Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Ethics - Essay Example

High school
Pages 2 (502 words)
Download 0


There are many criteria of personhood like when an entity is considered as a person at stage of unity of ovum and sperm, embryo, fetus, or newborn stage. Author has summarized views of some philosophers in relate to personhood. …

Extract of sample

Fletcher (1972), a philosopher and ethicist, proposed positive and negative criteria for personhood, but he did not suggest that one must fulfill all these criteria to be a person. Positive criteria’s are minimal intelligence, self awareness, self control, a sense of time, sense of futurity, sense of past memory, capability to relate to others, concern for others, communication, curiosity, change and changeability, idiosyncrasy and neocortical function. Negative criteria are antitechnology, essentially sexual, a bundle of rights and compelled to worship.
Singer (1972) believed that it should be morally permissible to kill disabled newborns that lack capability of becoming sentient. If communication ability remains a criteria for personhood then apes should have moral state of person and new born should not due to lack of capability to communicate. Tooley (1983) believed that use of language is critical to personhood and support aborting infant and killing newborn who has or is at risk of having disability. Englehardt (1975) exclude newborn as person based on self concept as critical criteria to personhood and newborn lacks self concept. Richard McCormick (1974), a priest and catholic theologian, also support withholding life sustaining treatment from infant who are ‘abnormal’ and unlikely to develop human relations.
If newborn lacks the cognitive ability to think, reason and plan and will likely never to develop them then philosophers suggest it permissible to take life. These arguments are primarily to maximize utility of invested resources and investing resources for cognitively impaired or at risk of impairment is unwise because it does not maximize utility.
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related Essays

After deciding I wanted to commit myself abroad, I decided to enroll in the Paris Summer Program. I felt that this program would offer me a hand on opportunity for me to further enhance and test my control of the French language in real life experience, something that could only be achieved by working overseas. I also knew that this would also help me complete the requirements of my French major. Beside just this, I would also become integrated and introduced to a new and exciting culture, as well as the different ideas and thought patterns of the French people. I feel this is invaluable…
2 pages (502 words)
Abortion and Personhood
Wade1 which based its landmark decision not on the issue of personhood, but rather on the viability of the fetus outside of the womb. This decision affirmed the legality of abortion without the need to establish or define personhood. Although highly controversial, the Roe decision, specifically, and the abortion debate, in general, continues to be one of the most significant issues, both from a theological and a moral perspective.When examining the use of the concept of personhood from an ethical standpoint, Gibson2 points out traditionally the debate surrounding abortion is, in actuality, a…
4 pages (1004 words)
Abortion: when is it morally right or wrong to end the life of a fetus?
Of all the issues that have invited controversy over the years, the moral debate regarding the right to end a fetus' life has easily been one of the most divisive and tempestuous. The very fact that a human life is involved makes it all the more sensitive.The whole debates stems from the single issue- at what stage does a fetus actually become alive. If one was to speak in purely biological terms, life is created the moment conception takes place between the male and female gametes. But it is way more complicated than that. The development of the fetus within the womb is an extremely…
4 pages (1004 words)
Philosophy The concept of the person
St Thomas connects the concepts of legal rights, "complete individual intellectual nature" (Clarke, 26-7) and adds the importance of 'acts of existence', to create an ideal of the person as self-possessing. It is important to note that the Christian concept of the person, as described by St Thomas, includes that of 'rights': the idea of personhood as dependant upon legal rights.…
2 pages (502 words)