StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

What are the advantages and disadvantages of the current jury system in the UK - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The first advantage is that it provides persons accused of various offenses with the opportunity to get a fair trial, especially when the offenses are deemed more serious. This increases the accused person’s…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
What are the advantages and disadvantages of the current jury system in the UK
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "What are the advantages and disadvantages of the current jury system in the UK"

The Advantages and Disadvantages of the Current Jury System in the UK The UK jury system has its share of advantages and disadvantages. The first advantage is that it provides persons accused of various offenses with the opportunity to get a fair trial, especially when the offenses are deemed more serious. This increases the accused person’s chances of getting fairer sentences. The jury acts as a revelatory of the public’s feeling. Generally, the public has confidence in the jury system because it values public participation.

For example, in R v Ponting for example, D, working as a civil servant, saw documents indicating that the Government (of MT) had lied concerning the sinking of the ship called "General Belgrano" which happened during the Falklands War. D submitted copies of these documents to an MP from the opposition camp so that the issue could be raised in parliament. D was charged in accordance with the Official Secrets Act. Despite the clear knowledge that D’s actions amounted to an offense, he was acquitted by the jury1.

The case above presents convincing evidence that the jury system acts as a counter balance to politically motivated and other improper prosecutions. Although they do not reveal their reasons for acquitting or convicting, juries provide certainty of their actions and this increases public confidence. Juries can also act on their conscience in addition to relying on evidence. This has the advantage of delivering justice even where confident witnesses present biased evidence. Despite these advantages, the jury system as applied in the UK has several disadvantages.

First, the jury system increases the costs incurred by courts. The group of jurors handling the case must be paid as well as the pool of jurors from which the jury has been selected. In addition, other court personnel are employed for the purposes of ministering to the jury during all stages of the case. Furthermore, the making of a verdict by one judge alone costs about £1,000 per day while a jury’s verdict costs about £7,400 per day, which is significantly more expensive.There is evidence of perverse verdicts in the UK jury system.

This is where juries make decisions that are outright against the law. One case in point in relation to this is R v Owen. In this case, it was established that D fired a sawn off a gun at T because T had killed his son through careless driving. T had been sentenced to serve a term of 12 months. D felt this was not enough, the reason for his action. D was tried for intentional malicious wounding and attempted murder. However, he was acquitted by Maidstone Crown Court’s jury2. It is without bias to state that for a number of reasons, the UK jury system lacks the competence to conduct its role.

One of the reasons for this situation is that the average intelligence of the UK juries has declined, and they are now less likely to understand financial matters. Because of this, they are not likely to appreciate evidences presented in fraud cases3. The lack of scientific knowledge also limits their understanding of scientific evidence. Incompetence in the UK jury system also comes about due to the juries’ misconceptions of classes or types of witnesses. As study on the UK jury system indicates that jurors tend to believe in confident witnesses compared to those who are less confident4.

There is also a tendency to rely on the opinion of experts without a question. It is possible to tamper with the current UK jury system, and this disadvantage is linked to the fact that juries are not required to mention the reasoning behind their acquittals or convictions. This is a great cause for concern considering that it increases the risk of rendering erroneous verdicts due to the nullification or lack of ability to apply the law to the given facts, or understand the complex factors surrounding a case.

The jury also has the ability to bend or manipulate the law/ without breaking it.Juries can display bias which makes it hard for them to appreciate the value of large sum. Sutcliffe v Pressdram Ltd exemplifies this. In the case, a private called Private Eye libelled C, the wife of the Yorkshire Ripper, in one of its articles stating that she has known the activities of her husband. The jury awarded her £600,000 for damages. This was excessive and a new trial settled for £60,0005. UK juries record a higher acquittal rate compared to normal courts and this gives the picture that the UK jury system can be manipulated by powerful/influential defendants against less powerful/influential/unfavoured victims.

Yet another issue that is evident in the system is that there is underrepresentation of some ethnic groups in the jury which predisposes some people to unfair judgments. In Smith, R v [2003] CA, D a black man was convicted foe causing serious bodily harm on T. The trial for the violent incident was conducted by an all-white jury. The victim and all witnesses were also white. D appealed on the grounds that a multi-racial jury was required for a fair trial in such a case. However, his appeal was dismissed and he was declared guilty6.

