StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Northwest Ecosystem Alliance v. Washington Forest practices board - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
During 1998, several environmentalist groups comprising of the "Northwest Ecosystem Alliance and Pilchuck Audubon Society", filed a suit under the APA seeking compliances of mandatory forest practices by Washington State Forest Practical Board. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
Northwest Ecosystem Alliance v. Washington Forest practices board
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Northwest Ecosystem Alliance v. Washington Forest practices board"

Administrative Court Case: Administrative procedures must be exhausted before Appeals to Court. Case taken up: Northwest Ecosystem Alliance v. Washington Forest Practices Board, 149 Wn.2d 67, 66 P.3d, 2003 WL 1848694. Issues: During 1998, several environmentalist groups comprising of the "Northwest Ecosystem Alliance, The Mountaineers, Alpine Lakes Protection Society, Kettle Range Conservation Group, Whidbey Environmental Action Network, and Pilchuck Audubon Society", filed a suit under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) with the Thurston County Superior Court seeking compliances of mandatory forest practices by Washington State Forest Practical Board.

(NWEA v Washington State Forest Practices Board: Clients). The plaintiffs argued that enforcement of the various forest practices, envisaging the due process of conservation and preservation of marine life, aqua resources, wild life, etc., were severely compromised by the Washington State Forest Practices Board, which was responsible for maintenance and enforcing of valid forest practices. Although the Board had enforced certain water related legislatures, it had failed to address to the larger needs of enforcement of forest practices and rules, thus leading to a severe erosion of its credibility, and grossly undermined its performance as a premier forest conservation authority.

Rules: The Board and others argued that the plaintiffs did not have the authority to approach a court without first using up all the other available administrative procedures and avenues available under law. Under the Rules, it was first necessary for the plaintiffs to initiate an appeal for rule-making procedure seeking the Board's intervention for changing its rules. The complainants had not adhered to this rule. Hence the Court should not consider this complaint. During May 1999, the Thurston Court dismissed the case citing that the due process of petition for rule making had not been followed in this case.

The plaintiffs however, appealed this verdict in the Washington State Courts of Appeal. Application: The Washington State Appeal Court upturned the decision of the country court, stating that the petition for rule making procedure was "a permissive not a mandatory process." (NWEA v Washington State Forest Practices Board: Background). Thus according to the decision of Appeal Court in April 2002, the lower Court judge had committed a mistake in his pronouncement, by delivering the wrong judgment, and had also made mistakes in other elements of the case.

This time round, the defendants, Washington State Forest Practices Board appealed against the decision of the Appeals Court in the Washington State Supreme Court. Conclusions: The decision of the Supreme Court in this case makes interesting reading. It upheld the validity of both plaintiffs and defendants, but in parts. While the Court ruled that the plaintiffs need to follow the petition for rule making procedure before seeking a decision, it was also decided by the Courts, that no decision could be forthcoming, while such rules were being subjected to necessary changes.

The Courts did not detail in its verdict regarding the process and procedure of rule- making nor did it delineate when the procedure would end and the appeal matter taken up. In other words, it could be inferred that the defendants, (aided by favorable courts ) had taken consolation and refuge behind the procedure of rule making, to renege on its duties and responsibilities to address the genuine concerns of environmentalists and their genuine grievances that are of major significance for ecological preservation and conservation.

However, the rule of exhausting all available administrative remedies is not always validated. It is seen that in the case of Keokuk County, Iowa v. H.B. (1999), the issue of administrative and monetary care of mentally disabled people in Iowa was considered. However, "the district court overruled the motion for summary judgment and found in the written ruling following the trial that there were no administrative remedies available for the county to exhaust." (In the Supreme Court of IOWA: Exhaustion of Remedies).

Thus, it would be injudicious to refer cases for administrative review. The significant aspects would be with regard to whether the case merits administrative review or petitioning before being heard by a Court of law, and need not be used indiscriminately in order to avoid court intervention in genuine grievances and appeals involving public bodies and their functioning. Works Cited In the Supreme Court of IOWA: Exhaustion of Remedies. www.judicial.state.ia.us. 1999. 24 Nov. 2008. .

