StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

What would you do - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The format that this paper will utilize is to first identify the scenario, then I will outline how I would react in the given scenario. This will be achieved…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
What would you do
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "What would you do"

What Would You Do? The purpose of this paper is to write a response to the question in the "What Would You Do?" given a certain situation. The formatthat this paper will utilize is to first identify the scenario, then I will outline how I would react in the given scenario. This will be achieved through first identifying the ethical issue, and then I will examine some externalities, view this situation under a number of ethical theories then explain my ultimate decision.The scenario involves me being relegated to the role of a civil servant that has to present a budget to the city council.

A friend had advised me that he had on occasion included a line item into his budget called a “Radio” item that would in essence make a lot of noise and attract attention but could be "unplugged" easily. He said that after the council focused all its attention on that item and it was finally removed, everything else would be approved with little question. The initial dilemma revolves around whether or not I would use some sort of ‘smoke and mirrors’ strategy to pass a budget that I personally believe to be sound.

Or do I prepare a budget to the best of my ability and let it come under exceptional scrutiny. What this translates to is that I could examine this scenario from either an egoist perspective in which I would act in accordance with what I personally believe is in my own self interest or if I should view this situation under a utilitarian perspective in which I should choose the solution that brings the greatest good to the greatest number of people. There are a number of externalities to consider in this situation.

One major concern is the decision making process of the town council. If it is the case that they are reasonable decision makers than it would be that I would possibly act differently if they are a group of vindictive or corrupt people. Secondly, special consideration must be made on the special conditions or items that I am placing in my own budget. For example, there may be a budget requirement that I believe is necessary for the effective running of a government bureau. If it is unlikely that a council will approve of this budgetary requirement, I may be persuaded to use some underhanded methods (Such as utilizing aggressive sales tactics) to educate the council of the benefits of this line item.

Special consideration must be afforded to the idea that there may be some regulatory board that oversees my actions and if I were to use a ‘Radio’ tactic it may be that there are some serious legal ramifications that need to be addressed. One final externality consideration would be the scenario in which somebody the committee approved the ‘radio’ expenditure. What this would translate to is a complete waste of taxpayer money on something controversial and potentially completely unnecessary.

The next major consideration would be to view this from a consequentiality ethical theory. If I were to examine this scenario using ethics of duties, I would operate under the assumption that all beings are rational and have respect for consistency, universality as well as respect for human dignity. Under this assumption it would be wildly inappropriate to use a ‘radio’ item in my budget. Using a virtue ethics perspective I would have to make sure that my main objective would be to shelter the taxpayers and the public from excessive government over expenditures.

With this information in hand I can now identify the decision that I will make. Ultimately I would not use some sort of ‘Radio’ strategy in effort to push though a budget. This decision was based on a number of factors. Firstly, if it is the case that I cannot convince my contemporaries that the true budget that I have proposed is not worthy of passing than perhaps I should reevaluate the entire proposal. However, if it is the case that the city council does not consist of reasonable people than from this perspective I would simply have to work harder to convince the council members that my budget is valid.

The next contributing factor that led me to make this decision is based on the fact that moralistically, the use of a ‘radio’ tactic represents a serious underhanded technique and as such pursing this action would be unfair to the public. Moreover, it can be the case that I could be called out on using this technique, which could have serious long tern negative repercussions for my credibility and reputation.One additional contributing factor for my decision is the consideration that as a civil servant I would want to bring the greatest good to the greatest number of people.

If I am not putting forward my most honest and best budget that I would theoretically be doing a great disservice to the public. Secondly as I highlighter earlier, it may be the case that the budget could go through with the ‘radio’ line item which would cost the public more money than is necessary.The final consideration for why I would make this decision is the fact that this action may represent only the beginning of a slippery slope of other city hall infractions. If I begin to use underhanded techniques like this with ease, it may be that I be willing to bribe officials, or misrepresent expenditures.

This represents a serious long terms risk to my credibility.In conclusion it is my belief that the best decision is to simply put my best work forward and to avoid using a radio strategy because even though it may be an easy technique of getting budget approved it may do a serious disservice to the public and could harm my credibility.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“What would you do Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1414379-what-would-you-do
(What Would You Do Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1414379-what-would-you-do.
“What Would You Do Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1414379-what-would-you-do.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What would you do

The Importance of Teamwork

what would you do differently in your own teaching as a result of this event?... What did you learn from this event about student learning?... What did you learn from this event about your own approach to teaching and learning?... What did you learn from this event about student learning?... I would very much want to apply this knowledge when attending to students, to help them be much more open and aware of other possibilities when analyzing or solving problems with no right or wrong answers....
20 Pages (5000 words) Assignment

Performance Management Through Benchmarking Simulation

Which two recommendations did you make to improve the equipment management process at LHAC Why Basing my decision on available information and advice of the staff, I decided that Nurses to Return Equipment and Equipment to be Terminal Cleaned as the best mix of processes to improve the medical management system.... what was the outcome Mr....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Best Parts of the Trip to Florida

Where would you go and what would you do?... We wanted to go somewhere what would you do if you were young and needed a break from living a mile high in Denver?... Where would you go and what would you do?... We wanted to go somewhere warm where there were lots of things to do.... What if you had some extra time and money?... Your answer may be different… you might even be persuaded to take a trip just like the one we took. My friend and I are both under 21 and needed a change of scenery....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

What If Someone Was Not Inspecting an Aircraft Properly

Same goes… As a manager, I would take these transgressions in a very strict way; I would call up the mechanic or the pilot and ask for an explanation within the what would you do if you knew someone was not inspecting an aircraft properly (a mechanic or pilot)?... How would you handle it as a manager?... As a co-worker, I would also do the same thing.... f someone is playing a foul whilst checking an airline, I would report this anomaly to a senior at the earliest....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Behavioral and Situational Rating During the Interview

When dealing with conflict, he should have also stated how he would convince others to solve contentious This shows that Baqer is capable of handling tasks that require quick decision making.... Baqer Alhashimdid's questions were well formulated and could have helped in evaluating how much the interviewee would be able to deal with situations that involved dealing with problems that involved teamwork as is always the case in most organizations....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

A Business Ethical Dilemma That I Came Across

On the other hand, if I had postponed the action, it would have seriously impacted the work of the organization I served for.... On the contrary, when I considered the possibilities ensuing out of ethical realism, I felt that since we live in an imperfect world, ignoring Tod's inefficiency would be a decision that will give way to minimal evil (Hartman 22)....
2 Pages (500 words) Admission/Application Essay

Private Trouble or Public Issue

In this case, people helped Stephanie, a Private Trouble and Public Issue al Affiliation) Private Trouble and Public Issue The video “Linda Hamilton- what would you do?... eferenceLinda Hamilton - what would you do?... ?? People will delay helping someone in trouble because they believe that the next person will do so.... ?? People will delay helping someone in trouble because they believe that the next person will do so.... It is evident that people would help the neatly dressed woman but ignored the homeless man due to their social wellbeing....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Model for Change in Business

OOD – I can recognize what the environment is and understand that there is a resistance to change from the manager.... This leads to pressure from the awareness of what might happen to my job if change doesn't occur.... The author of this assignment "Model for Change in Business" comments on his/her personal experience in change management....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us