StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Rockefeller Drug Laws - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Rockefeller Drug Laws

The year 1973 was marked by the Watergate scandal, an uneasy cease-fire in Vietnam, and a rising tide of the counter-culture. Fuelling the resentment of public institutions and the mistrust of the government was the proliferation of drug use by a new generation. To many conservatives, it appeared as though the liberal left had won and the seeds of permissiveness were never more apparent than they were in the drug culture in New York. Conservatives, such as Nelson Rockefeller, fought back with legislation that was aimed at this cultural group, and targeted drug use as a common denominator to identify his political and social enemies. New York State became the front lines in the War on Drugs with the passing of strict anti-drug laws that would become to be known as the Rockefeller Drug Laws. According to Haberman, "Their essence was to send drug felons to prison for very long stretches, with sentences made mandatory and leniency rendered unacceptable even for first-time offenders". The right wing hawks had lost the war and resigned the White House, but they were not in a mind to lose the War on Drugs.
At the heart of the Rockefeller Laws were sentencing guidelines that placed an emphasis on retributive incarceration, and eliminated any possibility of restorative justice. The laws, in many cases, called for mandatory sentencing that could be as long as life in prison with no possibility of parole. As an example, in 1999 a middle-aged mother was sentenced to life in prison for the possession of a small quantity of cocaine, even though she was a first time offender and was working for a larger organization (Papa). This experience has been repeated thousands of times in New York where the penalty for delivering drugs is on the same level as that for second-degree murder. In addition to the lengthy sentences there are the "mandatory sentencing regulations that effectively tie the hands of presiding judges" (Irwin 6). The law has preset the sentence and judges are not able to consider extenuating circumstances such as the possibility of rehabilitation or the social situation of the defendant. The ability of a judge to gauge the sentence is a hallmark of modern justice and is one of the basic functions of the court. However, under the Rockefeller Laws, this function has been usurped by the legislators, and left the judge as little more than a figurehead.
The Rockefeller Drug Laws have been criticized since their enactment, but were only recently reformed as protests grew louder. Since the passing of the laws conservatives have opposed the laws because they significantly altered the role of the judge in sentencing, and were unduly harsh. Concerned citizens argued that the mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years for the possession of a small amount of drugs was far out of proportion to the crime, and was comparable to the sentence guidelines for rape, manslaughter, and robbery (Rhett 6). Human rights watch groups pointed to the abuse by police, prosecutors, and courts as a reaction to clean up the streets and satisfy the public's thirst for a get tough on crime policy. However, these were non-violent victimless crimes, and getting the drug user off the streets only provided a marginal amount of safety for the public. Reasonable taxpayers objected to ...Show more

Summary

There is an old saying among criminals that says 'if you can't do the time, then don't do the crime'. The drug laws signed by Governor Nelson Rockefeller in 1973 put drug criminals on notice that he was serious about the prison time that would be incurred for using, manufacturing, or selling drugs in New York…
Author : rogahnmallie
Rockefeller Drug Laws essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Rockefeller Drug Laws"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Criminal justice
What issues are most prominent with regard to staffing and stress related environments of correction, and office burnout? How do the court decisions affect the shift supervisor in the jail facility, and what would the reaction be if he expressed his opinion regarding the administration and inmate population?
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Research Paper
Some of the challenges arising from overpopulation in prisons include being costly and most individuals are finding harsh penalties as an ineffective way of rehabilitating individuals therefore criticizing the laws. Among the concerns is that non-violent drug-related offenses should be dealt with in a different manner as compared to the present requirements of the law.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Drug Legislation
Drug abuse is on the rise and alongside is drug related crime. Reflecting critically I can see that a plan was needed to fight the war on drugs and shape service provision. I believe that is why the government responded to the resounding pressure and in April 1998 the government ordered a ten year strategy for tackling drug misuse.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Prison Expansion
(Warren 5). At the beginning of 2008 there were 2.3 million people incarcerated in the United States. This is out of an estimated population of 301,139,947 (using 2007 census data), or to say it another way, roughly one in every 99 people in the United States is behind bars (Ibid.).
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Sentencing
criminal punishment. One window into the scope of change since 1970 is supplied by raw statistics. In 1970, on any given day, the nation's prisons housed a reported 196,429 offenders. Jail populations added approximately 129,189 inmates, so that the U.S.
27 pages (6750 words) Essay
Longer sentences offer no more guarantee of reducing criminal propensities than do shorter terms (The effectiveness of sentencing, Home Office Resea
criminal punishment. One window into the scope of change since 1970 is supplied by raw statistics. In 1970, on any given day, the nations prisons housed a reported 196,429 offenders. Jail populations added
20 pages (5000 words) Essay
Individual freedon(see instruction below)
Therefore, this issue has to be controlled and deals with by the state and federal authorities. For this report, I picked the issue of drug abuse. It is relevant not only to
3 pages (750 words) Essay
5 page in depth essay on any topic of criminal justice system of New York
the number of prisoners dropped 7.4% - from 72,899 to 67,534 and the trend continues in the years following although the percentage slightly lessened. (Jacobson 58) The continuous drop in prison population New York highlights several important aspects in the state’s criminal
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Environmental laws
However, we believe that the laws are helpful to people, animals and pollution. Some of the existing environmental laws were formulated with the aim of ensuring that humans live in a habitable environment. This is true for example for the Clean Water Act of
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Drug Abuse / Drug Addiction
buse as well as addiction, and at the same time looks at the aspects of epidemiology, social problems, pathophysiology, as well as ethical issues that might arise with medical emergency responders. Drug abuse and drug addiction; exactly what does that imply and who is affected
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation