StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

A Critical Analysis of Some Processes in the Cultivation Effect by Robert Hawkins and Suzanne Pingree - Research Paper Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
A Critical Analysis of Some Processes in the Cultivation Effect by Robert Hawkins and Suzanne Pingree

The methodology adopted by the researchers, including detailed description of control variables introduced, is comprehensively explained. Any similarities, as well as the differences, in researchers’ approach with Gerbner and Gross’s method, are pointed out. The qualitative as well as quantitative data is properly explained and the researchers’ justifications for the deviant data values are also analytically evaluated. The findings, which stated that the very young audience is not psychologically mature enough to get ‘cultivated’ by television, and perception of a ‘violent’ world is associated with the amount of crime related dramas and cartoons seen by the children, are adequately explained. Any shortcomings in the researchers’ approach and logic, such as, small research period, and generalized control variables, are discussed. Proper recommendations, for instance, advanced study of preconceived notions in children over a long period of time, are provided. Introduction In 1976, while exploring the continuing effects of extensive television viewing on American audience, George Gerbner and Larry Gross introduced the ‘cultivation theory.’ The primary conclusion of their research was that prolonged exposure to violence related material on the television, results in the formation of a societal reality in the minds of the viewers, which further dictates their thought formation and alters their social behavior (Gerbner and Gross, 1976). To further this hypothesis, Robert Hawkins and Suzanne Pingree, in 1977, conducted a detailed research, to study how exactly cultivation effect takes place, and what variables can enhance or diminish it. In 1980, they documented their findings in a publication titled “Some Processes in the Cultivation Effect,” which is the subject of this paper. This paper will analyze how Hawkins and Pingree, in the light of ‘cultivation hypothesis’, formulated their thesis, conducted research, and interpreted qualitative and quantitative data. Furthermore, this paper will suggest any revisions, deemed necessary, to their adopted research methodology, along with the recommendations that can enhance their findings. Hawkins and Pingree’s research was based on the already established fact that the viewers highly exposed to television programming, both aggressive and non aggressive, would carry a certain amount of prejudice in their social outlook. They were also influenced by the contrasting and contradicting studies conducted by various researchers in other parts of world, controlling numerous variables, such as Doob and McDonald’s study of cultivation effects among various demographics in Toronto, Canada (1979), and Wober’s research in Great Britain (1978). These studies showed that the effect of television on viewer’s perception is certain, however, what is still unknown is the exact ‘size and importance of that effect’ (Pingree and Hawkins, 1980). Generally, it was observed that, when controlling a third variable, there was no strong relation between watching violent programming and fearing that viewer himself would get involved in a similar scenario. One of the reasons could be that people in other parts of the worlds were unconsciously aware that their society was different than that of America, and therefore, were not impacted that much by American programming. Furthermore, not much research had been done involving controls that would illuminate the exact process of cultivation in the children. There had been studies involving age as a variable, and discovering that children in the learning stages are usually more susceptible to the television messaging systems, as compared to very young and an older audience (Drabman et ...Show more

Summary

The methodology adopted by the researchers, including detailed description of control variables introduced,is comprehensively explained.Any similarities,as well as the differences, in researchers’ approach with Gerbner and Gross’s method, are pointed out…
Author : carmen44
A Critical Analysis of Some Processes in the Cultivation Effect by Robert Hawkins and Suzanne Pingree essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the research paper on your topic
"A Critical Analysis of Some Processes in the Cultivation Effect by Robert Hawkins and Suzanne Pingree"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Company critical analysis - DHL
The founders are involved into shipping and discovered that the documents can be shipped by air which can reduce the turnaround time of the company in port and thus discovered the new division DHL Airways which was based at San Francisco and operates along with DHL International of Brussels which is mainly concerned with the operations outside US.
6 pages (1500 words) Research Paper
Critical Analysis: Burn Dressing
He wanted to feel relieved from the painful feeling of being choked, as shown by his actions and comments that tended to pressure ER Nurse-in-charge of accommodating the entry and provision of facilities for the burn patient. A sense of agitation causes the nurse to coordinate with the Doctor on duty to prescribe a pain reliever minutes after the patient has been officially admitted in the ER.
8 pages (2000 words) Research Paper
Critical Analysis Research Paper
However, in the effort to portray the issue, the story goes defective in many places in technical subtitles. The most important one is that Armand - the male figure - is presented as a selfish, foolish, villain who changes his colors every now and then, and the female figures are presented as angels came down to earth who are so virtuous that they fail to understand the problem of race and color that existed in society.
3 pages (750 words) Research Paper
Analysis of Three Selected Poems by Robert Frost
Frost was born to William Prescott Frost Jr and Isabelle Moodie. His father was a teacher by profession and he also worked as a journalist. Robert Frost is regarded highly for his nature and rural depicted poetry and over his command of speech. He spent his life mostly on the move – moving from America to England and then back to America as he could not live a life of monotony and wanted change Robert Frost’s father died in the year 1885 due to tuberculosis.
5 pages (1250 words) Research Paper
A Critical Analysis of Robert Pear's Health Law to Be Revised by Ending a Program
Pear’s article which appeared in print on October 15, 2011, on page A10 of the New York Times (and published online on October 14, 2011 on the New York Times website), informs the public that in October 2011, the Obama administration declared ending the Community Living Assistance Services and Supports (CLASS) Program, a long-term care insurance program produced by the new health law as it was excessively lavish and unworkable.
3 pages (750 words) Research Paper
Critical Analysis of Paper
The studying of the state as has been done is only possible through the assistance of history. Historical studies are essential to understanding political movements, thoughts, along with institutions. History stands as a massive storehouse of information and facts ranging from which the political science obtains data for its overview.
5 pages (1250 words) Research Paper
Critical analysis of research
Hence, play gives the feeling of freedom, fun and fulfillment. The nature of the play has made it an important tool in treating people who are
7 pages (1750 words) Research Paper
Company critical analysis - DHL
covered the new division DHL Airways which was based at San Francisco and operates along with DHL International of Brussels which is mainly concerned with the operations outside US. With time the company grew rapidly operating in over 200 countries with 110,000 employees and
6 pages (1500 words) Research Paper
Content Analysis on Prime Time Television Using Cultivation Theory
Many studies have focused on delving and understanding the effects and the influence it holds over its viewers and, consequently, the society. As is stated in the Cultivation Theory, “The more a person is exposed to a message provided by the media, the more likely that person is to believe the message is real”.
7 pages (1750 words) Research Paper
Discourse Analysis: Critical Analysis paper
They have disciplinary precision. The aspect of precision helps in complying with the subject of concern conveyed in the analyzed texts. The concept also helps in upholding relevance in the reading and discourse analysis. Additionally,
3 pages (750 words) Research Paper
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation