StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Sterilization - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet
The reason for these elaborate procedures is that a great deal of concern exists in respect of the acceptance of requests for such sterilizations, due to the current legal position (Opinion on the contraception for the mentally handicapped. Document Number 49, 1996).
Article 16-3 of the Code Civil permits injury to a person's body, only if it is essential for curing some inherent disease. Further, such legal sanction is available only if the individual, who will be affected by such treatment, expresses willingness to undergo such medical procedure (Civil Code of 1804 - Napoleon Code, 2005).
A number of issues have to be addressed, namely, it is evident that it is difficult if not impossible to vindicate a medical course of action whose objective is to bring about contraception; mental retardation constitutes insufficient justification for contraception and it is well nigh impossible to obtain the voluntary and educated willingness of a mentally retarded person. Moreover, the possibility of young, mentally retarded women being subjected to abusive action is a palpable risk (Opinion on the contraception for the mentally handicapped. Document Number 49, 1996).
In order to address these issues several eugenic sterilization laws were enacted in some of the countries. In the year 1907, the state of Indiana enacted such laws for the first time in the United States. The subsequent decade saw the enactment of analogous legislation by fifteen more states. By the year 1936, around twenty - seven states had enacted such legislation (Opinion on the contraception for the mentally handicapped. Document Number 49, 1996).
In the case of Buck v. Bell, the US Supreme Court had to decide about the constitutional validity of a law that had been enacted in 1924, in the State of Virginia. Of the nine justices who heard this case, eight held that sterilization could be enforced by a State for eugenic causes. Further, they held that birth control was not a type of cruel or unusual punishment.
In Buck v. Bell the callousness of the judiciary is clearly depicted. In this case Oliver Wendell Holmes, the presiding judge, had Carrie Buck sterilized for being an imbecile. Later on he wrote stating that this decision afforded him immense pleasure. This eugenic sterilization statute of the State of Virginia violated constitutional rights of individuals. The ramification of this unfortunate decision were that it served as a precedent for similar laws and decisions in thirty other states, which resulted in the sterilization of around fifty thousand people. This case was cited as a justification for their similar evil deeds by the Nazis during the Nuremberg Trials, after World War II. In the German endeavour, named the Rassenhygiene, two million people were sterilized (Buck v. Bell. 274 U.S. 200 (1927), 1999).
However, in some States, these sterilization laws were applied very rarely and quite a few of these laws were repealed. Nevertheless, in the States of Virginia and California, approximately sixty thousand ...Show more


In respect of mentally disabled persons, birth control results in the emergence of several arguments to the fore. These issues depend on the people involved and their physical and mental condition. The situation is so complicated that on several occasions the course adopted has been to curtail debate to arriving at a decision as to whether the sterilization procedure is to be adopted or discarded (Opinion on the contraception for the mentally handicapped…
Author : wildermanbridge
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Current legislation, standards and guidance require microbial monitoring of utilities (eg steam and water), facilities (eg the c
The department must meet exacting standards of cleanliness, organization, and sterility for the utilities involved, the facility and rooms themselves, and for the final product before it is distributed to a patient (NHS Estate Staff 2004). If these standards are not met, the final product may carry great risk to the patient when it is administered, due to the possibility of microbial contamination.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
The Secret History of Forced Sterilization and America's Quest for Racial Purity
His book emphasizes on the eugenic movement and is one of the only books that talk about the eugenics. His claims were against the eugenic movement and he discusses about the thousands of people who were victimized in those early years. Better for All the World is Bruinius’ greatest success through which he retells the policies and the social movement made in the early 20th century, and that laid its impact on several humans.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Mass sterilization of women in Puerto Rico
When Puerto Ricans were granted citizenship of United States of America in 1917, the Congress started to make amendments in the constitution and passed bills that somehow meant to control the lifestyle of Puerto Ricans. In collaboration with health sector and USA’s Government, Puerto Rican government initiated a mass sterilization program.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Discuss how EN ISO 11607 Parts 1 and 2 in conjunction with EN 868 Part2 et seq provide assurance of the maintenance of sterility for a)individually packed supplementary instruments and b) instrument setspacked in reusable sterilization containers
Regardless of the keenness and safety that is observed when manufacturing these instruments, one cannot think of their sterility without thinking of the safety observed when packaging. The development and designing of a packaging system for sterilized medical devices is a complicated issue and a critical endeavor.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Medical law Essay
There is also clear negligence on the part of the medical personal. You have not given any information about the sterilization, its effects, risks and consequences. No consent form for sterilization was given to you. Obstetricians must provide valid information during the last trimester of pregnancy that includes the short and long term complications associated with major medical and surgical procedures performed during the labour - continuous electronic foetal monitoring,restriction of oral nourishment, IVs, labour stimulating/inducing drugs, off-label use of Cytotec/misoprostol, narcotics, epidural anaesthesia, indwelling bladder catheters, episiotomy, vacuum extraction, forceps and a 2
13 pages (3250 words) Essay
Critical Reading Assignment
Better for All the World is Bruinius’ greatest success through which he retells the policies and the social movement made in the early 20th century, and that laid its impact on several
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Vial filling and terminal sterilisation for drug in pharmacology FDA
sterilization process depends on the series of protocols, scientific experiments and demonstrations that show that associated procedures of control are right and can produce a sterile product. The results, conclusion, method and procedure determine whether the process of
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Autoclaves can be of different sizes. Large autoclaving systems obtain steam from steam generators whereas small autoclaves get steam from boiling water. Typical internal autoclave settings are 121 degrees centigrade for 15-20
2 pages (500 words) Essay
The use of Isotopes in medicine
The radiation from the isotopes destroys or weakens the targeted cells in the human body. Other isotopes are significant in the sterilization of the medical equipment and products. It is noteworthy that the utilization of
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Population control through forced sterilization in the past and medication, food in the present
His statement was that if there are no restrictions on these people, it would propagate the reproduction of other human wrecks. Consequently, the Oregon state legalized sexual sterilization to the people
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Let us find you another Essay on topic Sterilization for FREE!
Contact us:
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
Join us:
Contact Us