StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Article Critique: How Reliable Are Forensic Evaluations of Legal Sanity - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
[Professor Name] [Course Number] [Professor Name] [Date] How Reliable are Forensic Evaluations of Legal Sanity? The article talks about the reliability of the forensic evaluations of legal sanity. It analyzes that different forensic evaluators have different views for each defendant’s legal sanity; this shows that there is no agreed point…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Article Critique: How Reliable Are Forensic Evaluations of Legal Sanity
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Article Critique: How Reliable Are Forensic Evaluations of Legal Sanity"

Download file to see previous pages

There were many disagreements made. Most often the disagreements were made when the defendant was under drugs or alcohol at the time he committed the offence. However, evaluators were found agreeing where it was found out that the defendant had been in a psychiatric hospital or under a psychiatrist’s treatment before he committed the offence. The judges in the court follow what the majority of evaluators say (Boccaccini 100). This study examines the need for training and practise in the field as evaluators commonly disagree to opinions.

This means that there is something wrong in the evaluation method or theory which has to be corrected. The courts fully depend on the forensic evaluators so the law department must ensure that the methods used are appropriate. If this continues, the sanity defence can be easily used and any criminal may be freed on this basis. This is what the lay persons feel and they claim that forensic evaluators cannot judge the defendant’s state of mind when he committed the crime. This is also because the evaluation usually takes place after a long time of the conviction.

However, many also believe that the public view about the sanity defence is exaggerated because statistics show that the defence is rarely used in court cases and when it is used, it is rarely successful. The public assumes that it is used commonly and can cause many wrong decisions in cases. The literature in this article focuses on the research done to find the value of these forensic evaluations. These evaluations are complex and they are important in court cases. Many of the courts simply believe in what the forensic evaluations say and proceed with those beliefs.

But they don’t know how much of it is true as there are conflicting views. Every forensic evaluator has a different way to evaluate and thus different opinions are given. So how to ensure that the evaluations made are reliable and accurate (Boccaccini 100). This research is important as it presents studies through which the reliability of the forensic evaluations can be examined. The research includes many views, theories, methods and practices which are applied to the forensic evaluations to ensure their reliability.

It is an important aspect to consider as court cases depend on the forensics reports, and if they are unreliable, it can lead to many different outcomes of the case which may negatively impact our future society. The study context is based on samples taken in Hawaii because it is the place where courts require more than one evaluation to see what the majority says. This is why problems arise and so many disagreements are seen. The sampling method is chosen for this study where cases are taken and evaluations are made and then divided into three separate sanity evaluations for one defendant.

36 forensic evaluators were taken and they produced 483 reports which were included in the sample. The study also shows how the courts have reacted on issues where the disagreements were presented. However, in majority of cases the majority evaluations were considered but in certain cases where disagreements were present, the cases usually considered insanity over sanity of the defendant (Boccaccini 103). The limitation to the study is the lack of research done. The sample taken is the 384 cases decided in Hawaii which consecutively raised the defence of insanity.

These cases were taken as samples and the courts showed that 92% of

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Article Critique: How Reliable Are Forensic Evaluations of Legal Essay”, n.d.)
Article Critique: How Reliable Are Forensic Evaluations of Legal Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1486312-article-critique-how-reliable-are-forensic
(Article Critique: How Reliable Are Forensic Evaluations of Legal Essay)
Article Critique: How Reliable Are Forensic Evaluations of Legal Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1486312-article-critique-how-reliable-are-forensic.
“Article Critique: How Reliable Are Forensic Evaluations of Legal Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1486312-article-critique-how-reliable-are-forensic.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Article Critique: How Reliable Are Forensic Evaluations of Legal Sanity

Collage Success of Students from Three High School Settings

Sutton and Galloway explores deep into the national problems regarding the outcomes of the root level educational sector in order to establish the inevitable significance of their study.... With a holistic view of the student-teacher performance and their success rate, and the… With a view to dealing with the question “to what extent are the shortcomings of our nation's schools affecting our nation's p....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Social Exclusions Physiological Effects

Social psychologists Zhong and Leonardelli discovered in two experiments a physiological effect of social exclusion, which was previously thought to be tied only to mental states.... This evidence shows a link between anxious emotional states and perceptions of the environment.... hellip; In two experiments, Zhong and Leonardelli (2008) discovered that participants depicted social exclusion with cold-related concepts not only in a Running head: REVIEW OF EVIDENCE IN EXCLUSION Social Exclusion's Physiological Effects: A Review of the Recent Evidence Affiliation AbstractSocial psychologists Zhong and Leonardelli discovered in two experiments a physiological effect of social exclusion, which was previously thought to be tied only to mental states....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Computer forenscis

The various Linux distributions are used for basic operations at home or professional services, for example; in forensic labs (Dixon).... The various Linux distributions are used for basic operations at home or professional services, for example; in forensic labs (Dixon).... Linux has distinct advantages in a forensic lab setting; they are; availability and accessibility; the software is readily available on the internet.... n a forensic lab setting, both Linux and Windows have advantages and disadvantages....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Overview of digital forensics at NIST

Due to the increased computer related crimes, it is a fundamental requirement for any organization to employ these digital forensic skills to establish and solve their security issues.... Use of these forensic techniques provides an additional assistance to the organization since it helps in troubleshooting, identification and repair of operational issues within a system, reviewing of the operating systems (Barnett, par.... forensic Focus Journal....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Virtual Machine Forensics and Network Forensics

etwork forensics involves: 1) Identifying and responding to attacks against computer systems 2) The utilisation of security devices in gathering evidence data 3) utilising the networks for passive information collection during an investigation VM examintion Typical digital forensic investigation is divided into four main stages namely; access, acquire, analyze and report.... Then makes copies of all data from the running system and generate the forensic image of all storage media a process known as acquisition....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Mobile Phone Forensics

(Fadia 2006) In conclusion, forensics should update their tools to provide legal examiners solutions to the new and current technological advancements.... According to the paper, mobile phones are essential devices that assist in making day to day communication.... In the world today, more than 80% of individuals own mobile phones from various manufacturing companies....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

The Psychology of Confession Evidence

By doing this, Kassin and McNall were able to see how the police interrogators pulled answers out of their suspects, victims, and witnesses, and how reliable those answers were.... As such, the evidence that is pulled from the confessions may pose a danger to the overall well-being of the individuals being interrogated because the confessions are often not reliable.... Kassin's study, which was detailed in his article “The Psychology of Confession Evidence,” is centered on confession evidence in a courtroom setting and how unreliable it tends to be....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Firefighting Tactics and Forensic Awareness

DeHann (forensic scientist) and David J.... … The main operating standard procedure for responding to fire outbreaks has been to force entry, pull lines and to set up PPV fan to aid interior operations.... This method was useful in the past but due to advanced technology, new methods have been The main operating standard procedure for responding to fire outbreaks has been to force entry, pull lines and to set up PPV fan to aid interior operations....
7 Pages (1750 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us