StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Effects of Trade Protection Policies: Employment Context - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Effects of Trade Protection Policies: Employment Context

As an initial matter, it is important to define what is meant by trade protection policies. In general, trade protection policies are barriers to free trade. These types of policies may take the form of quotas, tariffs, or more sophisticated trade policies and laws. They are often enacted to protect specific industries from increasing imports and international competition. In the American context, from an historical point of view, the most protected industry has been the steel industry. Other industries which have lobbied for and received some benefits from trade protection policies are industries involved in textiles and automobiles. President Bush, a frequent proponent of free trade, was recently criticized for bowing to political interests and signing trade protection legislation in order to protect votes. More specifically, "Bush moved last year to protect steel manufacturers with large operations in political battleground states such as Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois and West Virginia by imposing three-year, 30 percent tariffs on foreign imported steel to protect an industry that employs more than 125,000 workers nationwide" (Powell, 2003: np). In short, the political influences are extraordinarily strong in the trade protection debate.
The question presented, however, is not wheth...
The answer is no. Economic studies demonstrate over and over again that trade protection policies do not save America jobs in the long run. There may be short term employment stabilization in a particular state or in a particular industry. These short-term employment benefits, however, rarely translate into longer term forms of stabilization. Indeed, there are tremendous costs associated with trade protection policies. In the steel context, for instance, protecting the steel industry results in across the board increases in steel prices for all other American companies using steel as a raw material. The short-term stabilization of jobs in one industry, in effect, results in employment threats to many more workers in other industries. As stated by Griswold, a leading American Commentator on trade protection policies,
Quotas and duties on imported steel will not "protect" U.S. industry. They will profit only one relatively small sector at the expense of others. Some of America's largest industries -- construction, industrial machinery, automobiles and durable goods -- swallow huge quantities of steel as an intermediate input to their final products. General Motors, General Electric and Caterpillar each buys more than 600,000 tons of steel a year. Higher steel prices will damage sales and profitability across a broad swath of the American economy, endangering jobs in industries that employ 40 times as many workers as does the domestic steel industry (The Government's no-win war: np).

The reality, therefore, is that trade protection policies, though politically popular, do not save jobs in the bigger American economy. There are other negative consequneces. American consumers, for instance, are compelled to pay higher prices for many ...Show more

Summary

This essay will examine the effects of trade protection policies on jobs. This is a difficult topic because there are many competing opinions; more particularly, these opinions are driven by a mixture of both political and economic considerations. To be sure, any policy affecting jobs is highly political in the United States…
Author : zernser
Effects of Trade Protection Policies: Employment Context essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Effects of Trade Protection Policies: Employment Context"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

The public sector is the sole remaining sector in which trade unions have influence in the employment relationship. Discuss th
These joint accords, in turn, are covered by judicial or conventional decrees which explain processes, causes and results. However, the rationality of these pacts does not merely represent judgments made by national institutions and economies. It also takes into account the social factors and the aggregation of decisions which constitute the systems of industrial relations.
18 pages (4500 words) Essay
Protection or Free Trade for International Trade
Protection or Free Trade for International Trade. The international trade policy of a country with other countries covers mainly import tariffs, import quotas, subsidies to local producers, and other administrative barriers. In a free trade system, the government does not put the importers at a disadvantage compared to the local producers whereas under a protectionist system, the government encourages local producers by having policies that discourage imports by influencing one or more of the levers of trade policy stated above.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Hospitality Management and Employment Relations
Trade union membership is low but in some countries collective agreements have been extended to cover all workers. Knowledge boundaries need extending to convey a view of employment relations that is not western-centric and drawn from 'Anglo' countries. Employment relations in the British hospitality workplaces are different on a national and private service sector comparison.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Free Trade and Protection
Till now the modalities and priorities of the international trade negotiations were primarily orchestrated by the developed world, led by the US and the Europe. However, the highlight of the negotiations held in July 2008 was the blatant refusal of the developing world voiced by India and China.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
International Trade and Competition Essay
One of the important issues is the controlling of rapid growth in trade deficit. Trade involves exchange of goods or services for cash or on credit. There are several other activities, which facilitate trade, and these alongwith trades are known as commercial activities.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Trade union density has undergone significant decline since 1979. Critically evaluate the reasons for this change in both the public and private sector during this period, and assess the likely effects of the recent downturn in the economy and the potenti
In the context of the global market business operating in various industries have to change their operational structure and priorities in order to meet the changing customer preferences and the strong competition; under these conditions,
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Employment relation
e gender, race, work and family life imbalance, insecurity arising from family and economic conditions, politics, migration and many more social problems are a part to get affected by the very changing nature of employment relations, Kalleberg (2009) in his article mentioned
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Critically assess the Role of Trade in Development
If an appropriate range of human resources and enough efficient producer services are available, even with minimal infrastructure many obstacles to economic efficiency
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Employment Relations
Employment relationship can also be regarded as one of the major aspects through which the employees can access their rights associated with employment practices (International Labour Organization, 2011). In most of the countries, it can be apparently observed
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Privacy protection policies

The author states that ethics in media is a complicated issue since it deals with various sensitive aspects of human life. Media ethics is based on a scope of philosophical standards such as fundamental Judeo-Christian qualities, Aristotle's values of virtue and  Kant's downright basic, Mill's guideline of utility, Rawls' cover of lack of awareness.

3 pages (750 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation