StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Civilian Contractors on the Battlefield - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Civilian Contractors on the Battlefield

The following discussion is going to explore the ethical problems, whilst defining the actual position of a civilian contractor on the battlefield. Also it will consider the security problems in depending on civilian personnel, because there interest is in the monetary value of their service rather than the loyalty and security of a nation4. Therefore this may jeopardize the security of battle planning, because if civilian contractors are working on a business level then if the opposition offered a better business deal then these civilian contractors become a breach in the US military strategy5.
In the first place the role of the civilian contractor can be seen as military personal as the Hague Convention of 1907 allows that other persons can be combatant in a time of war than just military personnel. Therefore under the Geneva Convention these individuals will be afforded the protections as prisoners of war. This means that on the ethical grounds of using contractors on the battlefield, governments such as the USA can legitimately affirm their use. In essence under the Hague Convention and the Geneva Convention these individuals are in fact quasi-military, i.e. ...
ercenaries.7 British Human Rights lawyer Helen Kennedy has illustrated that there is vast problems with the USA naming freedom fighters, armed guerrillas who are not part of a state army as terrorists in order to punish them through vengeance ethically and a breach of humanitarian law.
We [the UK] should not be tempted to take the American route There should never be a direct role for victims in punishment. If victims have a direct say in sentencing decisions, how will consistency be achieved between the victim bent on vengeance and the person willing to forgive8
The actions of the US authorities in Guantanamo Bay are an example of a nation of victims having a say in the punishment of possibly innocent people and these victims have no objectivity and mass cruelty and torture is happening. This is happening of civilians that have taken up arms to protect themselves and named terrorists. How does the US government legitimize civilian contractors who are getting paid for there services on one hand, but not freedom fighters on the other The distinction does not make legal or ethical sense, because morally a freedom fighter has a better argument for their actions and to become a war prisoner protected under the Geneva Convention than does the civilian contractor.9
Finally, the security issues that the uses of civilian contractors raise are vast. In the first instance is a contractor is being highly paid there are business reasons for their use on the battlefield.10 Therefore is it not conceivably possible that if the contractor is offered a higher price on the opposition, the needs of the business and money outweigh loyalty Secondly, there is the possibility that there will be infiltration by the opposition through the use of civilian contractors; especially in the case ...Show more

Summary

The ethical and political ramifications of having civilians on the field could be severe, especially in light of the Geneva Conventions when in a time of war non-military personnel should be kept out of harms way1. Yet, in a time of war it has been the policy of the US government to use civilian contractors…
Author : mallie86
Civilian Contractors on the Battlefield essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Civilian Contractors on the Battlefield"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Civilian employment with the US army in Germany
2,358 of the local population of Grafenwoehr are employed with the USAG Grafenwoehr. The population of the Garrison comprises 9162 military personnel, 5,098 training troops (hailing from NATO and US units).
11 pages (2750 words) Essay
The construction Firm: contractors and subcontractors
In times of serious economic recession, it is common on the part of most UK-based construction companies who failed to diversify and create strong business alliances in other countries to experience a temporary setback with regards to its construction projects.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Military Service vs Civilian Employment
..3 Education befits……........................................................................................................3 Travelling………………………………………………………………………………..4 Housing benefits....
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
The EU should have remained a civilian power. Discuss
The view of European Union (EU) being a civilian power has gained significant considerations and this has certainly led to animated deliberations since its inception, whereby often the concept of civilian power has been used to define and designate the role of EU as an actor in the international politics.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Understanding project contractors and contracting businesses
The two firms that have been chosen are Midas Retail Limited and Rock Fall Company Limited based in the United Kingdom whose primary line of operations includes construction and drilling. These companies have been chosen on the basis of a particular ratio which is turnover to total assets ratio.
13 pages (3250 words) Essay
Civilians On The Battlefield
There are many challenges with civilians on the battlefield; however, increased use of civilians has changed the face of combat for the military because Global War on Terror (GWOT) has advocated an increasing number of civilians on the nonlinear battlefield.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Fire-fighters - DOD and Civilian Certified
Fires occur accidentally or due to natural phenomenon and can come in a range of severity and may require different skill sets in different circumstances. Fires and other emergencies take a toll of thousands of lives and destroy property worth billions of dollars every year (Education-Portal).
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Love is like a Battlefield
“Battlefield,” throughout the whole duration of the song, tells a story of difficult times in love where two lovers who were once so in love are now battling one another and are endlessly fighting and arguing which brings feelings of
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Military Service vs Civilian Employment
However, the military employment entails more responsibility than civilian employment. There is a risk of taking part in combat operation which is dangerous to ones life. Military is a profession that a member must be on time for work, there are no excuses for lateness and
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Tracking Civilian Deaths in Afghanistan
Whereas it is true that there are differing shades of bias and that Ms. representation of data is oftentimes done without a malicious intent, or indeed without any intent at all, the article in question provides the reader with a core example of the d n which truthful numbers can be displayed and inferred from incorrectly.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation