argues that the sterile style that is created by a mass of editors rather than a single author presents problems. He believes that, by removing the author’

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Internet, Society and Information: A Comparison and Contrast of Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1453904-comparison-contrast-essay
(The Internet, Society and Information: A Comparison and Contrast of Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1453904-comparison-contrast-essay.
“The Internet, Society and Information: A Comparison and Contrast of Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1453904-comparison-contrast-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Internet, Society and Information: A Comparison and Contrast of the Views of Keen and Lanier

Comparing Born to be Good and Biology of Belief

Studying the work of Keltner in his book, Born to be Good, one is able to drawn clear patterns about his views regarding human emotions.... In contrast, Lipton is of the view that human genetic have a limited role to play in the conditioning of the individual, as the for the most part the environmental factors are responsible for the development of behavioral patterns.... In order to contrast the two works, it is first important to study the works in detail....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Anthony Knox Interview

Many tasks which otherwise consumed many hours began to be completed in a matter of minutes and one can access the entire world through the internet while sitting at one place.... In contrast, communication media now are unbelievably fast, liberating, rewarding, and facile.... AK: There is no comparison between the way I and other people of my generation used to communicate with family and relatives living abroad in the past and in the present....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

A Justifiable Way of Chief Executive Officers Rewarding

a comparison of the practices in the US and UK reveal certain differences.... ABSTRACT Compensation benefits granted to the chief executive officers (CEOs) have been of great concern to the shareholders and a regular subject of criticism by the press and media.... … CEO Pay – a justifiable way of rewarding CEOs?...
37 Pages (9250 words) Dissertation

Detecting Breast Cancer in Women Under the Age of 50

hellip; This study will compare and contrast these two methods by using the tests on a sample population in the specific age group of women below 50 years of age and recording them in an organized fashion.... his study will compare and contrast these two methods by using the tests on a sample population in the specific age group of women below 50 years of age and recording them in an organised fashion.... Reportedly, the two most popular methods used for screening breast cancer today, are contrast Enhance Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Digital Mammography....
44 Pages (11000 words) Dissertation

How Ovarian Cancer Swipes the Entire Woman Population

It is also of the greatest importance to identify factors of influence, then develop intervention in the form of information dissemination.... Ovarian cancer is an undeniable source of fear among middle-aged women today t could be noted that it is through the development of this particular illness that women today are given the chance to gain educational knowledge about the basic understanding that they need to have to allow themselves of the chances of avoiding the said health situation....
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

E-commerce law in European Union

It is said that lack of certainty resulting in legal action may undermine human rights such as freedom of expression, freedom of information, freedom of thought, freedom of creation, the right to education, as well as the rights to privacy and the protection of personal data.... Between 2006 and 2008, the EU shoppers buying at the minimum one product from the virtual arena increased from 27% to 33% (up to 91% in the Nordic countries)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Pros and Cons of Lawyer Contingent Fees in EU Countries

This proposal for research suggests investigating of pros and cons of lawyer contingent fees in EU countries.... The research will be primarily based on the review of published literature on the topic in various journals in the nations across the EU.... hellip; From a historical perspective, right from the initial stages of the emergence of European Union, private parties have been endowed with the right to institute litigation on competition rules and the member nations have been mandated not to “inhibit” such actions....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Proposal

Social Work and Its Role in Creating a Just Society

n his book, Michael Sandel tries to explain the components of a just society and how such a society can be created.... The paper "Social Work and Its Role in Creating a Just society" describes that I look forward to formulating ways through which I can handle and in some cases mitigate their causes as outlined above.... For example, social workers today play various roles in society such as;Other common roles and responsibilities for social workers include human rights activism, community developers, policy analysts for the general public, and justice systems for both adults and juveniles....
8 Pages (2000 words) Personal Statement
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us