StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Controversy Analysis and Rhetorical Analysis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The writer of the essay "Controversy Analysis and Rhetorical Analysis" suggests that legalization of the use of marijuana will not in any way lead to a decrease in the number of marijuana users. Neither will prohibition. In the Christian and Muslim faiths, drug use or abuse is highly discouraged…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.2% of users find it useful
Controversy Analysis and Rhetorical Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Controversy Analysis and Rhetorical Analysis"

25 September Controversy Analysis and Rhetorical Analysis A poll conducted in the recent past shows the desire of a great number of people for marijuana, popularly known as pot, to be legalized for recreational purposes too. Assuming marijuana was to be legalized as a recreational drug, why should it? Why shouldn’t it? According to a poll conducted by the Behavior research Center in 2010, “a staggering 51 percent of Arizonans said, “Yes” to the legalization of pot while only 49 percent were opposed to this thus approving the Proposition 203” (Gerber, 96). Gerber uses Inartistic proof to prove his point on the desire of the people by giving research-based evidence. Pot has been legalized in Arizona but under certain regulations. According to Donovan, “The Arizona Department of Health was then tasked with the regulation of sales and the use of marijuana solely for medicinal purposes” (Donovan, 107). Donovan uses alliteration as is shown by the repetition of consonants sounds /t/ to bring about flow in the sentence. The discussion only gets as interesting as it is controversial. Mr Scott a board member of Students for Sensible Drug policy faced felony charges for possessing marijuana for his personal use. According to him, “the incident made me realize that every year; hundreds of thousands of people were arrested in connection to marijuana as well as other drugs. It is wrong as these people had not committed any violent crimes nor were they selling drugs,” (Moriah, n.p.). Moriah makes use of the point of view by using 1st person to express Mr. Scott’s standpoint. So, who quantifies or qualifies legalization or prohibition? The controversy is pretentious and shows a society that is not yet ready for change. Thus, Geber states that, “While the pioneers of these movements, though passionate for changes in what seemed like a redundant and hypocritical society, worked hard to bring about radical changes in cultures and religions the world over, proponents of the legalization feel that they are indeed the messiah to the Arizona population” (Gerber, 107). In this statement, figurative language is used as it combines both assonance and alliteration to express the thoughts of theses first campaigners of legalization of Marijuana. Some people are of a different opinion. “For what seems to be strong political reasons, this will indeed not seem like a smart decision as it will pass for reckless policy bred out of ignorance and the indifference to the detrimental and profound effects it has on the youth and the general public safety” (107-9). Gerber uses hasty generalization as the statement is too quick a judgment. The statement is based on a generalized people’s point of view and not on a reality. Also, Mr. Ryan, a retired police officer in Denver, as well as a member of the Law Enforcement against Prohibition, argues that “in my 36 years of law enforcement, I have never had a problem with marijuana users” (Moriah). Moriah utilizes the point of view strategy whereby the statement is written in first person to express Mr. Ryan’s viewpoint. So how is Marijuana used? The drug is, usually, smoked. “A study conducted in the United States found people that smoke marijuana to have more health problems as well as missing more days at work due to the respiratory illnesses compared to their non-using counterparts. It has however not been established whether marijuana smoking can be attributed to the risk of lung cancer” (Baer, 126). Baer uses inartistic proof to give evidence based on research and facts. A number of studies have also linked chronic marijuana use with mental illness. According to these studies, “marijuana in high doses can cause a temporary psychotic reaction that may comprise of paranoia and hallucinations. In other users, the use of marijuana may lead to the worsening of courses of illnesses in patients that have schizophrenia” (Donovan, 169). Donovan also makes use of inartistic proof to give evidence on the effects of marijuana use and dispense any myths. Relationship between marijuana, as well as other mental health problems namely anxiety, depression and suicidal thoughts in adolescents, have been established. Baer explains that “during pregnancy, marijuana is related with the risk of the neurobehavioral problems in the babies. Courtesy of THC and other compounds that are used in marijuana mimicking the mother’s endocannabinoid chemicals, medics say that the use of marijuana among pregnant women may alters the developing endocannabinoid systems in the brains of the fetus. The problems in the children will include attention problems, problem-solving issues and the memory coordination” (Baer, 135-137). It is another case where Baer has used inartistic proof to explain his argument based on evidence. The medical fraternity is tasked with educating the society on the addiction process. It is said that, “The use of marijuana for recreational purposes should not be viewed as a moral failing or as an easily abandoned act of self-indulgence” (178). Here, Baer, uses assonance with the repetition of the sound /a/. While most legalization proponents claim that they would only legalize the drugs for the adult population only, maintaining this quota will only present an elusive and ill-conceived dream. Reason being youngsters will access the drug. “These youngsters may or may not be oblivious to the long-term effects of the drug use. In the case study of the Netherlands which had established coffee shops that customers had the option of selecting marijuana as they did ice-cream flavors, the rate of adolescents using the marijuana almost tripled” (180). Again, Baer makes use of inartistic proof to prove his point on abuse of the drug by youngsters. The recent activities in Sweden show how a well-planned restrictive policy can be effective. Restriction also seems not to be the ultimate solution to any problem, as shown in the 20th century when alcohol seemed to be an economic problem. “This is what is popularly known as the Prohibition Era. The counter effects are that instead of most people completely giving up the bottle; most continued to binge drink while others who did not even take it before took to the activity. Worse still, there emerged cartels headed by the likes of Al Capone who now operated a black economy that sold alcohol to people at exorbitant prices” (Gitlin, 24). Gitlin uses hyperbole to denote the price of alcohol. However, the questions of why it should and should not be are bound to get varied answers depending on whom or what party is answering these questions. In an interview with a member of Legalization Group in University of Arizona; he said that, “marijuana should be legalized because the drug war has led to the loss of life of many people like me.” (Legalization Group). The interviewee uses symbolism to express what type of people, people like him. Legalization to the use of marijuana will not in any way lead to a decrease in the number of marijuana users. Neither will prohibition. In the Christian and Muslim faiths, drug use or abuse is highly discouraged. “According to these faiths, and society in general, the ripple effect of the legalization will fall to morality problems as well as other deep reaching problems a factor that only leads to the debate growing more and more interesting (Gitlin 36-45). Gitlin has used foreshadowing to make the reader think of future implications of marijuana legalization. Works cited Baer, Hans A, Merrill Singer, and Ida Susser . Medical Anthropology and the World System. New York: Greenwood Publishing Group, 2003. Print. Legalization Group. Personal interview. 23 September 2014. Donovan, Todd, Daniel Smith,Tracy Osborn and Christopher Mooney. 4th ed. State and Politics. Chicago: Cengage Learning, 2014. Print. Gerber, Joseph R. Legalizing marijuana: drug policy reform and Prohibition politics. New York: Greenwood Publishing Group, 2004. Print. Gitlin, Martin. The Prohibition Era. Kansas: Juvenile Nonfiction, 2011. Print. Moriah Costa. Could Arizona legalize marijuana? Two groups want issue on ballot. 7 March, 2014. Web. 18 September 2014. National Institute on Drug Abuse: The science of Drug Abuse and Addiction. NIDA, n.d. Web. 18 September 2014. Sanchez, Yvonne and Mary Reinhart. Judge to Brewer: Follow voters’ will, proceed on pot dispensaries. The Republic, 19 January, 2012. Web. 18 September 2014. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Controversy Analysis and Rhetorical Analysis Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1658348-controversy-analysis-and-rhetorical-analysis
(Controversy Analysis and Rhetorical Analysis Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1658348-controversy-analysis-and-rhetorical-analysis.
“Controversy Analysis and Rhetorical Analysis Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1658348-controversy-analysis-and-rhetorical-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Controversy Analysis and Rhetorical Analysis

Communication: Rhetoric and Reasoning

Handbook of rhetorical analysis: Studies in Style and Invention: Designed to Accompany the Author's.... Discourse analysis of President Bush's Speech at Tsinghua University, China.... It can be said that the purpose of the writer has been to provide the emotional interaction between the writer and the audience by making extensive usage of the thesis, logos, pathos, ethos, inversion and controversy (Cockcroft & Cockcroft, 2005, p 72)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Influence of National Center for Science Education on its Audience

The objective of this paper is to conduct a rhetorical analysis of the National Centre for Science Education website in order to define the way in which the creation and or evolution has an influence on the target audience through explanations of their various parts.... The NCSE has been able to identify with the teaching fraternity all over the world since it was started over three decades ago, by ensuring that there is a production of a series of publications, which report on the creationism and or evolution controversy as well as providing resources for activists, which in this case are the teachers and other concerned parties....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

The Banning of the Last Meal for Condemned People in Texas

The following essay undertakes an analysis of the controversy behind the banning of the last meal for condemned people in Texas and a rhetorical analysis of Hennessey's and Hlavaty's articles on the subject.... Conventionally, as long as an inmate does not request alcohol or… In Texas, the controversy arose after and inmate by the name Lawrence Brewer who was sentenced to death for murder ordered a huge amount of food but on the day of the execution refused to eat it (Forsyth)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Analysis of Breastfeeding Baby Advertisement

nbsp; Teacher analysis of breastfeeding baby advertisement The advertisement created by Cheil Worldwide, an independent advertising agencywho came up with the ad to use during an awards gathering in South Korea created a controversy with the image they use.... hellip; According to the research findings, it can, therefore, be said that the image gathered controversy as well as praise due to the effective use of rhetorical devices of ethos, logos, and pathos.... In sum, the image gathered controversy as well as praise due to the effective use of rhetorical devices of ethos, logos and pathos....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Analysis of breastfeeding ad

The essay "analysis of breastfeeding ad" analyzes the Oreo cookies breastfeeding ad where it generated a lot of controversies.... Teacher analysis of breastfeeding ad The article that will be ed for analysis is Oreo cookies breastfeeding ad where it generated a lot of controversy.... The advertisement becomes very powerful because the image used the rhetorical tools of pathos, ethos, and logos effectively.... Logical appeal is logos in rhetorical tools that helps the message believable by making it consistent with reason and reality....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Should breastfeeding moms show nipples to the public

Ethos analysis Beyer Monica was justified in writing the article and brings the argument concerning showing nipples to the public during breastfeeding.... Pathos analysis Beyer Monica successfully brought ought the argument concerning displaying nipples to the public by women during breastfeeding.... Logos analysis Beyer Monica argument concerning exposing the nipple to the public during breastfeeding successfully became viral via the internet because of the use of reasoning and logic in persuading the reader....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Features of Mitt Romney's Faith Speech

The semantics used and the objective of the speech, therefore, require ideological criticism and we would be doing a critical analysis of the speech to find out the cause and effect of the text using rhetorical theory with cluster criticism.... This paper outlines rhetorical barriers, goals of the speaker, historical background, rhetorical strategies, special features, effectiveness, people's emotions, and respect....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Organizing GB's Information Services Department

The assignment "Organizing GB's Information Services Department" presents a message of the Director of Data management aiming to draw attention to the target audience to issues that have been ignored in the past to create in the organization a strategic basis for the new architectural changes and the introduction of push technology....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us