NWEA v Washington State Forest Practices Board: Clients. Washington Forest Law Center: Protecting the Environment by Providing Legal Services for Forest Cases of Statewide Significance. 24 Nov. 2008. . NWEA v Washington State Forest Practices Board: Background. Washington Forest Law Center: Protecting the Environment by Providing Legal Services for Forest Cases of Statewide Significance. 24 Nov. 2008. .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Northwest Ecosystem Alliance v. Washington Forest practices board Essay”, n.d.)
Northwest Ecosystem Alliance v. Washington Forest practices board Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1532899-northwest-ecosystem-alliance-v-washington-forest-practices-board
(Northwest Ecosystem Alliance V. Washington Forest Practices Board Essay)
Northwest Ecosystem Alliance V. Washington Forest Practices Board Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1532899-northwest-ecosystem-alliance-v-washington-forest-practices-board.
“Northwest Ecosystem Alliance V. Washington Forest Practices Board Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1532899-northwest-ecosystem-alliance-v-washington-forest-practices-board.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Northwest Ecosystem Alliance v. Washington Forest practices board

Ecosystem Succession

Succession from bare moraine to mature coniferous forest has been shown in areas left bare by the retreating ice in Glacier Bay, South East Alaska.... Current estimates have shown that it takes 250 years for mature forest to develop from bare moraine.... The Spruce eventually displaces the Alder, and it leads to a mature Sitka Spruce-Hemlock forest.... In another 1250 years, the mature forest changes to Sphagnum-dominated muskeg bog in suitable sites....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Ecosystem: Temperate Forests

The physical characteristics that define the temperate forest include the types of trees and other plants that are prevalent, the particular climate in which it is located, average and type of rainfall per year and the types of animals that make these forests home.... Temperate… These include species such as oak, hickory, maple, beech, hemlock, basswood, cottonwood, elm, willow, poplar and sycamore in addition to developing a diversified The animals that live in this type of forest generally include squirrels, rabbits, skunks, birds, deer, mountain lion, bobcat, timber wolf, fox, bears, foxes and other wildcats although most of the larger predators have been killed off or displaced by the human population....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

How Liajiaxia Hydropower Plant Disturbs Kanbula Forest Ecosystem

The paper "How Liajiaxia Hydropower Plant Disturbs Kanbula forest Ecosystem" highlights that the consequence of the construction of Liujiaxia Hydropower Plant has created a disorder in the food web of Kanbula Hydropower Plant, which has resulted in the loss of predators.... hellip; The major impact of the construction of Liujiaxia Hydropower Plant has been on the biodiversity and reservoir zone environment of the Kanbula forest.... Part of the dam has destroyed the natural habitat of the fauna of the forest and has caused the terrestrial and land plants to live in extremely stringent condition....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Human Society's Impact on Ecosystems

The country of Brazil, on the other hand, loses the biggest area of forest annually, while the Congolese consume more bush meat than any other humid country all due to human activity.... ?World deforestation rates and forest cover statistics 2000-2005.... washington, DC: Ecological Society of America.... The reporter underlines that human society forms part and parcel of the earth's ecosystem.... hellip; According to the Ecological Society of America, an ecosystem is a community of animals and plants interacting with one another and their physical environment....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

State of Washington

The forests in Washington include capitol state forest, Tiger mountain state forest and the Yacolt Burn forest.... The Washington's national forest foundation has put regulation measures against the abuse of forest through human activities.... Also, this body has emphasized on the need for forest development through establishment of man-made forests.... The cumulative impact of these activities is that washington has experienced great economic development in the recent past....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Threats to Forest Ecosystems

This has been primarily due to reversion of marginal farmland in the east, increased plantation in the south and control over forest fires.... With the increase in the population, there has been a significant loss of the original forest and the current situation shows that the century-old forest covers only 7% of the forest area.... n the east, the forest covers about 384 million acres area and includes broadleaf and coniferous forests....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Acid Deposition on Forest

The paper "Acid Deposition on forest" discusses that the contribution towards acid rain has reduced considerably in developed nations, than in developing nations.... nbsp; North-East Asian nations are developing at a tremendous pace that the care towards the environment takes the back seat....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Mediterranean Climate Ecosystem and Southwest Australia as Biodiversity Hotspot

The author of the current paper "Mediterranean Climate ecosystem and Southwest Australia as Biodiversity Hotspot" will provide a description of Hakea plant species and discuss in detail the evolutionary history and phylogeny of the species.... The literature review will discuss the characteristics of the Mediterranean-climate ecosystem and Southwest Australia as a biodiversity hotspot.... nbsp;Mediterranean Climate ecosystem and Southwest Australia as Biodiversity HotspotMediterranean climate ecosystems are characterized by wet and cool winters, dry and hot summers as well as vegetation such as woody shrubs, evergreen, and sclerophyllous shrubs (Syphard et al....
22 Pages (5500 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us