ReferencesLaw Reform Commission of Canada, The Jury in Criminal Trials (Working Paper, 27, 1980), at p.6. See also The Law Society (U.K.), “Another Chance for the Jury?: Evidence to the Roskill Committee on Fraud Trials” (1984) The Law Society’s Gazette 3574.L Re. “Eyewitness Identification: Why So Many Mistakes?” (1984) 58 Australian Law Journal 509, at p.516.R v. Ponting [1985] Crim LR 318, Crown CtSutcliffe v. Pressdram Ltd [1990] 1 All E.R. 269 (C.A.Owen, R v (1992) Maidstone Crown CourtSmith, R v [2003] EWCA Crim 927; (2003) All ER (D) 28 (Apr), CA.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“What are the advantages and disadvantages of the current jury system Essay”, n.d.)
What are the advantages and disadvantages of the current jury system Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1590741-what-are-the-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-the-current-jury-system-in-the-uk
(What Are the Advantages and Disadvantages of the Current Jury System Essay)
What Are the Advantages and Disadvantages of the Current Jury System Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1590741-what-are-the-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-the-current-jury-system-in-the-uk.
“What Are the Advantages and Disadvantages of the Current Jury System Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1590741-what-are-the-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-the-current-jury-system-in-the-uk.
  • Cited: 4 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What are the advantages and disadvantages of the current jury system in the UK

Advantages And Disadvantages Of The System Of Trial By Jury

The researcher of the essay "Advantages And Disadvantages Of The System Of Trial By Jury" analyzes the jury system in the uk.... … The jury system in the uk is a unique feature: as it combines the common sense of a non-legal person with the procedure of the law to ensure that justice is served.... the advantages of jury trial are numerous.... the advantages of jury trial are numerous.... It is a feature of the English legal system that has existed for hundreds of years but has gradually evolved over time to become an integral part of the legal procedure....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Timely Traffic Information

Title: advantages and disadvantages of Various Methods for Providing Near Real Time Traffic Information Purpose of Research: With increasing pressure of traffic in the present times, need for accurate and timely traffic information is highly essential for the general public as well as for working people and groups.... The present research discusses on the various methods that companies use for near real time traffic information and the advantages and disadvantages that are associated with these methods....
8 Pages (2000 words) Dissertation

Types of Voting Systems

This has happened in the past also, for example, Winston Churchill was very popular at the time of elections in 1945 in the uk but Conservative Party was not as popular as the result of which Churchill lost the elections.... This system has been inherited from British and today it is commonly used in United States, uk and some other countries as well.... The paper "Voting Systems" tells us about three kinds of voting system: plurality/majority system, proportional representation system, and semi proportional system....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Voting Systems in the United Kingdom

This essay describes types of the voting system there are generally three: plurality/majority system, proportional representation system, and semi-proportional system.... All these three division of voting system somehow relate to each other and more likely to bring the same political results.... hellip; So, we can say that the major difference in the voting system occurs among the three voting systems, and not within them....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Strength and Weaknesses of 3 Government Schemes

However, there are many who do not meet the recommended level of physical exercise, according to the BHF (British Heart Foundation) 45% of men in Scotland reported meeting… Governments try to solve some public problems by schemes and this essay will mention the advantages and the disadvantages of three physical activities schemes.... Two schemes The first scheme is from the uk which is creating an active Wales....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

European Business - Impact of International Trade to an Open Economy

The assignment "European Business - Impact of International Trade to an Open Economy" explores the uk balance of payment, effect of EU membership on the uk's trade relations, economic rationale of EU with respect to exchange rate stability, the EU major institutions' competencies, etc.... the uk has faced a consistent deficit in the current account, which implies that amount of the goods and services imported is more than the export volume.... Factors that can be held responsible for the current account deficit are noted below: Deficit in goods – Due to de-industrialisation, the uk has had a very large deficit of goods....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Market Risk Analysis on Solar Thermal vs. Solar Photovoltaic System in UK

Solar Photovoltaic System in the UK, will identify and examine the advantages and disadvantages of investing in solar PV and solar thermal system.... hellip; As the paper outlines, solar photovoltaic (PV) and solar thermal is another form of renewable energy resources that will enable the uk government to generate electricity using the sunlight that falls upon the silicon layer of a solar system.... To combat the global climate changes, the uk government decided to gradually shift from the use of non-renewable to renewable energy resources....
18 Pages (4500 words) Research Paper

Advantages and Disadvantages of the System of Trial by Jury

This essay "Advantages and Disadvantages of the System of Trial by Jury" focuses on the jury system in the uk that combines the common sense of a non-legal person with the procedure of the law to ensure that justice is served.... Lay participation strengthens legitimacy and makes the system more democratic and in line with the current social sensibilities.... The trial by jury is a feature of the English legal system.... The rationale behind the inclusion of juries in the legal system is to encourage lay participation....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us