StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Philadelphia Convention 1787 - Book Report/Review Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Philadelphia Convention 1787

A part of the book explains the importance of the Philadelphia convention of 1787 and the role it plays in the political history of US constitution. The book covers the whole of social history, particularly in terms of ethnicity. The book offers its readers a comprehensive and brief understanding of the journey undertaken by America which transformed the country of hunters and farmers to a mightiest industrial nation existing on this earth. Undoubtedly, it could be said that the Philadelphia convention that the way Murrin has portrayed Philadelphia convention is remarkable and it explains the on-goings of that time with a not-altogether-same perspective as the Collier's Decision in Philadelphia. (Powell's Books)
Both the books hold the Philadelphia convention of 1787 in high esteem and acknowledge its importance in the successful running of the American political system. The style of describing the whole period differs in both the books in two ways. Collier goes from describing one important event to another while Murrin's style in one of describing events in a chronological order. Secondly Murrin's book is written as in a manner of teaching and narrating while Collier's 'Decision in Philadelphia' actually is a discussion of the events with the students. The book 'Decision in Philadelphia' was published on the 200th anniversary of the Philadelphia convention and the author holds a great regard for the event. Consequently, the author's approach of the personalities, events and the convention itself is one where the book regards the convention reverence rather than depicting the true account. 'Liberty, Equality and Power' however narrates the history behind the convention considering both the negative and the positive sides of the picture. This could be seen from the fact that Collier in his description of anti-federalists like George Mason in which the author has painted a negative image in the reader's mind while displaying the nationalists and as patriotic and intellectual people. Murrin however adopts a neutral attitude in his description of events or people and he states the facts without confusing them with personal opinion though in a very interesting manner. Decision in Philadelphia engages more in elaborating the feelings and emotions of the people involved in drafting the Philadelphia convention, their endeavors, meetings and finally the constitution itself while on the other hand 'Liberty, Equality and Power' gives a third-person view on the whole situation rather than putting its focus on any one personality and event. The authors of 'Decision in Philadelphia' have somewhat given an underestimated view about the framers' commitment to the ideological notions of individual rights as well the state law. These issues are discussed in mild detail but their importance has been shadowed by the issues regarding the discussion of the politics of the Philadelphia convention. These details have been highlighted more to give an overview of the proceedings regarding the framing of the constitution. 'Liberty, Equality and Power', in contrast with 'Decision in Philadelphia' discuss these notions and ideologies in apt detail and regards these as ...Show more

Summary

Although the book was published some more than twenty years ago, Christopher and James Lincoln Collier's book still remains to be one of the most popular historical writing of a momentous moment in the avalanche of US political experience. The book describes the events and personalities related with the shaping of the constitution…
Author : hoppechad
Philadelphia Convention 1787 essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the book report/review on your topic
"Philadelphia Convention 1787"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

The Federalist book report
Hamilton, in the “Introduction” of the work, maintains, “After full experience of the insufficiency of the existing federal government, you are invited to deliberate upon a New Constitution for the United States of America. The subject speaks its own importance…” (Hamilton et al, 1) Therefore, it is fundamental to realize that the subject of the book is greatly relevant to the overall political thought in the United States of America as it deals with the ratification of the proposed U.S.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Book Analysis on The Frontier Against Slavery
Indeed, the South was devoted to agrarian plantation economy while the North had embraced industrialization, infrastructure growth and large influx of immigrants. As the South recognized its rights to protect slavery, while in the North, abolitionists believed that slavery was morally wrong rather than simply a social evil.
5 pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
Slavery and the Founders and Literty in the Age of Jefferson
As the paper stresses historians like to present events and characters as if they belong in one or other of these two polar opposites: either defenders of freedom and justice or defenders of the iniquities of slavery. The situation is considerably more complex than that, and the constitution is inextricably bound up in the ideology of slavery. 
8 pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review
Social Convention
Social convention has always demanded the periods of childhood and adolescence be a time of innocence and as such most parents attempt to shield their children from the harsher realities of life. A child who thinks or behaves like an adult, worries teachers and parents alike.
8 pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review
A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift. The French Revolution of 1789. Differences between Political Developments in Western Europe (France) and Eastern Europe (Russia)
The power games played between rival forces trying to topple each other effect commoners, who suffer the heaviest brunt and the stories of their lives shape the history. The book, A Modest Proposal, written by Jonathan Swift is an account of the conditions of the Irish people who were subjected to British hegemony during the 18th century, wherein these people were mistreated and deprived of their rights as human beings.
14 pages (3500 words) Book Report/Review
Slave Narratives of American Slaves
This paper seeks to discuss Olaudah Equiano, Frederick Douglass and Harriet Jacobs and their impact on slavery in the lights of broad and diverse academic resources. Olaudah Equiano is considered to be one of the most notable and popular Africans, who actively participated in the movement to abolish the slave trade.
7 pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review
Catherine Drinker's Miracle at Philadelphia
These, in turn, drew from classical and contemporary history and philosophy with which the more intellectual leaders in the colonies were intimately familiar One of the latest full-service entries in the history survey sweepstakes, American Passages is a beautiful text that is well-designed.
6 pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
Poems Comparison
There is no irony or sarcasm in this poem, when compared with the other two. Barbie Doll refers to the chilling stereotyping a young girl, growing up, is subject to. She is expected to conform to unrealistic standards of beauty and behavior, to become a pleasing, plastic, plaything, and forget her own individuality.
2 pages (500 words) Book Report/Review
The Federalist
elf, that it was Alexander Hamilton, an influential New York lawyer, who conceived the idea of the work as a series of newspaper essays with an intention of supporting the work of the Constitutional Convention which was held in Philadelphia in 1787. Hamilton, in the
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Critical Book Review - Slavery and the Founders , Race and Liberty in the Age of Jefferson 2nd edition by Paul Finkelman
In fact, as this book by Paul Finkelman is at pains to reveal, the situation is considerably more complex than that, and the constitution is inextricably bound up in the
8 pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation