StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Thomas Aquinas - Law, Morality and Politics - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Thomas Aquinas - Law, Morality and Politics" it is clear that many elements of the world view that underlie today`s political institutions and democratic practices are a result of a long chain of developments in the history of thought within the field of political philosophy. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
Thomas Aquinas - Law, Morality and Politics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Thomas Aquinas - Law, Morality and Politics"

Many elements of the world view that underlies todays political s and democratic practices are a result of a long chain of developments inhistory of thought within the field of the political philosophy. In this regard, Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274), one of the prominent Italian thinkers of the Middle Ages during which the ground was laid for the upcoming early modern period with its upsurge in political philosophy, presents a very indicative example when an issue that constitutes one of the most hotly debated political problems nowadays was equally important for this medieval philosopher. This critical issue revolves around the problem of human freedom, or lack of it, in the most general sense, and in a practical relation to the social organisation as well. Of course, we must be aware of the limitations inherent to attempts to compare attitudes towards such a complex philosophical problem between its modern interpretations and the views of almost a millennium ago, as even the revolutionary thinkers were embedded in the historical context of their time, with its dogmatic and world outlook influences. However, despite influences on Aquinas from the political climate of that time, we can perhaps find out the essence of his view on the mentioned problem that still would be relevant for our todays situation. Thomas Aquinas lived at a pivotal period for the Western philosophy when the return of the Aristotelianism combined with scholasticism to reignite debates about the correlation between reason and faith. Aquinas became fully acquainted with this school of philosophy after he joined the Dominican Order and for several years studied with Albertus Magnus (1193-1280), a scholastic philosopher who worked on restating of the Aristotelian heritage. This acquaintance of Aquinas is considered to be the most significant influence on his world view, which turned him into an erudite scholar devoted to the Aristotelian method (McInerny, 1992, p. 16). In general, Scholastics of that time promoted empiricism and voiced support for policies and doctrines of the Roman Catholic Church. They stood in opposition to Christian mysticism as well as to concepts of dualism of mind and of the evil nature of the world promoted earlier by Plato and St. Augustine (McGrade, 2003, pp. 33-34). What interests us in relation to the problem that we have raised is Aquinas' theory of natural law. To better understand this theory, it must be pointed out that Aquinas views philosophy as a general term which relates to a set of sciences. To diverse philosophical fields Aquinas ascribes the following due order for their study: logic, mathematics, natural philosophy, moral philosophy, and metaphysics, which is the apex of philosophical study. Aquinas' theory of natural law concerns moral philosophy, for which the notion of the human good is central. Aquinas sees a difference between acts of a man and human acts, as the former acts can be also seen in non-human agents, while human acts stem from knowledge and will and always aim at a known good. But Aquinas points out that as a certain good is not the same as the goodness itself, then what holds together all the human actions is what he terms as the overarching goodness which is the ultimate end. Therefore, any human action is directed towards the ultimate end (Lisska, 1998, pp. 132-133). Now that we have uncovered the basic ground of the morality for Aquinas, we can better understand his views towards what he called the natural law. In fact, what forms the essence of the natural law moral theory is the view that morality stems from the nature of the world and of the human beings. For Aquinas, main morality-generating principle of human nature is its rationality, for instance manifested in human pursuit of a certain good, which underlies any moral law. Therefore, as humans are born rational, it is morally right to behave in correspondence with our rational nature. In this way Aquinas connects moral laws with the human nature and this connection forms the basis of the "natural law", that now can be seen as the due involvement of humans in the postulated higher eternal law, which in its turn governs the nature of an eternal universe. Importantly, while the rest of finite creatures are such that their good lies in their unconscious fulfilment of their nature, a human being is conscious of the good and can freely pursue it. At the same time humans are not free to choose their good as such but are free only to choose whether to follow or not this true end. Building on this, Aquinas views the natural law as the basis for the main principles of practical reasoning. To exemplify what it means, he reminds about the basic elements of reasoning as such, when some concepts and judgements precede all others. Aquinas says that our basic concept is that of being, and that our basic judgement is that one cannot deny and confirm the same thing. All other concepts that we produce are specific examples of what exists. Already Aristotle has remarked that children tend to call all women mother and all men father, so that those terms become generic. This proves that we presuppose that what is generically described is an instance of being. Therefore, the concept of being is prior not because it is conceived independently from its particular manifestation, but because some concrete examples of being are perceived, which at least implies that something is existent. Similarly, our basic judgement of lack of inner contradiction is manifested in humans already in the very early age, so that it becomes embedded in all our other concrete judgements. Drawing parallels with such basic elements of thinking, Aquinas connects his understanding of the natural law with the practical realm, where there is also a basic concept represented by the good, akin to the concept of being in the theoretical realm. The good signifies that which is pursued as a source of fulfilment, so the first rational practical judgement becomes to pursue the good and to avoid evil. All other practical judgements emanate from this basic one and therefore contain it. The natural law, in its turn, consists of this basic judgement and some other most general judgements that cannot be disputed, and that form the natural human good to which we are inclined, like existence, food, family, etc. At this point we should mention that there is another aspect of the natural law theory which deals with the correlation between morality and law. From this point of view, there is no clear difference between norms of law and moral notions, and laws draw their authority not from some prior human agreement, but are logically related to natural moral norms. Simply put, some standards are obligatory because of their moral truthfulness, even though there is no particular convention that legitimised them. Such an idea of interdependence between notions of law and morality is also called the Overlap Thesis (Finnis, 1980, p.351). In this regard, Aquinas is also a law theorist, because for him laws, established within human societies, can be legitimate only if they correspond to the natural law. On the contrary, an unjust law is actually not a law. Such an idea that a norm that does not correspond to the natural law is not legitimate constitutes the basic ground of conceptual naturalism. Building on the mentioned aspects of Aquinas political philosophy, let us finally try to summarise how he allows for human freedom within his structure of law. From the philosophic point of view, Aquinas view of rationality as the part of our nature which we cannot freely choose, but which we can freely pursue can be classified as pertaining to compatibilism, a view that champions the lack of contradiction between the causal roots of human actions and elements of freedom in them, as long as an agent is not constrained in his pursuing of the goals he or she has set, even though unfreely. From the point of view of political philosophy, the sphere of philosophical interests of Aquinas can be related to the general distinguishing between negative and positive aspects of the term 'liberty'. In this light, negative liberty is considered to represent a mere absence of obstacles that would prevent an agent from an action (even if it is itself not a free one) and positive liberty requires the presence of control over ones own destiny and of ones own interests (MacCallum, 1967). Now, in this regard views of Aquinas can be associated with both approaches. He refers to negative liberty in his attitude to the human laws, which for him must not prevent people from being able to pursue the human good, the condition that underlies the norm of morality. On the other hand, in respect to human ability to choose whether to actually follow the good, Aquinas touches upon the field of concern of positive liberty theories. References: Aquinas, Thomas. On Law, Morality and Politics. Hackett Publishing Company, 1988. Finnis, John. Natural Law and Natural Rights. Oxford University Press, 1980. Lisska, Anthony J. Aquinas's Theory of Natural Law: An Analytical Reconstruction. Oxford University Press, 1998. MacCallum, Gerald C. Jr. "Negative and Positive Freedom." Philosophical Review, vol. 76 (1967): 312-34. McGrade, A. S. (Ed.). The Cambridge Companion to Medieval Philosophy. Cambridge University Press, 2003. McInerny, Ralph M. Aquinas on Human Action: A Theory of Practice. The Catholic University of America Press, 1992. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Politics Aquinas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Politics Aquinas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515543-politics-aquinas
(Politics Aquinas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Politics Aquinas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515543-politics-aquinas.
“Politics Aquinas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515543-politics-aquinas.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Thomas Aquinas - Law, Morality and Politics

Aquinas and Aristotle's Perspective on the American Government

thomas aquinas was a Roman Catholic priest and as an influential philosopher, he focused most of his writings on natural theology and in this respect wrote extensively on governance in view of theological values (Reagan, 36).... thomas aquinas observed that there are two types of governments, just and unjust.... This paper will analyze Aristotle and Aquinas view on the American style of governance and on allegations that the British occupation was unjust under the law of nature and God....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Saint Thomas Aquinas and his influence on Western thought

Name Instructor Course Date Saint thomas aquinas and his influence on Western thought St.... thomas aquinas is also referred to as Aquino, lived between 1225- 1274.... thomas aquinas left back great works that can never be forgotten.... One could only conclude that Aquino's existence was needed at this time when Catholic politics and the events in the world needed great intervention (Aquinas and Regan 73).... He was an Italian theologian as well as philosopher during the medieval era (Gilby and aquinas 5)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Greeks and Extra-Marital Sex

In other words, morality and religious issues have been virtually identical, but atheistic moral issues appeared in the late age of civilization.... thomas aquinas also argued about human resilience; thus, he provided the position on moral theory and flourishing.... Resilience and Christian Virtues: What the Psychosocial Sciences Offer for the Renewal of thomas aquinas' Moral Theology of Fortitude and Its Related Virtues.... The sexual morality has been influenced by varied religious convictions, and the influence was quite often indirect, restrained or concealed (Carmichael123)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

How Medieval Christian Thought Contrasts with Greek Philosophy

The paper "How Medieval Christian Thought Contrasts with Greek Philosophy" highlights that on the matter of discussed dualistic dichotomy the late antique and medieval Christian thought was in a constant, albeit equivocal, dialogue with the Greek philosophical heritage.... ... ... ... Many elements of modern Western world views are inherited from the Greco-Roman and late antique and medieval Christian philosophies....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Augustine and Aquinas Justifications of the Exercise of Social and Political Ruling

thomas aquinas as regards their political ideologies can be found within their respective works.... thomas aquinas was born in the early 13th century, of an affluent family, with direct blood lines to the ruling royal families of the day (Dyson, R.... thomas aquinas's Political Writings translated by R.... thomas aquinas's Political Writings ... thomas aquinas differs from Augustine, because Augustine was living the political upheaval of the day that involved, by allegation, and problem some complicity too, those events that brought down Rome....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Concept of Individual Liberty Development

He always preached goodness, morality and truthfulness on the one hand, and taught mathematics, logic, gymnastics and philosophy on the other.... thomas aquinas (1225--1274) has discussed free choice and individual liberty in his wonderful “Summa Theologiae.... International politics, international law, state organisations, social justice, equality, liberty and social movements also come into the fold of liberalism.... ??But since man is naturally a civic animal, as is proved in Aristotle's politics, hence a third order is necessary, whereby man is directed in relation to other men among whom he has to dwell....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Concepts Visions and Ethical Behavior

thomas aquinas Aristotle Discussion Works Cited David Hume David Hume is worthy from deviating from the rationally-focused philosophers that preceded him, and placed desire at the core of his human philosophy, being a member of the school of philosophy that has come to be known as Empiricism.... thomas aquinas ... thomas aquinas is a towering figure in western philosophy, and is credited with being able to undertake the marriage of the philosophy of Aristotle and Christianity in his groundbreaking work Summa Theologica....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

To What Degree Does Machiavelli Agree with Aquinas' Theory

thomas aquinas view on the nature of sin”.... It highlights Aquinas' ideas on nature of laws and their relationship to politics, his understanding of man's sinful nature and compares his ideas to those of Machiavelli.... This is therefore, a reflection of how the it is the nature of humans to be involved in sin even in the politics human beings participate.... number Aquinas complex on nature of law and their relationship to politics Aquinas was one of the most influentialtheologian with his philosophy and natural laws that reconstructed the aspect of sin....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us