StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Comparison of equity and common law in the field of breach of a fiduciary duty in a trust - Essay Example

Extract of sample
Comparison of equity and common law in the field of breach of a fiduciary duty in a trust

In "Junior books v Veitchi (1983) 1 AC 520" recovery of economic loss was imposed as liability. And the elements for constituting negligence such as (a) A duty of care owed by the defendant to the plaintiff (b) A bleach of that duty by the defendant (c) consequential damage suffered by the plaintiff (d) Such damages caused by the bleach are formulated. (Peter de Cruz 320)
Equity is the Creation of Courts, it is innovative and it provides various quick remedies such as injunction, rescission, rectification and specific performance. Thus equity is not a separate law but it a supplement to the common law. Discretionary is common feature of equitable remedies. Equity has wider scope than the common law.
The common law does not look into the conduct of the parties what is required is the claim has to proved. Once the claim is proved the damages are awarded. The common remedy in common law is awarding of damages. In Common law the courts have limited discretionary functions compared to law of equity. (Terence Ingaman 442)
Common Law and equity is distinguished on concept of jurisdiction such as "Equitable property interest", "fiduciary obligation", "Unconsciousness" and "Proprietary remedies", which are the distinct concepts developed by the courts of chancery.

1. Equitable Property Interest.

Where the interest in the property is vested under the law of equity such as interest in trust property, the interest of the beneficiary over the property in trust is enforceable not only against the trustee but also against the third party who acquires such property. Therefore the beneficiary interest is conceived as proprietary. The beneficiary is at liberty to convert the beneficial interest into the absolute ownership interest at any point of time.

Where the interest in the property is vested under the Common law such as through transfer of property, the interest is absolute and the person can exercise such rights over the property for his sole lawful benefits. Where as in equity a trustee with equitable property right exercise his rights over the property for the benefit of the beneficiary and cannot exercised for his benefit. (Peter Cane 187)

2. Unconscionable Conduct:

Chancery courts are conscience. As discussed in earlier topic the liability under the common law is strict liability caused due to reasonable misconduct or tortuous act. The Chancery courts under the law of equity are liberal in granting the remedies extending to suspected conduct. Unconscionable act is related to the strict liability to fiduciary and the negligence is to the strict liability in tort. The common law provides remedies to those subjected to harm due to negligence of others where as the law of equity stretches further and provides the relief against the unfair advantage taken by the others. (Peter Cane 191)

3. Fiduciary obligations:

Fiduciary obligations are created in trust. The fiduciary in relation to the trust property must act for the benefit of the beneficiary but not for the benefit ...Show more

Summary

In the common law the tortuous liability was on nuisance, conversion and trespass. Now the House of Lords has expanded the scope of liability further. In Hedley Byrne v Heller (1964) AC 465 the liability was extended from physical to the economic loss, in this it was held that if economic loss is caused due the negligent misstatement by a person who owe a duty of care to the plaintiff, if he voluntarily assume responsibility…
Author : mohamed76
Comparison of equity and common law in the field of breach of a fiduciary duty in a trust essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Comparison of equity and common law in the field of breach of a fiduciary duty in a trust"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Law of Equity & Trust
At that time, the affected parties have the prerogative to file petition to the Crown. The appeals of the appellants were handed over to Lord Chancellor. Those who have read Charles Dickens’s Bleak House know that by the 18th Century, equity had become obsolete.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Equity and Trust Law Essay
f in a position where his interest and duty conflict.5 Aside from putting the two rules together, the ruling in Bray also speaks to the strict application of the rule by using the word “inflexible”. The inflexibility of the rule suggest that in discretionary trusts, the trustee may be less inclined to exercise a reasonable discretion for fear of accusations or claims that he or she made a profit or placed himself or herself in a position where there was a conflict of duty and interest.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Equity and trust law
In many cases, unclear trusts established by deceased people leaves the court to use its wisdom, based on the scarce available information to determine who should get the disputed estate or how the people conflicting on the discounted Intestate Estate should share the estate.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Common law and Equity
The common law will be applied only where it is impossible to choose between the parties to the litigation in accordance with the principle that where there is equal equity, the law shall prevail. Therefore, in a situation in which there is no clear distinction to be drawn between parties as to which of them has the better claim in equity, the common law principle which best fits the case is applied (Hudson, 2004, p.9).
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Equity and Trust Law
If the legal rules did not provide a solution to the problems, it was possible to petition the Crown. The origins of jurisdiction have brought in the principles of equity that could now be applied to every civil court in the land. According to some judicial interpretations, trusts are one of the greatest inventions of equity so such definitions would not make any fundamental distinction between trusts and equity and would consider trust as a branch of equity.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Equity and Trust Law Essay
This legislation established a unified Supreme Court of Judicature, effectively fusing the administration of equity and common law. The need for ongoing creativity by equity was recognised after the Judicature Acts 1873-75 came into force: I intentionally say modern rules, because it must not be forgotten that the rules of Courts of Equity are not like the rules of the Common Law, supposed to have been established from time immemorial.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
EQUITY AND TRUST Critically examine the contribution made by the trust to the following area of law Unauthorised profits made by a fiduciary
1 The concept of trusts arises from imparting rights to third parties on the lands of England landowners to be immune from creditors while having the benefits of ownership. This helped in taking shape of concept of trust in the time of nonexistence of feudal concerns and when there is a chance of having wealth in many other forms other than land.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Equity and trust law
As stated by Tony Blair, “the current law is unclear, has not evolved in a way which best meets the needs of contemporary communities and does not reflect the diversity of organizations which operate for the public benefit.”1 Thus, while
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Trust & equity law
In an attempt to define the scope of charities, the court in the case of Commissioners for Special Purposes of the Income Tax v. Pemsel (1891)3, tried to set a definition of
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Equity And Trust Law Assignment
It is this to which Lord Diplock made the greatest contributions in his legal career; and in particular, to the debate over equity’s
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation