The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle

The Criticisms of Scalon
Journalism & Communication
Pages 4 (1004 words)
Download 0
The Millian Principle Student’s name Course Institution Date The Millian Principle “There are some harms, which even though would not transpire but for some acts of expression, however, cannot be included in the justifications for legal limitations on these acts.


The Millian principle on Liberty simply means that certain harms may have had no probability of occurring if, not for some expressed actions. However, once these harms occur, the perpetrators may not justify their actions by legally restricting the actions. These harms include; those that originate from certain acts of expression, which include deceiving the individuals into having false beliefs and acts of expressions, which lead people into acting in ways that may lead to harmful consequences, especially in situations where there is a correlation between the act of expression and the succeeding harmful consequences. This correlation simply includes a mere fact that the act of expression facilitated the agents’ belief or led them to believe that it would be worthy performing the acts. Scanlon defended this principle by illustrating that it was a consequence of a certain idea regarding limits of justifiable political authority. That the government’s legitimate powers are restricted to people that can be protected on incompatibility grounds, with the citizen’s authority Scanlon (1979, p. 529). However, Scanlon does not fully agree with this principle. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?