StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Electoral College System - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"The Electoral College System" paper states that the attempt to disassemble the Electoral College system undermines the ability of the country to provide effective leadership to elected officials, which in turn would make the country weaker in the end…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.6% of users find it useful
The Electoral College System
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Electoral College System"

?In a vibrant democracy, there is always the desire to change one’s government for the better such that it represents more of its citizens in a satisfactory way. Within this context, there are those parties in the United States who have this strong desire to change the structure of the federal government as a means of abolishing a long-held tradition of electoral vote. In the electoral vote, each state in the union receives the number of electoral votes equal to the number of its members to Congress, which varies considerably depending on that state’s particular population. States with large populations, like California and Texas, thus receive a greater share of the electoral vote than smaller states, like Rhode Island and Delaware. This system of giving a voice to the smaller states was a system designed by the Founding Fathers at the beginning of America’s history, when only a few states stood in existence (Hardaway 76). Just like many decisions of the federal government today, the Electoral College system was built from a compromise that gave greater strength to the union. The attempt to disassemble the Electoral College system undermines the ability of the country to provide effective leadership to elected officials, which in turn would make the country weaker in the end. Although the United States is commonly described as a democracy, it is in fact not a pure popular democracy like Ancient Greece, in which each citizen was invited to make decisions in the legislature (Diamond 7). Rather, the Constitution of the United States strictly limits power between individual citizens and the federal government. The Electoral College is one such limitation placed on the power of the people, and it must be understood properly within this historical (or Constitutional) context. Namely, while the United States is a democracy, the interests of the people are upheld by the representatives that take on that power. The electoral vote shares this power between the people and the government in a way that incorporates the interests of states, the people, and the federal government. With respect to the states, the Electoral College provides protection to the interests of smaller states, just as the Founding Fathers originally intended. At that time, the critical issue on everyone’s mind could not be avoided—namely, how the small and large states would share power in both the legislative and executive branches” (Hardaway 76). That is because the current system provides for the protection of all states’ rights. Remembering that the United States is a federation of states, and not one single state, each state is deserving of its own individual say in the election of the president to preside over that union. A popular vote undermines the concept of a federal system of states, causing candidates to focus only on the most populous, urban areas of the country. “Elections are as freely and democratically contested as elections can be—but in the states… Democracy thus is not the question regarding the electoral college; federalism is” (Gregg 7). There also appears to be a practical problem with changing the electoral vote system to a system of popular vote, which is its primary competitor. Fears surrounding the Electoral College deal with the possibility that the popular vote does not match the electoral vote. However, this is a nonexistent problem, considering “the fact that the electoral and popular vote winners have been the same in every presidential election conducted in the past 100 years” (Hardaway 11). In fact, because inconsistency between the two methods of measuring vote legitimacy is so rare in history, it seems practically irrelevant to implement the changes need to switch to a popular vote. Changing the electoral system would require an Amendment to the Constitution, which also poses a practical problem for Congressmen. Members of the House and Senate from large states, like California and Texas, will be unlikely to surrender their power over smaller states in return for a system that rarely differs from the one already in place (Durbin). One potential disadvantage the popular vote might raise in the United States, if it replaced the electoral vote, is that of a recount, which is a challenge to political legitimacy (Diamond 7). As elections in recent years have become closer in terms of the margin between the candidates, it is certainly possible that a close election could lead to accusations of voter-fraud and calls for a recount. Not only would this delay the election of a president, but also it could create questions of legitimacy for the president following an election. The Electoral College gives a more objective basis for determining the result of elections. In the election challenge of 2000, in which George W. Bush lost the popular vote but won the electoral vote, Bush triumphed because the electoral system provides that objective benchmark with which we can decide a winner. In the end, the country rallied behind its new leader, not questioning his position as president. Limiting the number of crucial votes to 538 as opposed to 300 million, as the electoral college does, there is much less of a margin of error in determining what a candidate needs to win his election in terms of the votes gained. One criticism frequently leveled at the Electoral College is that it causes candidates to focus only on so-called “swing states”, which vary in terms of their political affiliations in between election cycles (Durbin). For instance, states like Michigan and Florida typically receive higher levels of candidate attention during elections because of the voter diversity. On the other hand, states like Massachusetts and Texas typically vote one way in elections, for Democrats or Republicans respectively. Thus, the criticism is that the Electoral College distorts presidential campaigns: causing them to campaign less in so-called “safe” states and to spend more resources in states that could potentially swing their way and change the results of the election. As a result, politicians are less concerned or less in tune with the problems or concerns of certain geographical areas within the country. Nevertheless, such a criticism ignores the fact that America is a large country with a myriad of different perspectives and people. A system that encourages those candidates who appeal to a broader base of constituents (beyond those contained merely within the “swing states”) is more likely to produce a government that listens to the entire country, as opposed to a select portion of it. The electoral system, unlike the popular vote system like that in place in countries like the United Kingdon where only the interests of London and the surrounding areas are heard in Parliament, encourages participation in government from many different states. That is, it is not merely enough for a presidential candidate to earn support from a few large states, when it is clear that he does not represent the interests of small states as well. “At least a substantially plurality of popular votes countrywide are ultimately elected, and smaller parties representing narrow interests must either compromise or merge with a major party” (Hardaway 16). Additionally, the political affiliations and political diversity of the states is not static. Parts of the country are not “given” in all elections. It is certain that any other system other than the Electoral College would provide no benefit to the legitimacy of elected politicians. In fact, a popular vote system would create far more problems than it solves. Considering that the United States is not a true direct democracy, there is no constitutional or philosophical basis on which one can argue that the Electoral College is unjust. It represents the fact that the United States is not one centralized state like most other countries in which a popular vote is used; rather, it is a decentralized union of states, of which each deserves some say in the election of federal executives. This ensures representation for all, which is one of the bases for the founding of the United States in the first place. As such, it seems that the United States should uphold the Constitutional necessity and political practicality of maintaining its electoral vote system. Bibliography Diamond, Martin. Testimony in Support of the Electoral College. Washington D.C.: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, 1977. Durbin, Richard J. Should the Current Electoral College System be Preserved? January 2001. March 2011 . Gregg, Gary L. "The Origins and Meaning of the Electoral College." Gregg, Gary L. Securing Democracy: Why We Have the Electoral College. 2nd. Washington D.C.: Intercollegiate Studies Institute, 2008. Hardaway, Robert M. The Electoral College and the Constitution: The Case for Preserving Federalism. New York: Praeger Publishers, 1994. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Electoral College Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1412977-electoral-college
(Electoral College Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1412977-electoral-college.
“Electoral College Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1412977-electoral-college.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Electoral College System

Electoral College Reform

This paper explores the reform needs in The Electoral College System used in U.... The Electoral College System has been deemed as requiring reforms despite its being a time-honored system because of its likelihood to conflict with the popular vote.... The United States is perhaps the only modern state in which presidents are elected indirectly through The Electoral College System.... This paper explores the reform needs in The Electoral College System used in U....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Mathematics and the U.S. Presidential Elections

The Electoral College System in voting for the US President presents a more complex form of mathematics than that.... This paper will provide a discussion on how the US Presidential Elections work, including its history and a description of the concepts of the electoral college and popular vote.... In the current electoral process, the electoral college is responsible for electing the next president of the United States of America.... the electoral college is composed of electors from different states of the country....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Democracy within the Electoral College

From the paper "Democracy within the Electoral College" it is clear that there are enough reasons and pieces of evidence to believe that The Electoral College System has not achieved its desired purpose; thus, has to a large extent caused the deterioration of the American democracy.... The objective of the framers in entrenching The Electoral College System within the selection of the president was to have men and women of virtue and outstanding characters to select the president....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Electoral College

This essay discusses that if The Electoral College System is replaced by a simple majority system then the whole election system should be modified – a nationalized body of government officials to be introduced with which the threat of 'major fraud' boosted up following some statistical data about fraud by federal officials.... This research will begin with the definition of the electoral college as a system of indirect voting applied for the presidential elections in the USA....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

What Is the Electoral College

The opposition group regards the abolishment of The Electoral College System as advantageous for the third party which is again disregarded by the supporters as they regard the abolishment of the Electoral College not as beneficial for the third party.... A weakness of The Electoral College System is that the members of the Electoral College appear to favor the Democratic Party and not the Republicans, which is a kind of favoritism and cannot be regarded as fully democratic....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College

This research paper 'Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College' examines the abolition of The Electoral College System of voting.... According to the essay, The Electoral College System of voting has been seen to award victory to candidates who have lost the popular vote, like George W.... Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College The Electoral College System of voting was established in the Constitution of the United States to vote for the President and the Vice President....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the Electoral College

The supporters argue that The Electoral College System grants every region the freewill to design its laws regarding voting.... The Electoral College System does not encourage contenders to agitate for the attendance of electors they only do this in the state that are highly populated (Kimberling and William 1992).... The Electoral College System grants minority regions power, and it is unjust for the bigger regions.... The Electoral College System boosts the minority systems power....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Brilliance of Electoral College

Arguments against The Electoral College System have been and continue to be vocally expressed by its critics as an archaic system in need of reform.... The Electoral College System is a more effective system for electing a president than a popular vote system would be for various reasons.... Primarily The Electoral College System is a system that represents the entire citizens of the United States and not just the ones living in bigger more significant States....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us