StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Leung Tsang Hung and Lee Wai Yu v. The Incorporated owners of Kwok Wing House, HKSAR FACV42007 - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Leung Tsang Hung and Lee Wai Yu v. The Incorporated owners of Kwok Wing House, HKSAR FACV42007

Madam Liu died and it was found that the 15 lbs. triangular piece of concrete came from Kwok Wing House and fell from Flat A on the 11th floor and it formed the corner of a concrete canopy which is projecting out from over the enclosed balcony of the flat, before it had been detached and fallen down into the street ("Case Alert: Case 2 (FACV4/2007)," 2008; and "Leung Tsang Hung and Lee Wai Yu v. Incorporated Owners of Kwok Wing House FACV4/2007," 2007).
The tenant as well as the incorporated owners was sued in negligence and public nuisance. And they were held liable for the case. The First Instance Judge as well as the Court of Appeal had dismissed the claim against the Incorporated Owners ("Case Alert: Case 2 (FACV4/2007)," 2008).
The Court of Final Appeal handed down the decision on the case on October 26, 2007 and the case has clearly laid down the responsibilities as well as liabilities of the incorporated owners in relation to common areas and illegal structures of the building. They were also held responsible for the Death of Madam Liu.
In August 1999, Madam Liu was plying her trade as a hawker in Tung Choi Street, when she met was struck by a falling piece of concrete coming from adjacent building, known as Kwok Wing House and as a consequence, she died. ...
e decision on the case on October 26, 2007 and the case has clearly laid down the responsibilities as well as liabilities of the incorporated owners in relation to common areas and illegal structures of the building. They were also held responsible for the Death of Madam Liu.
3. Facts
A. Factual events leading up to the case
In August 1999, Madam Liu was plying her trade as a hawker in Tung Choi Street, when she met was struck by a falling piece of concrete coming from adjacent building, known as Kwok Wing House and as a consequence, she died. That piece of concrete fell from Flat A on the 11th floor of the said building, which formed a corner of a concrete canopy projecting out from the enclosed balcony of the flat. Tenant of the flat and incorporated owners were sued in negligence and public nuisance. The tenant and owners of the flat were held liable, however, the first Instance Judge and Court of Appeal had dismissed the claim against the Incorporated Owners so, the plaintiffs appealed to the Court of Final Appeal ("Case Alert: Case 2 (FACV4/2007).

Accident's Cause
There was a canopy protruding from outer wall of the premises on top of the building to which someone added the extended canopy and converted the open balcony beneath as part of the covered space inside the premises. From that extended canopy the fatal concrete fragment fell. No evidence found when was the extended canopy erected and who was responsible for it and it could have been erected in 1964, soon after occupation permit was issued and before the sale of the said premise to its first owner. Investigation report of Building Authorities implies that the extended canopy was cast against the approved canopy with roughened joint however, connecting steel reinforcement and spanned between the ...Show more

Summary

This is an accident that caused death of Madam Liu wherein not only the owner/occupier as well as the tenant of the illegal structure, but also the incorporated owners of the Kwok Wing House was held liable ("Leung Tsang Hung and Lee Wai Yu v. Incorporated Owners of Kwok Wing House FACV4/2007," 2007).
Author : toygiovanna
Leung Tsang Hung and Lee Wai Yu v. The Incorporated owners of Kwok Wing House, HKSAR FACV42007 essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Leung Tsang Hung and Lee Wai Yu v. The Incorporated owners of Kwok Wing House, HKSAR FACV42007"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

APPLE INCORPORATED
From the research it can be comprehended that although the company has adequate resources and capabilities to deal with the issues it might lack in few context. For instance, in order to deal with the issues related to complexity, the company has talented team members who can manage the complexities in the near future.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Lee Morgan
Morgan’s music genre was Jazz; his styles were Trumpet Jazz, Jazz Instrument, and hard bop and the instruments he played were the Trumpet, and flugelhorn. He was the '60s’ finest and among hard bops’ greatest trumpeters of that time. In 1963, the trumpeter returned to New York where he recorded The Sidewinder which.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Yu Minhong: A Chinese Entrepreneur
According to the paper a country’s prosperity depends largely upon the entrepreneurship prevailing in the country. This is the reason that the governments all around the world strive to develop and creates opportunities and conditions for entrepreneurs to flourish so that these entrepreneurs make progress in the best interest of their respective nations and increase the competitiveness in the business world.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Won Kar-wai
Influenced by the French New Wave, bent through the prism of Hong Kong cinema, his is a stylish and unique vision. "Wong belongs to the mid-1980s Second New Wave of Hong Kong filmmakers who continued to develop the innovative and fresh aesthetic initiated by the original New Wave (Wright 2002)".
11 pages (2750 words) Essay
Far Right Wing Politics
(Weinberg, 2003) Fascism is also characterized by social stratification along these crucial variables, especially in the UK where it is identified by the establishment it gained over the last 50 years following by the growing influence of less education, those holding negative views of the EU and, indirectly, among rural dwellers which are increasingly becoming determined of Right Wing by perceived vision of race, culture, ethnicity and religion.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Lee Miller
She captured not only the image but the feeling of it as well. Albeit a clich, she brought the images to life and breathed the soul into each of her photographs. She described her life as "a water-soaked jig-saw puzzle, drunken bits that don't match in shape or design."1 Her eventful, exciting life would make a great movie.
13 pages (3250 words) Essay
West Wing Episodes Discussion
The West Wing, is a television series, created by writer Aaron Sorkin, that is a dramatic depiction of the workings of the United States government through the eyes of chief White House staff.  In Episode 95 of The West Wing, “Separation of Powers”, The Bartlett Administration wants the frail, elderly Chief Justice of the Supreme Court
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Handgun owners
fter arguing that carrying a concealed hand gun makes one safer when confronted by a thug, the paper moves on to discussing concealed carry laws (without directly relating those to safety), before moving on to arguing that people who carry concealed weapons with permits are law abiding (again, not directly related to safety).
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Lan Yu
Later focus will be on the acceptance of LTGB by the society in China. I agree with the opinion that gay couples go through similar challenges as those faced by the opposite gender couples. Gay couples
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Barbara Grutter v. Lee Bollinger
Hence, such are prohibited. The fact that Pohoski did not read this policy cannot be used to deny her, her rights. It is very clear that, most of the time Faust Senior could utter such sexually harsh words to Pohoski
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation