StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Brief The Of State V. Stark - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The Case Study "Brief The Case Of State V. Stark" analyzes that during the period from June 30, 1988, to October 3, 1989, the Clallam Health Department’s staff met five times with the defendant, during which the defendant went through broad guidance about his infection. 
 …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
Brief The Case Of State V. Stark
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Brief The Of State V. Stark"

Brief The Case Of State V. StarkHistoryCalvin Stark was convicted within the Superior Court, Clallam County Washington, of two Counts of second-degree dishonor for intentionally disclosing his intimate partner to the HIV (Human Immunodeficiency virus), and he appealed. The Washington Court of Appeals asserted and remitted the case for commutation.FactsOn March 25, 1988 Calvin Edward Stark hereafter “Defendant” was tested to be positive for HIV, which was substantiated by further testing initially on June 25 and then again on June 30, 1988.

During the period from June 30, 1988 to October 3, 1989, the Clallam County Health Department’s staff met five times with the defendant, during which the defendant went through broad guidance about his infection. He was instructed regarding safe sex, the danger of dispersing the infection and the need of letting his partners know about his disease prior to engaging in sexual practice with them. The Clallam County Health Officer, Dr. Locke on October 3, 1989, after discovering that the defendant has neglected his advise and was engaging in unprotected sexual practice, issued a cease and desist order as approved by RCW 70.24.024(3)(b).

But the defendant did not cease and desist and Dr. Locke on March 1, 1990, went to the prosecuting officer’s office aiming to look for the prosecutor’s assistance, consistent to RCW 70.24.034(1), in getting juridical enforcement of the “cease and desist order”. Stark was then charged by the State with three assault counts in the second degree under RCW 9A.36.021 (1) (e). RCW 9A.36.021 (1) (e). At the panel trial, in count one, the victim attested to her sexual relationship with Stark and the panel received deposition testimony of Dr.

Locke concerning the contacts of Health Departments with Stark. In the bench trial, Dr. Locke testified but it was not testified by Stark. In front of the bench trial, the State demonstrated testimony of one of neighborhood friends of Stark. She attested that Stark on one night, after drinking, visited her apartment and let her know about his state of being HIV positive. Upon asking about the need of protecting oneself, Stark denied the need and also asserted his desire of spreading the infection to others.

The jury thus established Stark to be guilty on count one.Stark was then found guilty of the second as well as third counts by second trial judge at a bench trial. Stark was rendered an extraordinary sentence of 120 months on count one, due to the being a danger towards the community in future. While the usual range for such offense was between 13 to 17 months. On the other hand, Stark, on counts two and three, was rendered the lower end of the usual range i.e., 43 months each, to be assisted at the same time but sequentially to count one (Samaha 10).

Part bStark attempted review of the Superior Court’s judgment for Washington’s Clallam County that made him a convict of three counts of second-degree assault and that, later in count one the judgment of guilty, enforced a sentence that surpassed the standard range.Part cCourt’s DecisionThe court asserted defendant's condemnations for three counts of second-degree assault, but remitted the case for commutation on count one.Part dStandard on which Case ReliedStark elicits a number of matters in his pro se brief.

Initially, he argues that the State had been unsuccessful to charge him properly [*438] with assault due to particular statutory prohibitions pre-empt universal ones. More particularly, he contests that RCW 70.24 displaced the more common provisions of RCW 9A.36.021 (1) (e).Secondly, Stark contests that the court strayed in viewing evidence that came from rigid confidence since it was confined by the physician-patient privilege. Dr. Locke, as mentioned above, did not dishonor the privilege as [***24] he appropriately attempted the enforcement of the cease and desist order from the prosecuting officer.

The psychologist-patient privilege is relevant "only 'so far as practicable' in criminal cases." State v. Mark, 23 Wn. App. 392, 396, 597 P.2d 406 (1979). It is statutory, legal, not of constitutional order of magnitude. State v. Boehme, 71 Wn.2d 621, 634, 430 P.2d 527 (1967), cert. denied, 390 U.S. 1013 (1968); RCW 5.60.060(4). Practical application of the privilege necessitates a harmony of the gains of the privilege versus the public concern of full disclosure of the facts. Petersen v. State, 100 Wn.

2d 421, 429, 671 P.2d 230 (1983) (Dickson 20).Lastly, Stark contests that the State consecrated an ex post facto frailty by utilizing confidential information to accuse him with assault. Stark confesses that if the public prosecutor had suitably complied with the statutory guidelines then an ex post facto infirmity would not have been established. Moreover, he contends that the employment of confidential information by the prosecuting officer, in order to assure a conviction made such an infirmity.

Stark seems to be contending that since the Legislature provided him an enthroned right in the privacy of his HIV status, [***25] the [*439] use of information by the prosecutor to accuse him criminally eliminated that right, thus creating [**118] an ex post facto loss. As mentioned above, the prosecutor officer did not surpass his authority in depending on Stark's or else confidential information concerning his HIV status.Work CitedSamaha, J. Criminal law. 9th. Belmont, Ca: Cengage Learning, Inc, 2008. Print.Dickson, D.

 HIV, AIDS, and the law: legal issues for social work practice and policy. Hawthrone, New York: A division of Walter de Gruyter, Inc, 2001. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Brief The Case Of State V. Stark Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1466510-brief-the-case-of-state-v-stark
(Brief The Case Of State V. Stark Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1466510-brief-the-case-of-state-v-stark.
“Brief The Case Of State V. Stark Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1466510-brief-the-case-of-state-v-stark.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Brief The Case Of State V. Stark

Offshoring, Globalization and the World

We will utilize a case analysis and explore two countries which have embraced free trade and economic growth as a haven for outsourcing.... There are also important tax advantages to outsourcing jobs overseas and as we shall see in our case analysis of China below, companies can often expect certain tax benefits when utilizing productive labor in the developing world (Friedman 2005; Bendor-Samuel 2005).... This brief assignment will explore the globalization phenomenon with an eye to outsourcing and the dynamics of the change of the global economic community....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

The California Gold Rush

the case study "The California Gold Rush" points out that As with all major breakthroughs in history and in science, the discovery of gold in California was an accident.... The California gold rush started with a Swiss immigrant who did not seek gold but wanted to start an agricultural venture....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

CASE ANALYSIS heart of atlanta motel v. united states

In the case under consideration, Heart of Atlanta Motel questioned and challenged the constitutionality of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and attempted to justify and assert its policy of discrimination against African Americans.... United s Facts and Briefs This groundbreaking case posed a potent opposition to the Civil Rights Act of 1964....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Supreme Court of the United States

nbsp; The paper presents the case of the company registered in the state of New York, and an object protruding outwards from what looked liked the railcar's door struck him, knocking him down.... the case study "Supreme Court of the United States " states that What was the applicable law in regard to this matter, where the matter in dispute occurred in Pennsylvania, and the railroad company had been registered in New York.... Section 34 of the Federal Judiciary Act provided that; the several state's law shall only be applicable in a common law trial in making the decision, except where it is otherwise required or provided by the United States Constitution, treaties or statutes, United States courts or in applicable cases....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Love Brief case state v stark

Brown and state v.... d 429 (1992)state v.... olding: The ruling of the case was based primarily on the specific dictations by law which holds an individual responsible for his actions, which are intended to do bodily harm to another person, making him guilty of second degree assault.... Despite numerous warnings stark disregards the doctor's orders,… Even then stark's failure to comply resulted in his doctor reporting his actions to the County prosecutor's office where he was then charged with three Case brief: stark v....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Mary Kay Incs Nine Leadership Keys to Success

in 1963 after retiring from the Stanley Home Products.... Even though she launched her new company with just $5,000, her new enterprise would quickly develop into being an international corporation under her capable leadership.... Paul Burn's… aracteristic qualities of entrepreneurs in his ‘model of start-up influences' include self-confidence, internal locus of control, self motivation, and the desire to succeed. Even though Mary Kay had numerous qualities that Burns attributes in his model to owner managers, In Mary Kay, it would seem that there was not an evident breach between the roles of entrepreneur and owner-manager (Underwood 2003)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Berman vs Department of Interior Case

The court kept the briefing schedule for the case pending with the disposition in the United State vs.... POGO controlled the disposition of the case.... POGO does not take part in the disposition of the case.... The following case study "Berman vs Department of Interior case" is focused on the judgment on Merit Systems Protection Board for Berben vs....
13 Pages (3250 words) Case Study

Case Vignette: Candice

"Case Vignette: Candice" paper analyses the case of Candice who has a difficulty in quitting smoking due to various factors that are ongoing in her life.... This is the case with Candice she had to be literally dragged to seek health care.... the case is unique since the patient had very minimal communication with the family due to her transgender situation mainly and other things which I will seek to establish.... or an effective treatment plan, I will have to identify the key symptoms being manifested in Candice's case....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us