StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Meat Inspection-Theory and Reality - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Instructor Institution Date Meat Inspection- Theory and Reality The meat packing industry in America involves slaughtering, processing, packaging and distributing livestock products such as beef (Lawrence 5). It is very important to review the history of this industry in America and in deed the whole world because the accounts and stories about the meat packing and inspection industry within the public domain, especially in the 19th century up to the early 20th century are against the marketing theory of free market regulation…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Meat Inspection-Theory and Reality
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Meat Inspection-Theory and Reality"

Meat Inspection- Theory and Reality The meat packing industry in America involves slaughtering, processing, packaging and distributing livestock products such as beef (Lawrence 5). It is very important to review the history of this industry in America and in deed the whole world because the accounts and stories about the meat packing and inspection industry within the public domain, especially in the 19th century up to the early 20th century are against the marketing theory of free market regulation.

It is also significant to understand some of the less discussed issues in the industry such as the monopolistic practices of the big companies in the industry commonly referred to as the ‘Big Four’ (Lawrence 11). Historical accounts about the industry state that the industry was left unregulated before the Federal meat inspection Act was passed in Congress. This led to unsanitary conditions in the industry that made the public vulnerable to diseases. Upton Sinclair, a writer from The Appeal to Reason, in his book The Jungle, created awareness in the public regarding the state of affairs in the meat packing and inspection industry.

The public, becoming aware of the conditions in the meat packing industry, urged President Theodore Roosevelt to pass legislation to allow for inspection of meat in the industry. This upset a majority of the meat packers who fought against the legislation. The disgusting picture of the meat packing industry was confirmed by the Neil- Reynolds Report, which reaffirmed the need to put in place meat inspection regulation as well as regulating the whole meat packing industry, which had failed to control itself internally.

A clear examination of the facts about this industry which are in public domain reveals a number of factual discrepancies and mistakes that these historical accounts make (Lawrence 23). Contrary to historical accounts, the meat packaging industry was not unregulated. By the time Sinclair wrote his book, the industry had been regulated for over ten years. The Meat Inspection Act had been passed in 1891, after allegations about contaminated meat being sold to the public emerged. There is no evidence however to support the claim that the legislation came as a result of tainted meat.

This legislation was mainly passed due to the changing economical conditions in 1891. This was because of the emergence of four big firms in Chicago with the introduction of refrigeration. These firms controlled about 90% of the industry and greatly altered the supply and demand of livestock products (Lawrence 27). There were concerns about prices of cattle falling down, due to the increased demand. This called for regulation to stabilize the industry. Allegations of unsanitary conditions in the meat packing industry revealed in Sinclair’s book are in fact not true.

This book was a fictional novel and even though fictional novels can reveal truths about the society, this one in this case does not. A report by the Bureau of Animal Industry in 1906 refuted Sinclair’s claims about unsanitary conditions. Accusations made by the Neil- Reynolds report also seem not to hold as they did not have experience and knowledge of how the meat packing industry operated at the time. Their main aim of going to inspect the Chicago facilities was to identify faults so as to enable them pass the legislation.

As noted within the public also that the big four firms in the industry were unhappy with the new legislation, it turns out that the firms were indeed supportive of the new piece of legislation. At a meeting with the government before the bill was passed, the big four firms applauded the regulations and termed it as a ‘wise law’ that had to be enforced. Works Cited Lawrence W. Reed. Ideas and Consequences: Of Meat and Myth. The Freeman, Volume 44. Issue 11, 2011.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Meat Inspection-Theory and Reality Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1480909-meat-inspection-theory-and-reality
(Meat Inspection-Theory and Reality Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1480909-meat-inspection-theory-and-reality.
“Meat Inspection-Theory and Reality Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1480909-meat-inspection-theory-and-reality.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Meat Inspection-Theory and Reality

American Perspective

American Perspective paper Introduction American Perspective paper deals with the changes, which occurred in the American nation in the beginning of the twentieth century and in the need of the nineteenth century.... … Name Professor's Name Subject Date American Perspective paper Introduction American Perspective paper deals with the changes, which occurred in the American nation in the beginning of the twentieth century and in the need of the nineteenth century....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Inserting Foley Catheters and Infection risks involved with them

Topic: Inserting Foley Catheters & Infection Risks Involved Student: Course: Date: Professor: Abstract Self actualization is an important aspect of Maslow's need theory which forms a central part of humanistic philosophy.... This theory delineates self actualization which is the driving force behind reaching full potential and tantamount to self fulfillment....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Peripheral Intravenous Therapy

This essay is about changing the management of peripheral intravenous therapy in an intermediate rehabilitation ward.... The essay is focusing on the efforts of a specialist practitioner, who will work with the qualified nurses to 'unfreeze' them from the current position and induce a change in Peripheral Intravenous Therapy management area. … The idea that cannulation is solely the responsibility of the medical staff needs to be changed....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Benefits of Hands-on Training

However, even after decades of research and analysis, questions remain as to the optimal educational processes, particularly as they relate to comprehension and mastery of vocational tasks. For the purposes of this paper, an OH&S inspection tour of a meat-processing plant has been established (more details of this tour can be found in Appendix A).... I made an outline that represented the challenges and requirements, and focused on the key tenets that I wanted trainees to bring away from their time at the meat-processing plant....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Management of Suckwell Vacuum Cleaners Company

The company manufactures and assembles vacuum cleaners for household customers.... The annual production of the company is around 300,000 units which are sold at 40.... 0 each.... Each vacuum cleaner consists of plastic bodies that came from a subcontractor which are loosely packed in large boxes....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Instructional Design of Task Using Cognitive Information Processing Techniques

I made an outline that represented the challenges and requirements and focused on the key tenets that I wanted trainees to bring away from their time at the meat-processing plant.... The main objective of this assignment is to investigate the benefits of hands-on training in regard to the learning process....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Contemporary Nondestructive Testing Procedures

The following paper under the title 'Contemporary Nondestructive Testing Procedures' focuses on nondestructive testing which may be defined as the test methods used to inspect the reliability of material or structure without damaging its future usefulness.... hellip; Nondestructive testing is used to examine the material reliability of the test article....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Lean Manufacture, Just-In-Time Approach, Total Quality Management, and Total Productive Maintenance

"Lean Manufacture, Just-In-Time Approach, Total Quality Management, and Total Productive Maintenance" paper focuses on Just-In-Time that manufacturing has been implemented in Japan.... It is a philosophy that guides a manufacturing company in organizing and managing it's business more effectively....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us